Convergent regulatory evolution and the origin of flightlessness in palaeognathous birds

Timothy B. Sackton, Phil Grayson, Alison Cloutier, Zhirui Hu, Jun S. Liu, Nicole E. Wheeler, Paul P. Gardner, Julia A. Clarke, Allan J. Baker, Michèle Clamp, Scott V. EdwardsbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the molecular basis of flightlessness in palaeognathous birds, finding that convergent evolution in regulatory DNA regions, rather than protein-coding genes, is the primary driver of this trait. By analyzing new genomes and functional assays, the research highlights the crucial role of non-coding DNA in evolutionary adaptation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Evolutionary biology often grapples with understanding how similar traits arise independently in different species – a phenomenon called convergent evolution. A classic example is the loss of flight in birds, observed in groups like ostriches, emus, and kiwis (collectively known as ratites). While changes in protein-coding genes can drive such adaptations, the role of regulatory DNA (regions that control gene expression) has been less clear. This paper aims to disentangle the contributions of protein-coding versus regulatory evolution to the convergent loss of flight in ratites, a group with a complex evolutionary history.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Phylogenomics: They assembled and analyzed 11 new palaeognath genomes, including an extinct moa, to reconstruct their evolutionary relationships. This involved sophisticated phylogenetic methods like MP-EST (Maximum Pseudo-likelihood Species Tree) and ExaML (Exascale Maximum Likelihood) on a large dataset of conserved non-exonic elements (CNEEs), introns, and ultraconserved elements.
  • Genome-wide analysis of conserved non-exonic elements (CNEEs): They identified over 284,000 CNEEs across 35 bird species and 7 non-avian reptiles. Using a novel Bayesian method, they detected "convergent accelerations" – instances where these conserved regions evolved rapidly in parallel across multiple ratite lineages.
  • Functional Characterization: To test the regulatory role of these accelerated regions, they used ATAC-seq to map open chromatin regions (indicating active regulatory elements) in developing chicken embryos. They then focused on candidate enhancers, particularly in the forelimb, and performed enhancer activity assays using a reporter gene (GFP) in developing chicken embryos. This allowed them to directly test if specific regulatory elements drive gene expression and if changes in these elements correlate with flightlessness.

Datasets

The study utilized several key datasets:

  • Newly sequenced genomes: 11 palaeognath genomes were sequenced and assembled, including a draft genome of the extinct little bush moa.
  • Published genomes: Data from existing published genomes of ostrich and white-throated tinamou were also incorporated.
  • Transcriptome data: RNA sequencing data from three tissues (brain, liver, gonad) of emu and Chilean tinamou were generated.
  • Conserved Non-Exonic Elements (CNEEs): A dataset of 284,001 CNEEs was identified from a whole-genome alignment of 35 birds and 7 non-avian reptiles.
  • ATAC-seq data: Genomic regions of open chromatin were mapped across eight tissues during chicken development.
  • ChIP-seq data: Previously published ChIP-seq data for chicken developmental studies were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regulatory DNA is the star player: The most striking finding is that convergent evolution of flightlessness in ratites is overwhelmingly driven by changes in regulatory DNA (CNEEs), not by changes in the genes themselves. This suggests that altering when and where genes are expressed is more critical for major phenotypic shifts like losing flight than altering the proteins they encode.
  • Flightlessness is a regulatory rewiring event: The study provides strong evidence that the loss of flight involved a coordinated "rewiring" of gene regulatory networks, rather than a series of independent protein-level adaptations.
  • Convergent acceleration in CNEEs is a strong signal: The high frequency of convergent acceleration in CNEEs within ratites, compared to other bird groups, points to these regions as key targets of evolutionary pressure related to flight loss.
  • A specific enhancer shows functional divergence: The functional assay on the TEAD1 gene's intronic enhancer provides a concrete example. A conserved version in volant birds drives gene expression, while an accelerated version in flightless birds fails to do so, directly linking regulatory change to phenotypic outcome.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic resolution: The new genomes helped resolve palaeognath phylogeny, confirming ratite paraphyly (meaning not all ratites form a single, distinct group) and suggesting multiple independent losses of flight.
  • Convergent acceleration in CNEEs: The analysis identified a significantly higher incidence of convergent acceleration in CNEEs within ratites (47.3 CNEEs per trio) compared to random bird trios (2.7 CNEEs per trio).
  • Enrichment of regulatory elements near key genes: Convergent RARs (ratite-accelerated regions) were found to be enriched near genes involved in transcription factor activity, suggesting a coordinated regulatory response.
  • Functional validation of a regulatory element: An enhancer element in the TEAD1 gene showed conserved activity in volant tinamous but failed to drive expression in the flightless rhea, demonstrating functional divergence linked to accelerated evolution.
  • Limited evidence for protein-coding convergence: In contrast to regulatory regions, the study found little evidence for convergent amino acid substitutions or rate shifts in protein-coding genes associated with flightlessness in ratites.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assigning CNEEs to genes: The authors acknowledge that computationally assigning CNEEs to the genes they regulate is inherently imprecise.
  • Detecting partially degenerated pseudogenes: The methods used to detect gene loss might miss genes that have partially degenerated into pseudogenes.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that future research should continue to explore the role of noncoding regulatory regions in the evolution of flightlessness and other complex traits. They also highlight the need for more attention to the possible role of protein-coding changes, which might be lineage-specific rather than convergent.

Summary updated

Abstract

The relative roles of regulatory and protein evolution in the origin and loss of convergent phenotypic traits is a core question in evolutionary biology. Here we combine phylogenomic, epigenomic and developmental data to show that convergent evolution of regulatory regions, but not protein-coding genes, is associated with flightlessness in palaeognathous birds, a classic example of a convergent phenotype. Eleven new genomes, including a draft genome from an extinct moa, resolve palaeognath phylogeny and show that the incidence of independent, convergent accelerations among 284,000 conserved non-exonic elements is significantly more frequent in ratites than other bird lineages. Ratite-specific acceleration of conserved regions and measures of open chromatin across eight tissues in the developing chick identify candidate regulatory regions that may have modified or lost function in ratites. Enhancer activity assays conducted in the early developing chicken forelimb confirm that volant versions of a conserved element in the first intron of the TEAD1 gene display conserved enhancer activity, whereas an accelerated flightless version fails to drive reporter gene expression. Our results show that convergent molecular changes associated with loss of flight are largely regulatory in nature.
BibTeX
@misc{sackton2018convergent,
  author = {Timothy B. Sackton and Phil Grayson and Alison Cloutier and Zhirui Hu and Jun S. Liu and Nicole E. Wheeler and Paul P. Gardner and Julia A. Clarke and Allan J. Baker and Michèle Clamp and Scott V. Edwards},
  title = {{Convergent regulatory evolution and the origin of flightlessness in palaeognathous birds}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/262584},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure