Correction to: Intersection bodies of polytopes

Katalin Berlow, Marie-Charlotte Brandenburg, Chiara Meroni, Isabelle ShankarBeiträge 2022 · DOI

This document is a formal correction to the research paper "Intersection bodies of polytopes," originally published in Beiträge zur Algebra und Geometrie. It addresses a specific algebraic error that propagated through several formulas and examples in the original work.

TL;DR

This correction fixes a scaling error in the fundamental formula for the radial function of intersection bodies of polytopes. While the original paper's qualitative conclusions and geometric figures remain valid, the authors provide the corrected algebraic expressions and polynomial coefficients for several complex geometric examples.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The original research aimed to provide precise algebraic descriptions of the boundaries of "intersection bodies" of polytopes. An intersection body is a geometric object derived from a star body (like a polytope) where the distance from the origin in a given direction is determined by the volume of the central hyperplane section perpendicular to that direction.

The authors discovered that the proof of Theorem 2.6 in the original article contained a mistake in the constant factor of the radial function $\rho_{IP}(u)$. Specifically, a factor of $\frac{1}{d!}$ was used where $\frac{1}{(d-1)!}$ was mathematically required (where $d$ is the dimension). This error affected subsequent proofs, algorithms, and the specific polynomial equations used to describe the boundaries in the paper's examples.

Methods

The authors re-evaluated the mathematical derivations for the radial function and the algebraic boundaries. By replacing the incorrect scaling factor, they re-calculated the specific polynomials that define the boundary of the intersection bodies for various polytopes. The methods involve:

  • Convex Geometry: Analyzing the intersection of hyperplanes with polyhedral cones.
  • Algebraic Geometry: Expressing the volumes of these intersections as piecewise polynomial functions (radial functions).
  • Symbolic Computation: Generating the corrected, high-degree polynomials that describe the boundary surfaces in specific regions of space.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical mathematics paper, it relies on geometric proofs and algebraic derivations rather than external datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scaling vs. Structure: The most important takeaway is that the error was a constant scaling factor ($d$). Because the error was a constant, the degrees of the polynomials and the qualitative shapes of the intersection bodies described in the original paper remain correct.
  • Robustness of Visuals: The authors explicitly note that the figures in the original paper do not need to be changed. This suggests that the visual representations captured the correct geometric behavior, even if the underlying equations had incorrect coefficients.
  • Complexity of Algebraic Boundaries: The corrected examples highlight just how complex these boundaries are. For instance, in Example 5.10, the boundary is defined by a sextic (degree-6) polynomial with dozens of terms involving square roots of integers (e.g., $\sqrt{5}$).

Key Results

The correction provides the exact, updated formulas for several key examples:

  • Formula Correction: The radial function $\rho_{IP}(u) = \sum_{j \in J} \frac{1}{d!} |\det(M_j(u))|$ is corrected to $\rho_{IP}(u) = \sum_{j \in J} \frac{1}{(d-1)!} |\det(M_j(u))|$.
  • Example 2.8: Provides corrected radial functions for 24 different regions, including expressions like $\rho(x, y, z) = \frac{2(x^2 + 2xy + y^2 + 2xz + z^2)}{xyz}$.
  • Example 5.10: Lists a massive degree-5 polynomial for regions spanned by five rays and a complex sextic polynomial for regions spanned by three rays.
  • Example 6.2: Provides a corrected quartic (degree-4) polynomial for a four-variable case ($w, x, y, z$).

Limitations and Future Work

Not discussed in the paper. As a correction notice, the scope is strictly limited to fixing the identified mathematical errors in the previously published work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{berlow2022correction,
  author = {Katalin Berlow and Marie-Charlotte Brandenburg and Chiara Meroni and Isabelle Shankar},
  title = {{Correction to: Intersection bodies of polytopes}},
  booktitle = {Beiträge},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s13366-022-00638-y},
}

Loading related content...

Figure