Correction of exciton binding energy in monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides

Zi‐Wu Wang, Yao Xiao, Weiping Li, Runze Li, Zhi‐Qing LiarXiv 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We theoretically investigate the corrections of exciton binding energy in monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) due to the exciton-optical phonon coupling in the Fröhlich interaction model by using the linear operator combined Lee-Low-Pines variational method. We not only consider the excitons couple with the intrinsic longitudinal optical (LO) phonon modes, but also the surface optical (SO) phonon modes induced by the polar substrates underneath the TMDs. We find that exciton binding energies are corrected on a large scale due to these exciton-optical phonon couplings. We discuss the dependences of exciton binding energy on the cut-off wave vector of optical phonon modes, the polarization parameters of materials, and the interlayer distance between the polar substrates and TMDs. These results provide potential explanations for the divergence of the exciton binding energy between experiment and theory in TMDs.

Introduction: The Theoretical-Experimental Gap

In the field of monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) such as $MoS_2$, $MoSe_2$, $WS_2$, and $WSe_2$, excitons—bound states of an electron and a hole—exhibit remarkable stability. Due to the reduced dimensionality and weakened dielectric screening in these one-atom-thick materials, their exciton binding energies are exceptionally high, typically ranging from 0.5 to 1.0 eV. This stability makes them ideal for next-generation optoelectronic applications.

However, a persistent challenge has been the significant discrepancy between theoretical predictions and experimental measurements. Standard hydrogenic models and even sophisticated first-principles calculations often overestimate binding energies compared to experimental data. This gap suggests that a critical physical mechanism has been omitted from previous models. This research identifies the Fröhlich interaction—the coupling between charge carriers and the polar vibrations (optical phonons) of the crystal lattice—as the missing link, specifically accounting for both internal vibrations and those originating from the underlying substrate.

Theoretical Framework: The Fröhlich Interaction

The authors employ a theoretical framework based on the Fröhlich interaction model to calculate corrections to the exciton binding energy. The core of their approach is the Lee-Low-Pines (LLP) variational method combined with linear operators.

Key features of the methodology include:

  • Dual Phonon Coupling: The model accounts for both intrinsic Longitudinal Optical (LO) phonons within the TMD layer and Surface Optical (SO) phonons induced by the polar substrate (e.g., $SiO_2$, $HfO_2$, $ZrO_2$).
  • Unitary Transformations: LLP transformations are used to simplify the complex Hamiltonian, allowing for a solvable description of the relative motion of the electron-hole pair.
  • Variational Calculation: By minimizing the energy functional, the researchers determine the magnitude of the binding energy shift caused by these phonon interactions.

Key Insights: Substrate Effects and Proximity

A central finding of the study is that the substrate is not a passive component. The "Surface Optical" phonons from the substrate are a dominant factor in correcting the binding energy. The degree of correction depends heavily on the polarity of the substrate and the distance between the TMD and the substrate surface ($z_0$).

Figure 3: Exciton binding energy dependence on substrate type and distance.

As shown in the figure above, more polar substrates like $ZrO_2$ and $HfO_2$ induce much larger corrections than less polar materials like $h-BN$. Furthermore, the influence of these SO phonons decays rapidly with distance. When the TMD layer is separated from the substrate by more than ~3 nm, the SO phonon effect becomes negligible, and the internal LO phonons become the primary source of correction. This proximity effect offers a mechanism for "tuning" excitonic properties through precise control of the interlayer distance or substrate choice.

Key Results: Quantifying Phonon Corrections

The research demonstrates that exciton-phonon coupling can lower binding energies by tens to hundreds of meV, effectively bridging the gap between theory and experiment.

Figure 4: Breakdown of LO and SO phonon contributions to binding energy correction in MoS2/SiO2.

For a $MoS_2$ layer on a $SiO_2$ substrate, the model quantifies the impact of different phonon modes. At a typical distance of 0.5 nm, the uncorrected binding energy of approximately 810 meV drops to roughly 660 meV when both LO and SO phonons are accounted for. The coupling is strongest with long-wavelength phonons (small wave-vectors $k_c$), confirming that macroscopic lattice polarization is the primary disruptor of the exciton's electrostatic binding.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work provides a robust theoretical explanation for the observed exciton binding energies in TMDs by incorporating the Fröhlich interaction with both intrinsic and substrate-induced phonons. While the model successfully uses a modified hydrogenic wave function, future work could refine this by addressing the "non-hydrogenic" Rydberg series observed in high-precision experiments. Additionally, integrating this phonon coupling model with simultaneous treatments of electronic screening in complex van der Waals heterostructures remains a promising avenue for further research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We theoretically investigate the corrections of exciton binding energy in monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) due to the exciton-optical phonon coupling in the Fr$\ddot{o}$hlich interaction model by using the linear operator combined Lee-Low-Pines variational method. We not only consider the excitons couple with the intrinsic longitudinal optical (LO) phonon modes, but also the surface optical phonon modes that induced by the polar substrates underneath the TMDs. We find that exciton binding energies are corrected in a large scale due to these exciton-optical phonon couplings. We discuss the dependences of exciton binding energy on the cut-off wave vector of optical phonon modes, the polarization parameters of materials and the interlayer distance between the polar substrates and TMDs. These results provide potential explanations for the divergence of the exciton binding energy between experiment and theory in TMDs.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2017correction,
  author = {Zi‐Wu Wang and Yao Xiao and Weiping Li and Runze Li and Zhi‐Qing Li},
  title = {{Correction of exciton binding energy in monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1701.00559},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.00559},
}
Figure