Abstract
Du 1er juillet 1975 au 30 juin 1976, j’ai fait mon internat en médecine interne à l’Hôpital Royal Victoria de Montréal, au Québec, après avoir terminé mes études en médecine à l’Université Emory. À cette époque là, les internes se voyaient encore attribuer une salle de garde.
Introduction
The legacy of Dr. Wilder Penfield, the pioneering neurosurgeon and founder of the Montreal Neurological Institute, is well-documented in the annals of science. However, the private reflections of such a figure in his final days offer a unique perspective on the intersection of medicine, philosophy, and personal history. This account, reconstructed from handwritten notes taken by Dr. Alan Blum during a one-hour bedside meeting in April 1976, serves as a piece of "narrative medicine," capturing Penfield’s thoughts just days before his death.
The Brain as an Electrical System
During the conversation, Penfield reflected on the nature of the human brain, which he posited was essentially an electrical system. He suggested that the transition between sleep, dreaming, and wakefulness—states that often seem mysterious—would appear simple once the "switch" for consciousness was fully understood. This mechanical yet profound view of the mind characterized much of his life's work.
Philosophy, Spirituality, and the "Creative Man"
As he approached the end of his life, Penfield’s thoughts turned toward the philosophical. He discussed the relationship between the "Creator" and the "creative man," suggesting that the evolution and complexity of the universe implied a deliberate plan.
A significant point of clarification arose regarding a New York Times review of his book, The Mystery of the Mind. The reviewer had claimed Penfield accepted "bilingualism" in a neurological sense. Penfield corrected this, stating he was actually referring to his belief in monotheism. This distinction highlights his move toward a more spiritual interpretation of existence in his final days.
The Value of Imagination in History
Penfield was not only a scientist but also an author of historical fiction, such as The Torch. He argued that a novelist could sometimes capture "truth" more effectively than a traditional historian. While historians provide lists of events, Penfield believed that writing with imagination allows one to capture the underlying reality and emotional truth of the human experience.
Career Origins and the "I" in Science
The conversation also touched upon Penfield’s early career. He recounted his refusal of a lucrative offer from the Henry Ford Hospital because they would not grant him sufficient laboratory time. This pivotal decision led him to New York and eventually to Montreal, where he founded the Neurological Institute.
Penfield also shared an anecdote about physicist J. Robert Oppenheimer. He noted that Oppenheimer’s secretaries were surprised to see the word "I" used in a scientific manuscript. This observation underscored the rigid objectivity and lack of personal voice that dominated mid-century physical sciences—a convention Penfield seemed to challenge through his own narrative and philosophical explorations.
Conclusion
This 1976 encounter provides a rare, intimate look at a scientific giant's final reflections. While the account is subject to the limitations of memory over a 35-year gap, it preserves the "sensations" of a foundational figure in neuroscience grappling with the ultimate questions of consciousness, creativity, and the divine.
Summary updated