Convexified Graph Neural Networks for Distributed Control in Robotic Swarms

Saar Cohen, Noa AgmonIJCAI 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Convexified Graph Neural Networks" (Cx-GNNs) that overcome the non-convexity issues of standard GNNs, enabling efficient distributed online learning for robotic swarms. By reformulating the learning problem, these Cx-GNNs achieve faster convergence and better generalization, particularly in dynamic environments with changing network topologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Controlling robotic swarms, especially in dynamic environments where robot positions, velocities, and communication links can change unpredictably, is a significant challenge. Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are promising for this task as they can learn from the network structure. However, standard GNN training involves solving a non-convex optimization problem, which is computationally expensive (NP-hard) and hinders their use in real-time, distributed learning scenarios. This non-convexity also makes them unsuitable for online learning, where models need to adapt continuously to changing data. The paper addresses this by developing convexified GNN architectures that are amenable to distributed online learning, allowing robots to adapt their control strategies in real-time without a central controller.

Methods

The core innovation lies in "convexifying" GNNs. The authors tackle the non-convexity in two main ways:

  • Linear Activation Functions: For simpler cases with linear activation functions, they leverage the nuclear norm as a convex relaxation of a rank constraint on the filter weights. This transforms the problem into a convex optimization problem.
  • Non-linear Activation Functions: For more complex non-linear activations, they propose a relaxation into a Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space (RKHS). This clever technique reduces the problem to a linear case, making it convex and solvable.

These convexified architectures (Cx-GNNs) are then integrated into a distributed online learning framework. This allows each robot in the swarm to update its local controller parameters based on its own observations and local losses, without needing to communicate its entire state to a central server. The paper also extends these ideas to other GNN variants like Aggregation GNNs (A-GNNs) and Time-Delayed GNNs (TA-GNNs), creating Convexified A-GNNs (CA-GNNs) and Convexified Time-Delayed GNNs (CTA-GNNs).

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses a simulated flocking environment called "GymFlock" for evaluating the proposed models on a robotic swarm control task. The experiments involve generating trajectories for training, validation, and testing, with varying parameters like initial velocities, visibility radius, and number of agents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Convexity is Key for Online/Distributed Learning: The paper strongly emphasizes that the non-convexity of standard GNNs is the primary bottleneck for efficient distributed online learning in dynamic systems like robotic swarms. By achieving convexity, they unlock these capabilities.
  • Nuclear Norm and RKHS as Powerful Tools: The application of nuclear norm relaxation for rank constraints and RKHS for non-linear function approximation are elegant mathematical techniques that effectively transform a hard, non-convex problem into a tractable, convex one.
  • Trade-offs in Convexification: While convexification enables faster convergence and better generalization, the paper notes a potential trade-off: as the number of robots (n) increases, the expected generalization error of convexified models can also increase, suggesting a nuanced performance profile depending on swarm size.
  • Hybrid Models (HC-GNNs) Offer a Balance: The introduction of Half-Convex GNNs (HC-GNNs), which combine a standard GNN with a convexified counterpart, suggests a promising direction for balancing the representation power of non-convex GNNs with the convergence benefits of convex ones.

Key Results

  • Faster Convergence: Experiments on a flocking model show that the proposed Cx-GNNs and their variants (CTA-GNNs, HC-GNNs) exhibit significantly faster convergence rates compared to non-convex GNNs, especially in the initial training epochs.
  • Improved Performance in Dynamic Settings: The models demonstrate competitive performance in controlling robotic swarms, aligning velocities and regulating spacing, even with changing network topologies.
  • Competitive Performance: HC-GNNs achieve performance comparable to non-convex GNNs, suggesting that the hybrid approach effectively leverages the strengths of both.
  • Validation Set Performance: While training performance is similar across models, HC-GNNs generally yield better average performance on the validation set, attributed to their faster initial convergence. However, for larger swarm sizes (higher 'n'), non-convex GNNs sometimes outperform convexified ones on the validation set, highlighting the trade-off mentioned earlier.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that for larger swarm sizes ('n'), the expected generalization error of convexified GNNs can increase, suggesting a potential limitation in scalability for very large swarms.
  • The proofs for RKHS relaxation are omitted due to space constraints and are available in supplementary material.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest exploring the applicability of their convexified models beyond swarm robotics, particularly in other real-world applications where data can be naturally represented as graphs (e.g., recommendation systems).
  • Further investigation into the trade-offs observed with increasing swarm size could be a valuable future direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cohen2021convexified,
  author = {Saar Cohen and Noa Agmon},
  title = {{Convexified Graph Neural Networks for Distributed Control in Robotic Swarms}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2021/318},
}
Figure