Correlated topological flat bands in rhombohedral graphite

Hong‐Yun Zhang, Qian Li, Michael G. Scheer, R.z. Wang, Chuyi Tuo, Nianlong Zou, Wanying Chen, Jiaheng Li, Xuanxi Cai, Changhua Bao, Ming-Rui Li, Ke Deng, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Mao Ye, Peizhe Tang, Yong Xu, Pu Yu, J. Ávila, Pavel Dudin, Jonathan D. Denlinger, Hong Yao, Biao Lian, Wenhui Duan, Shuyun ZhouProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have experimentally observed topological flat bands on the surface of rhombohedral graphite (RG). These bands, protected by bulk topological features, exhibit unique splitting and bandwidth changes upon electron doping, suggesting strong electron-electron correlation effects are at play. This discovery positions RG as a promising new platform for exploring the interplay of topology, correlation, and emergent quantum phenomena.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quest for novel quantum materials hinges on understanding and controlling exotic electronic states. Two particularly exciting areas are "flat bands," where electrons have very little kinetic energy, making them highly susceptible to interactions, and "topological physics," where materials possess robust electronic properties protected by their underlying band structure. Rhombohedral graphite (RG), with its unique ABC stacking, has been theoretically predicted to host both these features simultaneously. However, experimental verification and a deeper understanding of how these properties manifest and interact, especially in the presence of electron-electron correlations, have been lacking. This paper aims to bridge this gap by experimentally demonstrating topological flat bands in bulk RG and investigating their behavior under doping, shedding light on the role of correlations.

Methods

The researchers employed Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES), a powerful technique that probes the electronic band structure of materials by measuring the kinetic energy and momentum of emitted electrons. They utilized micrometer or nanometer scale beam size (MicroARPES or NanoARPES) to achieve high spatial resolution, allowing them to focus on specific regions of the RG sample. To understand the doping-induced changes, they performed in situ electron doping, a process where electrons are intentionally added to the material, altering its electronic properties. Complementary to the experimental work, self-consistent Hartree-Fock (HF) calculations were performed to theoretically model the electronic structure and investigate the role of electron-electron interactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements on synthesized rhombohedral graphite samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • RG as a Topological Playground: The experimental confirmation of topological flat bands (TFBs) on the surface of bulk RG, protected by bulk helical Dirac nodal lines (DNLs), establishes RG as a tangible platform for studying these exotic phenomena.
  • Doping-Induced Splitting and Correlation Signature: The observed splitting of the TFBs upon electron doping, with a dramatic increase in the bandwidth of the lower band and the pinning of the upper band near the Fermi level, is a strong indicator of significant electron-electron correlation effects.
  • Beyond Mean-Field: While Hartree-Fock calculations capture some aspects of the doping evolution, the inability to fully explain the pinned upper band suggests that correlation effects beyond the mean-field approximation are crucial for a complete understanding.
  • Bulk-Boundary Correspondence in Action: The TFBs are shown to arise directly from the bulk topological properties (helical DNLs), providing a clear experimental demonstration of the bulk-boundary correspondence principle.

Key Results

  • Experimental Observation of TFBs: ARPES measurements clearly show weakly dispersing topological flat bands near the K and K' points of the Brillouin zone in rhombohedral graphite.
  • Bulk Helical Dirac Nodal Lines: The presence of bulk helical Dirac nodal lines was also experimentally confirmed, which are responsible for protecting the surface TFBs.
  • Exotic Doping Evolution: Upon electron doping, the surface TFBs split into two bands. The lower band's bandwidth increases by an order of magnitude, while the upper band remains pinned near the Fermi level.
  • Hartree-Fock Agreement and Disagreement: HF calculations reproduce the splitting and the bandwidth increase of the lower band, but struggle to explain the pinned upper band, highlighting the importance of stronger correlation effects.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their Hartree-Fock calculations, a mean-field theory, do not fully capture the complex correlation effects responsible for the pinning of the upper band near the Fermi level. They speculate that these effects might be related to phenomena seen in other correlated systems like twisted bilayer graphene, such as topological Kondo models.

Future work could focus on:

  • Developing more advanced theoretical models: To fully understand the pinned upper band, theoretical approaches that go beyond mean-field theory, such as dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) or quantum Monte Carlo methods, might be necessary.
  • Exploring other doping regimes: Investigating the effects of hole doping or different types of dopants could reveal further exotic behaviors of the TFBs.
  • Investigating other emergent phenomena: The unique combination of topology and flat bands in RG makes it a prime candidate for exploring other interaction-driven phenomena like superconductivity or magnetism.
  • Probing different RG thicknesses and structures: While this study focuses on bulk RG, exploring thinner flakes or different stacking orders could uncover new topological and correlated states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Flat bands and nontrivial topological physics are two important topics of condensed matter physics. With a unique stacking configuration analogous to the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model, rhombohedral graphite (RG) is a potential candidate for realizing both flat bands and nontrivial topological physics. Here, we report experimental evidence of topological flat bands (TFBs) on the surface of bulk RG, which are topologically protected by bulk helical Dirac nodal lines via the bulk-boundary correspondence. Moreover, upon in situ electron doping, the surface TFBs show a splitting with exotic doping evolution, with an order-of-magnitude increase in the bandwidth of the lower split band, and pinning of the upper band near the Fermi level. These experimental observations together with Hartree-Fock calculations suggest that correlation effects are important in this system. Our results demonstrate RG as a platform for investigating the rich interplay between nontrivial band topology, correlation effects, and interaction-driven symmetry-broken states.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024correlated,
  author = {Hong‐Yun Zhang and Qian Li and Michael G. Scheer and R.Z. Wang and Chuyi Tuo and Nianlong Zou and Wanying Chen and Jiaheng Li and Xuanxi Cai and Changhua Bao and Ming-Rui Li and Ke Deng and Kenji Watanabe and Takashi Taniguchi and Mao Ye and Peizhe Tang and Yong Xu and Pu Yu and J. Ávila and Pavel Dudin and Jonathan D. Denlinger and Hong Yao and Biao Lian and Wenhui Duan and Shuyun Zhou},
  title = {{Correlated topological flat bands in rhombohedral graphite}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2410714121},
}
Figure