Coordinate the Express Delivery Supply Chain with Option Contracts

Mengying Zhang, Qin JinInt. J. Inf. Syst. Supply Chain Manag 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of "out of capacity" issues in express delivery supply chains, particularly during peak online shopping seasons. The authors propose using option contracts between online retailers and delivery providers to coordinate capacity decisions, leading to improved profits and supply chain efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of e-commerce has led to a surge in demand for express delivery services. However, delivery capacity is a "service product" that cannot be inventoried, making it difficult for providers to balance investment and avoid shortages during peak demand. This "out of capacity" problem, exemplified by events like China's Singles Day sales, results in delayed or lost packages, customer dissatisfaction, and ultimately, reduced profits for both retailers and delivery companies. Traditional supply chain models struggle to address this issue due to the inherent risk aversion of delivery providers, who tend to limit capacity to avoid unprofitable investments. This leads to a suboptimal system-wide capacity and a failure to achieve supply chain coordination.

Methods

The authors employ a newsvendor model as a benchmark to analyze the capacity decision problem in an express delivery supply chain. They then introduce and analyze a set of option contracts as a coordination mechanism. The core idea is to allow the online retailer to reserve delivery capacity in advance from the delivery provider. This reservation can exceed the provider's self-owned capacity, as the provider can then rent additional capacity from a third-party logistics provider. This reallocation of risk between the retailer and the delivery provider is the key to achieving coordination and improving supply chain efficiency. The paper focuses on how these option contracts can lead to a system-optimal capacity decision and quantifies the potential improvement in expected profits for the members.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Delivery Capacity as a "Service Product": The inability to inventory delivery capacity is a fundamental challenge that distinguishes express delivery supply chains from traditional ones. This lack of salvage value for unused capacity drives conservative capacity decisions.
  • The "Out of Capacity" Dilemma: During peak demand periods, the mismatch between supply and demand is severe, leading to significant operational problems and customer dissatisfaction.
  • Option Contracts as a Solution: Option contracts offer a novel way to align incentives. By allowing retailers to secure capacity in advance, they effectively transfer some of the demand uncertainty risk to the delivery provider, who can then manage it more effectively by leveraging third-party logistics.
  • Coordination for Mutual Benefit: The proposed option contracts not only improve the overall supply chain performance but also aim to increase the expected profits of both the online retailer and the delivery provider, demonstrating a win-win scenario.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that, compared to a benchmark newsvendor model, option contracts can effectively coordinate the express delivery service supply chain. The authors identify feasible option contracts that improve the expected profits of both supply chain members and quantify the degree of improvement achievable. While specific numerical results are not detailed in the provided abstract and introduction, the study's contribution lies in theoretically proving the effectiveness of option contracts in achieving system-optimal capacity and enhancing member profits.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges the need to identify feasible option contracts that are acceptable to both supply chain members. Future research directions would likely involve exploring different types of option contracts, conducting more in-depth numerical analyses to validate the theoretical findings, and potentially extending the model to include multiple retailers or delivery providers. The practical implementation and potential complexities of managing these contracts in real-world scenarios could also be areas for further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2016coordinate,
  author = {Mengying Zhang and Qin Jin},
  title = {{Coordinate the Express Delivery Supply Chain with Option Contracts}},
  journal = {Int. J. Inf. Syst. Supply Chain Manag.},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.4018/ijisscm.2016100101},
}
Figure