Correction to "Wafer-Level Vacuum-Packaged High-Performance AlN-on-SOI Piezoelectric Resonator for Sub-100-MHz Oscillator Applications"

Guoqiang Wu, Jinghui Xu, Xiaolin Zhang, Nan Wang, Danlei Yan, Jayce Lay Keng Lim, Yao Zhu, Wei Li, Yuandong GuIEEE Trans. Industrial Electronics 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

This document provides formal corrections to the 2018 publication regarding AlN-on-SOI piezoelectric resonators. The updates address typographical errors in equipment model numbers and frequency units for phase noise and jitter measurements, ensuring technical accuracy and reproducibility for future research in timing components.

Introduction

In the field of high-precision microelectronics, sub-100-MHz oscillators serve as the fundamental timing reference for complex systems. The original research focused on the development of a Wafer-Level Vacuum-Packaged AlN-on-SOI (Aluminum Nitride on Silicon-on-Insulator) Piezoelectric Resonator. These devices utilize vacuum packaging to maintain a high Quality factor ($Q$) by minimizing air damping, which is essential for stable frequency generation. However, several typographical errors in the original manuscript necessitated this formal correction to maintain the integrity of the reported data.

Technical Corrections

The erratum addresses four specific technical points to ensure the experimental setup and results are correctly documented.

Instrumentation and Measurement Offsets

The original paper misidentified the primary measurement tool. The authors have clarified that a Keysight E4990A impedance analyzer was used for characterization, rather than the previously cited "E4490A." Additionally, the offset frequencies for phase noise measurements were corrected to standard units: 1 kHz, 10 kHz, 100 kHz, and 1 MHz.

Jitter Integration Bandwidth

One of the most critical corrections involves the reported RMS jitter. The original text stated a jitter value of 2.02 ps (rms) integrated over a range of "12 to 10 MHz." This has been corrected to 12 kHz to 10 MHz.

The correction notice clarifies technical specifications and equipment used in the original 2018 publication.

Significance of the Updates

In the context of frequency control and timing standards, the integration bandwidth of 12 kHz to 10 MHz (or 20 MHz) is the industry benchmark for calculating RMS jitter in telecommunications protocols like SONET. By correcting the lower bound from "12" (ambiguous or MHz) to 12 kHz, the authors confirm that the resonator's performance meets standard industrial requirements. These corrections ensure that the high-performance metrics claimed are properly contextualized and reproducible by other researchers in the MEMS field.

Conclusion

While the fundamental findings of the original research remain sound, these corrections are necessary for technical precision. The update highlights the importance of rigorous reporting of units and equipment models in micro-electromechanical systems (MEMS) literature to facilitate accurate benchmarking and technology transfer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Presents corrections to the above named paper.
BibTeX
@article{wu2020correction,
  author = {Guoqiang Wu and Jinghui Xu and Xiaolin Zhang and Nan Wang and Danlei Yan and Jayce Lay Keng Lim and Yao Zhu and Wei Li and Yuandong Gu},
  title = {{Correction to "Wafer-Level Vacuum-Packaged High-Performance AlN-on-SOI Piezoelectric Resonator for Sub-100-MHz Oscillator Applications"}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Industrial Electronics},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=_bx50mLLKrO},
}
Figure