Correction: Time to Organize the Bioinformatics Resourceome

Nicola Cannata, Emanuela Merelli, Russ B. AltmanPLoS 2006 · DOI

Abstract

The initial steps toward a bioinformatics resourceome are clear. First, an overall ontology with the high-level concepts (algorithms, databases, organizations, papers, people, etc.) must be created, with a set of standard attributes and a standard set of relations between these concepts (e.g., people publish papers, papers describe algorithms or databases, organizations house people, etc.). The initial ontology should be compact and built for distributed collaborative extension. Second, a mechanism for people to extend this ontology with subconcepts in order to describe their own resources should be designed. The precise location of a tool within a taxonomy is not critical—the author will place it somewhere based on the location of similar/competing resources or based on a best-informed guess. Others may create links to the resource from other appropriate locations in the taxonomy in order to ensure that competing interpretations of the appropriate conceptual location for the resource are accommodated. Third, the formats for the ontologies and the resource descriptions should be published so enterprising software engineers can create interfaces for surfing, searching, and viewing the resources. The resulting distributed system of resource descriptions would be extensible, robust, and useful to the entire biomedical research community.

Introduction: The Discovery Crisis in Bioinformatics

Bioinformatics is currently experiencing a period of unprecedented growth, yet this success has created a significant discovery crisis. Researchers are generating computational tools and databases at a rate that outpaces the community's ability to track them. This has resulted in several critical gaps:

  • The Discovery Gap: Biologists lack a comprehensive index for finding specific algorithms.
  • The Literature Gap: Scientific papers provide only a static snapshot of a tool, often leading to "404" errors as links break over time.
  • The Search Gap: General search engines often fail to distinguish functional tools from unrelated academic mentions.
  • The Curation Gap: Manual, grassroots lists struggle to maintain currency as the field scales.

The Resourceome Framework

To address these challenges, we propose the creation of a "resourceome"—a standardized, machine-readable ontology and distributed registry. This framework treats the entirety of bioinformatics resources as a single, explicitly characterized entity, analogous to the genome or proteome.

Conceptualizing the Resourceome as a web of interconnected biological resources.

The implementation of the resourceome involves three strategic steps:

  1. Core Ontology Development: Establishing a high-level hierarchy of concepts (algorithms, databases, organizations, etc.) and their relationships.
  2. Distributed Extension: Allowing tool creators to classify their own resources, ensuring the system scales alongside the field.
  3. Open Formats for "Killer Apps": Encouraging the development of sophisticated search and navigation interfaces by publishing standard ontology formats.

Key Insights and Community Models

A central tenet of this proposal is that centralized curation is unsustainable. Instead, a distributed model leveraging the expertise of the community is required. We suggest adopting a "peer-review" or rating system, similar to the Amazon model, to highlight reliable resources.

The role of Open Access in fostering a distributed, community-driven resource registry.

The success of such an initiative depends on community mobilization. Organizations like the International Society for Computational Biology (ISCB) and open-access publishers play a critical role in establishing the necessary infrastructure and incentives for researchers to participate in this shared ecosystem.

Challenges and Future Work

Several hurdles remain, including the "Killer App" problem—the need for user-friendly tools that mask underlying ontological complexity. Additionally, maintaining the currency of metadata and preventing link rot requires ongoing commitment from funding agencies and the scientific community. While previous attempts at large-scale knowledge representation have faced adoption issues due to complexity, a compact, extensible ontology built for collaboration offers a more robust path forward.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cannata2006correction,
  author = {Nicola Cannata and Emanuela Merelli and Russ B. Altman},
  title = {{Correction: Time to Organize the Bioinformatics Resourceome}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.0020020},
}
Figure