CORESIDING WITH PARENTS, SON PREFERENCE, AND WOMEN’S DESIRE FOR ADDITIONAL CHILDREN IN VIETNAM

Yen T. Nguyen, Truc Ngoc Hoang Dang, Brian Buh, Isabella Buber‐Ennser2023 · DOI

Abstract

Due to strong filial piety, parents(-in-law) play an important role in their adult daughters’ fertility decisions in Vietnam; women feel pressured to fulfil their duties to produce a male descendant for the family. However, rapid urbanisation and industrialisation mean that multigenerational households are becoming less common, despite having been the standard household structure for centuries. Based on the 2020–21 Vietnam Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, we investigate if women who coreside with the parental generation are more likely to desire additional children. In an industrialised economy, grandparents may be an important source of childcare while simultaneously exerting pressure on their adult children to have additional children. Further, we explore the association of the sex of previous child(ren) to capture the pressure associated with son preference. Multivariate regressions reveal an association between coresiding with parents and the desire for a second child, regardless of the sex of the first child. Among women with two children, third-child desires do not appear to be associated with coresiding with parents but are substantially related to having two daughters. Given the strong two-child norm in Vietnam and previous policies implying negative consequences for parents with three or more children, few women show a desire for a third child. Those women who report a desire for a third child mostly have two daughters, reflecting societal norms about the need for a male heir.

Introduction

Vietnam presents a unique demographic case study. For two decades, the country has maintained a stable total fertility rate (TFR) near the replacement level of 2.0. This stability persists despite rapid industrialization and urbanization, which typically drive fertility rates downward. Central to this dynamic is the tension between modern economic shifts and enduring Confucian values, particularly filial piety and the preference for male heirs. As Vietnam navigates these changes, the traditional multigenerational household is becoming less common, raising questions about how living arrangements influence reproductive choices.

The "Coresidence Effect"

Historically, the presence of grandparents in the home has been a cornerstone of Vietnamese family life. In a modern context, this "coresidence" can influence fertility through two primary mechanisms. First, grandparents often provide low-cost, high-trust childcare, creating a "pro-fertility" environment that eases the burden on working parents. Second, they may exert traditional social pressure on their adult children to expand the family, ensuring the continuation of the lineage.

This research explores whether living with parents or parents-in-law encourages higher fertility desires and how this effect interacts with the sex of existing children.

Methodology and Data

The study utilizes data from the 2020–21 Vietnam Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS), a nationally representative dataset covering all six economic regions and major urban centers like Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City. The final analytic sample consisted of 4,401 married women aged 15–44, categorized by their current number of children (parity).

Researchers employed multivariate logistic regression to isolate the effects of coresidence and child sex while controlling for socio-demographic factors such as age, education, economic region, and urban/rural residence. A stepwise hierarchical approach was used to measure how model fit improved as different layers of socio-economic data were integrated.

Key Findings: The Second Child vs. The Third Child

The research reveals a distinct shift in motivations as families grow, highlighting the transition from general family expansion to the specific pursuit of a male heir.

The Second Child Threshold

For women with only one child, coresidence is a significant predictor of wanting another. The analysis showed a positive association (coefficient of 0.324) between living with parents and the desire for a second child. Interestingly, at this stage, the sex of the first child does not significantly impact the decision. This suggests that the desire to reach a two-child family is a near-universal goal in Vietnam, supported by the practical and social benefits of a multigenerational household.

The Power of the Two-Child Norm

There is a dramatic drop-off in fertility desire after the second child. While 78.5% of women with one child desire another, that figure plummets to just 11.3% for those who already have two children. This indicates that the "two-child family" has become the definitive social standard, likely reinforced by decades of government policy and shifting economic realities.

Son Preference as a "Tie-Breaker"

While coresidence does not appear to drive the desire for a third child, the sex composition of the existing children becomes the primary motivator. Women with two daughters are significantly more likely to desire a third child than those with at least one son (carrying a massive coefficient of 1.514). In this context, son preference acts as the primary driver for breaking the established two-child norm.

Socio-Economic Influences

Beyond family structure, several other factors play a role in shaping fertility desires:

  • Age: Fertility desires decline sharply with age, with women in the 35–44 age group significantly less likely to want more children (coefficients of -1.284 for parity 1 and -1.792 for parity 2).
  • Urbanicity: Women in urban areas are less likely to desire a second child (coefficient -0.486) compared to their rural counterparts, likely due to higher living costs and different social pressures.
  • Education and Region: Higher education levels and residence in less economically developed regions, such as the Northern Midlands, were associated with a higher desire for a second child.

Limitations and Conclusion

While the study provides strong evidence for the roles of coresidence and son preference, it faces limitations. The survey does not explicitly measure the intensity of grandparental pressure or the exact amount of childcare provided. Additionally, the data reflects only the woman's perspective, omitting the potentially influential views of husbands and parents-in-law. Furthermore, the study cannot account for the role of sex-selective abortion, which may influence observed sex ratios.

In conclusion, while Vietnam's "two-child norm" is deeply entrenched, traditional family structures and values continue to shape the path to that norm. Coresidence facilitates the transition to a second child, but only the persistent cultural need for a male heir is strong enough to push a significant minority of families toward a third. Future research using longitudinal data or qualitative methods could further illuminate the internal household negotiations that drive these demographic trends.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to strong filial piety, parents(-in-law) play an important role in their adult daughters’ fertility decisions in Vietnam; women feel pressured to fulfil their duties to produce a male descendant for the family. However, rapid urbanisation and industrialisation mean that multigenerational households are becoming less common, despite having been the standard household structure for centuries. Based on the 2020–21 Vietnam Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, we investigate if women who coreside with the parental generation are more likely to desire additional children. In an industrialised economy, grandparents may be an important source of childcare while simultaneously exerting pressure on their adult children to have additional children. Further, we explore the association of the sex of previous child(ren) to capture the pressure associated with son preference. Multivariate regressions reveal an association between coresiding with parents and the desire for a second child, regardless of the sex of the first child. Among women with two children, third-child desires do not appear to be associated with coresiding with parents but are substantially related to having two daughters. Given the strong two-child norm in Vietnam and previous policies implying negative consequences for parents with three or more children, few women show a desire for a third child. Those women who report a desire for a third child mostly have two daughters, reflecting societal norms about the need for a male heir.
BibTeX
@misc{nguyen2023coresiding,
  author = {Yen T. Nguyen and Truc Ngoc Hoang Dang and Brian Buh and Isabella Buber‐Ennser},
  title = {{CORESIDING WITH PARENTS, SON PREFERENCE, AND WOMEN’S DESIRE FOR ADDITIONAL CHILDREN IN VIETNAM}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1553/0x003e7385},
}
Figure