Correlates of life course physical activity in participants of the Baltimore longitudinal study of aging

Ann Zenobia Moore, Eleanor M. Simonsick, Bennett A. Landman, Jennifer A. Schrack, Amal A. Wanigatunga, Luigi FerrucciAging 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel "Life Course Physical Activity" (LCPA) metric derived from retrospective self-reports, demonstrating that a person's physical activity history across decades, not just their current activity level, is independently associated with better health outcomes, including improved body composition and physical performance, and reduced multimorbidity. This highlights the cumulative benefits of sustained physical activity throughout life.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the benefits of physical activity for health and longevity are well-established, most research focuses on current activity levels. This overlooks the potential cumulative impact of physical activity patterns over an entire lifetime. It's unclear how much past activity contributes to current health, especially since individuals' activity levels can change significantly over decades due to lifestyle, health, or environmental factors. This paper aims to quantify the impact of a person's entire physical activity history, from adolescence to older age, on various health indicators, independent of their current activity.

Methods

The researchers developed a brief questionnaire to capture participants' self-reported physical activity levels (minimal, light, moderate, intense) in each decade of their lives, starting from adolescence. This data was used to create a "Life Course Physical Activity" (LCPA) score. The LCPA score was derived by ranking participants based on their reported activity levels across decades, prioritizing more recent activity.

They then used this LCPA score in multivariable linear regression models to assess its association with various health outcomes, including:

  • Body Composition: Measured using CT scans for abdominal fat (subcutaneous and visceral) and thigh muscle area and density.
  • Physical Performance: Assessed through measures like peak VO2, usual gait speed, and the Health ABC Physical Performance Battery.
  • Clinical Characteristics: Including fasting glucose, fasting insulin, HDL, triglycerides, and multimorbidity (a count of various chronic conditions).

Crucially, these analyses were adjusted for current physical activity levels (measured by both questionnaires and accelerometers) and other demographic factors (age, sex, race, education, smoking status) to isolate the independent effect of LCPA.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging (BLSA), a long-running cohort study of community-dwelling adults. The primary dataset for this analysis included 690 participants who provided data for the physical activity history questionnaire and had data for current physical activity estimates and key covariates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cumulative Benefit of Activity: The LCPA metric suggests that the duration and consistency of physical activity over a lifetime, not just peak intensity or recent engagement, significantly contribute to health.
  • Independent Predictor: LCPA emerged as a significant predictor of health outcomes even after accounting for current physical activity levels, indicating that past activity has a lasting, independent effect.
  • Beyond Current Snapshot: Relying solely on current activity might underestimate the health benefits derived from a lifetime of consistent engagement, or conversely, overestimate the impact of recent changes in activity.
  • Practicality of LCPA: The brief questionnaire approach to derive LCPA is feasible for large-scale studies, offering a way to capture a crucial life-course exposure that is often overlooked.

Key Results

  • Independent Associations: LCPA was significantly associated with numerous health markers, independent of current physical activity. These included:
  • Positive Associations: Higher peak VO2, higher HDL, higher hemoglobin, greater thigh muscle area and density, and faster usual gait speed.
  • Negative Associations: Lower fasting glucose, lower fasting insulin, lower abdominal subcutaneous fat, lower visceral fat, and lower multimorbidity.
  • Magnitude of Effect: A one standard deviation increase in LCPA was associated with a 1.95 cm² increase in thigh muscle area and a 0.03 m/s increase in gait speed.
  • Consistency with Trajectories: The LCPA ranking showed a good correlation with estimated physical activity trajectories derived from longitudinal accelerometer and questionnaire data, suggesting it captures a meaningful pattern of activity over time.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Specificity: The BLSA cohort is unique and may not be representative of the general US adult population, limiting generalizability.
  • Retrospective Reporting: The LCPA relies on self-reported past activity, which is subject to recall bias and potential misclassification, especially for distant decades. The study notes that the reliability of recalled activity attenuated over time.
  • Broad Categories: The activity categories in the questionnaire were broad, and the wording might not capture all forms of incidental activity, leading to potential imprecision.
  • Reverse Causation: For outcomes like lower multimorbidity, it's possible that individuals who were healthier were more able to be physically active, rather than activity directly causing lower multimorbidity.

Future work could involve developing more refined methods for capturing life-course physical activity, perhaps integrating objective measures where possible or using more detailed recall techniques. Further research could also explore the specific biological mechanisms through which long-term physical activity confers these lasting benefits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Physical activity is consistently associated with better health and longer life spans. However, the extent to which length and intensity of exercise across the life course impact health outcomes relative to current activity is undefined. Participants of the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging were asked to categorize their level of physical activity in each decade of life from adolescence to the current decade. In linear mixed effects models, self-reported past levels of physical activity were significantly associated with activity assessed at study visits in the corresponding decade of life either by questionnaire or accelerometry. A pattern of life course physical activity (LCPA) derived by ranking participants on reported activity intensity across multiple decades was consistent with the trajectories of activity estimated from standard physical activity questionnaires assessed at prior study visits. In multivariable linear regression models LCPA was associated with clinical characteristics, measures of body composition and indicators of physical performance independent of current physical activity. After adjustment for minutes of high intensity exercise, LCPA remained significantly associated with peak VO<sub>2</sub>, fasting glucose, thigh muscle area and density, abdominal subcutaneous fat, usual gait speed, lower extremity performance, and multimorbidity (all p < 0.01) at the index visit. The observed associations suggest that an estimate of physical activity across decades provides complementary information to information on current activity and reemphasizes the importance of consistently engaging in physical activity over the life course.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moore2024correlates,
  author = {Ann Zenobia Moore and Eleanor M. Simonsick and Bennett A. Landman and Jennifer A. Schrack and Amal A. Wanigatunga and Luigi Ferrucci},
  title = {{Correlates of life course physical activity in participants of the Baltimore longitudinal study of aging}},
  booktitle = {Aging},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1111/acel.14078},
}
Figure