Cooperative Estimation for Synchronization of Heterogeneous Multi-Agent Systems Using Relative Information

Jingbo Wu, Valery A. Ugrinovskii, Frank AllgöwerarXiv 2015 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel distributed estimation framework for heterogeneous multi-agent systems that leverages only relative measurements. The key innovation is a scalable approach where each agent estimates its own state and those of its immediate neighbors, guaranteeing robust performance against disturbances and enabling integration with synchronization algorithms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing accurate state estimators for multi-agent systems is crucial for coordination and control. Traditional approaches often require centralized estimation or assume agents have access to absolute state information, which is impractical in many real-world scenarios like vehicle platooning or drone swarms. Heterogeneous systems, where agents have different dynamics, further complicate this. This paper tackles the challenge of distributed state estimation using only relative measurements (e.g., distances between agents) in such heterogeneous systems. A significant hurdle is the scalability of existing methods, which can lead to estimator complexity growing with the total number of agents. The authors aim to overcome this by developing an estimation strategy where each agent's computational burden is limited to its local neighborhood, thus improving scalability.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development of a "Cooperative Estimation" framework. This framework proposes a local estimator for each agent that:

  • Estimates Local and Neighbor States: Instead of trying to estimate the state of the entire system, each agent $k$ estimates its own state $x_k$ and the states of its direct neighbors $x_{j_i}$ (where there's an edge from $j_i$ to $k$ in the communication graph).
  • Uses Relative Measurements: The estimators rely on relative output measurements $z_{kj} = y_j - y_k + w_{kj}$, where $y_k$ is the output of agent $k$, and $w_{kj}$ is a measurement disturbance.
  • H∞ Suboptimal Design: The estimator gains are designed to achieve guaranteed $H_\infty$ performance, meaning they provide a bound on the influence of model and measurement disturbances on the estimation error. This is formulated using Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMIs).
  • Integration with Synchronization: The proposed cooperative estimators are shown to be integrable into existing output synchronization algorithms, allowing for coordinated behavior of the multi-agent system.

The paper also defines necessary conditions for the system's detectability, which is crucial for the estimators to function correctly.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is performed using a simulation example with defined system dynamics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Scalability through Local Estimation: The most significant insight is that by restricting local estimators to only consider immediate neighbors, the computational complexity per agent remains constant regardless of the total number of agents in the network. This is a major step towards scalable distributed estimation.
  • Relative Information is Sufficient: The work demonstrates that even with only relative measurements, it's possible to achieve robust state estimation for heterogeneous systems, a scenario where absolute measurements are often unavailable or impractical.
  • Guaranteed Robustness: The use of $H_\infty$ control theory ensures that the estimation performance is bounded even in the presence of uncertainties and disturbances, making the system more reliable.
  • Enabling Synchronization: The framework directly addresses the need for reliable state estimates to drive synchronization algorithms, bridging the gap between estimation and coordinated control.

Key Results

  • The paper presents a design procedure for local estimators that achieve $H_\infty$ suboptimal performance, providing guaranteed bounds on estimation errors in the presence of disturbances.
  • A simulation example with four interconnected agents demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed cooperative estimation algorithm.
  • The authors show that their approach can be integrated with synchronization controllers, and they analyze the resulting $H_\infty$ performance for the closed-loop system.
  • The proposed method is shown to be scalable, with estimator complexity not growing with the network size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conservatism in Performance Bounds: The authors acknowledge that the performance bounds derived for the synchronization problem might be conservative.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests several avenues for future research:
  • Applying the framework to other synchronization algorithms.
  • Investigating time-varying communication topologies.
  • Exploring scenarios with separate measurement and communication topologies.
  • Improving the performance bounds for the closed-loop system.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we present a distributed estimation setup where local agents estimate their states from relative measurements received from their neighbours. In the case of heterogeneous multi-agent systems, where only relative measurements are available, this is of high relevance. The objective is to improve the scalability of the existing distributed estimation algorithms by restricting the agents to estimating only their local states and those of immediate neighbours. The presented estimation algorithm also guarantees robust performance against model and measurement disturbances. It is shown that it can be integrated into output synchronization algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2015cooperative,
  author = {Jingbo Wu and Valery A. Ugrinovskii and Frank Allgöwer},
  title = {{Cooperative Estimation for Synchronization of Heterogeneous Multi-Agent Systems Using Relative Information}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1512.02075},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.02075},
}
Figure