Correct and Certify: A New Approach to Self-Supervised 3D-Object Perception

Rajat Talak, Lisa Peng, Luca CarlonearXiv 2022 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces C-3PO, a novel framework for certifiable 3D object pose estimation. It provides not only a pose estimate but also a guarantee of its correctness using two new certificates: "observable correctness" and "non-degeneracy." This framework enables a powerful self-supervised training approach that significantly improves performance, especially in challenging scenarios with occlusions and sim-to-real gaps.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robots need to accurately estimate the pose (position and orientation) of objects to interact with their environment. Traditional methods often struggle with partial or noisy 3D data (like point clouds from depth sensors) due to occlusions. Furthermore, even when a pose is estimated, there's no reliable way to know if it's actually correct, especially for learning-based models. This lack of trustworthiness is a major hurdle for deploying robots in safety-critical applications. Existing approaches offer statistical guarantees or focus only on certifying the final optimization step, not the entire perception pipeline. This paper tackles the problem of providing provable correctness guarantees for end-to-end object pose estimation from partial point clouds, and doing so in a self-supervised manner to overcome the limitations of large, annotated datasets and sim-to-real discrepancies.

Methods

The core of the paper is the C-3PO (Certifiable 3D POse) model. It builds upon a standard semantic-keypoint-based pose estimation pipeline (KeyPO). The key innovations are:

  • General Theory of Certification: The authors introduce the concept of "$\zeta$-correctness," which defines a pose estimate as correct if it's within a certain distance ($\zeta$) of the ground truth. They propose two certificates to check this:
  • Observable Correctness: Checks if the model's output is consistent with the input data and prior knowledge (e.g., object shape).
  • Non-Degeneracy: Assesses if the input data is sufficient to uniquely determine the object's pose, crucial for handling ambiguous inputs (like highly occluded objects).
  • Keypoint Corrector: A novel module that takes the initial, potentially erroneous, detected semantic keypoints and refines them. This is implemented as a differentiable optimization layer, allowing it to be trained end-to-end and correct significant detection errors, bridging the sim-to-real gap.
  • Certificate-based Self-Supervised Training: The certificates are used to create a supervisory signal for training. The model is trained only on input-output pairs that are deemed "observably correct" by the certificate. This allows the model to learn from real-world data without explicit pose annotations, progressively improving its accuracy and trustworthiness.

Datasets

  • ShapeNet: Used for generating synthetic depth point clouds for training and testing.
  • YCB Dataset: A real-world dataset of household objects with RGB-D images, used for evaluating performance on real data and demonstrating the sim-to-real gap bridging.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Certification is Key to Trustworthiness: The paper argues that for robots to operate safely, we need more than just accurate predictions; we need provable guarantees. Their certification framework provides this.
  • Observable Correctness + Non-Degeneracy = Certifiable Correctness: The combination of these two certificates is shown to be sufficient for guaranteeing $\zeta$-correctness, a significant theoretical contribution.
  • Keypoint Correction is More Powerful than Pose Refinement: The keypoint corrector, by directly refining keypoint locations, proves more effective at handling large errors and bridging the sim-to-real gap than traditional pose refinement methods like ICP.
  • Certification Enables Effective Self-Supervision: The ability to identify "correct" outputs via certificates is the crucial enabler for training robust models on unlabeled real-world data, a major step towards scalable robot perception.
  • Semantic Keypoints Remain Relevant: Despite trends towards other methods, the paper demonstrates that well-chosen semantic keypoints, when combined with their corrector and certification, still offer state-of-the-art performance, especially in challenging scenarios.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: C-3PO significantly outperforms existing baselines, including methods like DeepGMR and PointNetLK, especially in challenging scenarios with occlusions and large pose variations. For instance, on the ShapeNet dataset, C-3PO achieves performance close to the fully supervised baseline (KeyPO real).
  • Effective Error Correction: The keypoint corrector module demonstrably improves pose estimation accuracy and reduces error variance, particularly for "observably correct" instances.
  • Successful Self-Supervised Training: The self-supervised training approach, guided by certificates, successfully bridges the sim-to-real gap, leading to models that perform well on real-world data even when trained on synthetic data. The percentage of observably correct instances approaches 100% during training.
  • Handling Degeneracy: The non-degeneracy certificate effectively filters out ambiguous cases, significantly improving performance on objects prone to degeneracy (e.g., caps, mugs). For example, for the "mug" object, applying both certificates improves ADD-S scores from 68.00% to 100.00%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hand-crafted Indicator Sets: The non-degeneracy certificate currently relies on hand-crafted indicator sets of keypoints. The authors suggest that implementing a learning-based model to automatically discover these indicator sets would be a valuable future direction.
  • Generalization of Certification: While the theory of certification is general, its application to other perception problems beyond pose estimation is an open area for future research.
  • Automatic Tuning of $\epsilon_{oc}$: The parameter $\epsilon_{oc}$ for observable correctness is crucial for self-supervised training. The authors suggest that automatic tuning of this parameter based on training progress could be explored.
  • Category-Level Keypoint Discovery: Extending C-3PO to solve category-level object pose estimation without requiring hand-annotated semantic keypoints (e.g., through self-supervised discovery) is another promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a certifiable object pose estimation problem, where -- given a partial point cloud of an object -- the goal is to not only estimate the object pose, but also to provide a certificate of correctness for the resulting estimate. Our first contribution is a general theory of certification for end-to-end perception models. In particular, we introduce the notion of $\zeta$-correctness, which bounds the distance between an estimate and the ground truth. We show that $\zeta$-correctness can be assessed by implementing two certificates: (i) a certificate of observable correctness, that asserts if the model output is consistent with the input data and prior information, (ii) a certificate of non-degeneracy, that asserts whether the input data is sufficient to compute a unique estimate. Our second contribution is to apply this theory and design a new learning-based certifiable pose estimator. We propose C-3PO, a semantic-keypoint-based pose estimation model, augmented with the two certificates, to solve the certifiable pose estimation problem. C-3PO also includes a keypoint corrector, implemented as a differentiable optimization layer, that can correct large detection errors (e.g. due to the sim-to-real gap). Our third contribution is a novel self-supervised training approach that uses our certificate of observable correctness to provide the supervisory signal to C-3PO during training. In it, the model trains only on the observably correct input-output pairs, in each training iteration. As training progresses, we see that the observably correct input-output pairs grow, eventually reaching near 100% in many cases. Our experiments show that (i) standard semantic-keypoint-based methods outperform more recent alternatives, (ii) C-3PO further improves performance and significantly outperforms all the baselines, and (iii) C-3PO's certificates are able to discern correct pose estimates.
BibTeX
@misc{talak2022correct,
  author = {Rajat Talak and Lisa Peng and Luca Carlone},
  title = {{Correct and Certify: A New Approach to Self-Supervised 3D-Object Perception}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.11215},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.11215},
}
Figure