Convergent approach for direct cross-coupling enabled by flash irreversible generation of cationic and anionic species

Hiroki Soutome, Hiroki Yamashita, Yutaka Shimizu, Masahiro Takumi, Yosuke Ashikari, Aiichiro NagakiNature Communications 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel "flash synthesis" approach using flow microreactors to generate and immediately react highly unstable cationic and carbanionic intermediates simultaneously. This method enables direct C-C bond formation in seconds, overcoming limitations of conventional batch reactions and mimicking the efficiency of biological synthesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nature's biosynthetic pathways are remarkably efficient, orchestrating the generation, transport, and reaction of transient, highly reactive intermediates to build complex molecules with exquisite selectivity. Mimicking this in synthetic organic chemistry has been a long-standing goal. Conventional methods often struggle with the rapid generation and controlled reaction of such unstable species, leading to decomposition, side reactions, and low yields. Specifically, generating and reacting both cationic and anionic intermediates in a single step, in a controlled manner, has been a significant challenge. This paper addresses the need for a synthetic strategy that can rapidly and irreversibly generate these reactive species and bring them together for immediate coupling, akin to biological systems.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the application of flow microreactor technology. The authors leverage the precise control over reaction time and mixing offered by these systems.

  • Flash Generation of Cations: Unsaturated precursors, like enamines, are reacted with a superacid (trifluoromethanesulfonic acid, TfOH) in a flow microreactor. This generates highly reactive iminium ions (cations) rapidly and irreversibly. The flow setup is crucial to ensure these cations react before they can decompose or undergo unwanted dimerization with the starting enamine.
  • Flash Generation of Anions: Simultaneously, in a separate flow path, carbanions (e.g., organolithium reagents) are generated.
  • Convergent Mixing and Reaction: The independently generated cationic and anionic streams are then brought together in a micromixer. This "flash reaction" occurs within milliseconds to seconds, allowing the highly reactive intermediates to couple and form new C-C bonds before they degrade.
  • NMR Spectroscopy: Low-temperature NMR was used to confirm the irreversible generation of the cationic species by observing characteristic shifts and the absence of precursor signals.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on demonstrating a synthetic methodology rather than training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mimicking Biosynthesis: The approach successfully mimics the biological strategy of generating and reacting transient intermediates in close proximity, leading to high efficiency and selectivity.
  • "Flash Synthesis": The concept of "flash chemistry" is extended to "flash synthesis," where multiple reactive intermediates are generated and reacted in rapid succession within seconds.
  • Irreversible Cation Generation is Key: The irreversible generation of cationic species, facilitated by the flow microreactor's rapid mixing and short reaction times, is critical to prevent side reactions like dimerization and ensure efficient coupling.
  • Flow Reactor Advantage: The precise control over mixing and residence time in flow microreactors is paramount for managing the reactivity of these short-lived species, enabling reactions that are difficult or impossible in batch.
  • Broad Applicability: The method demonstrates successful cross-coupling for various C-C bond formations, including sp³-sp³, sp³-sp², and sp³-sp couplings, with diverse nucleophiles and electrophiles.

Key Results

  • High Yields in Seconds: The developed method achieved direct C-C bond formation with good to high yields in reaction times as short as milliseconds to a few seconds.
  • Successful Cross-Coupling:
    • Direct coupling of iminium cations with neutral nucleophiles yielded products in 20-21 seconds with yields up to 83%.
  • Direct sp³-sp³ C-C bond formation with organolithium reagents was achieved in as little as 0.36 seconds with yields up to 72%.
  • Convergent synthesis of sp³-sp² and sp³-sp C-C bonds using aryl and alkynyl lithiums, respectively, was accomplished with high yields (up to 96% and 92%) in reaction times under 10 seconds.
  • Overcoming Batch Limitations: The flow method successfully produced desired products where batch reactions failed or gave low yields, particularly in cation-anion coupling.
  • Confirmation of Irreversible Cation Formation: Low-temperature NMR confirmed the rapid and irreversible generation of iminium and oxocarbenium ions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: While flow chemistry offers advantages for scale-up, the paper focuses on proof-of-concept and doesn't extensively detail large-scale production.
  • Scope of Nucleophiles/Electrophiles: Although broad, the paper suggests further exploration of more complex substrates and reactive intermediates.
  • Further Investigation: The authors anticipate that this "flash" reaction strategy can be applied to achieve even more complex syntheses by leveraging multiple reactive intermediates, indicating ongoing research in this area. They also mention the need for advanced analysis like CFD for more accurate mixing time estimations.

Summary updated

Abstract

In biosynthesis multiple kinds of reactive intermediates are generated, transported, and reacted across different parts of organisms, enabling highly sophisticated synthetic reactions. Herein we report a convergent synthetic approach, which utilizes dual intermediates of cationic and carbanionic species in a single step, hinted at by the ideal reaction conditions. By reactions of unsaturated precursors, such as enamines, with a superacid in a flow microreactor, cationic species, such as iminium ions, are generated rapidly and irreversibly, and before decomposition, they are transported to react with rapidly and independently generated carbanions, enabling direct C-C bond formation. Taking advantage of the reactivity of these double reactive intermediates, the reaction take place within a few seconds, enabling synthetic reactions which are not applicable in conventional reactions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{soutome2024convergent,
  author = {Hiroki Soutome and Hiroki Yamashita and Yutaka Shimizu and Masahiro Takumi and Yosuke Ashikari and Aiichiro Nagaki},
  title = {{Convergent approach for direct cross-coupling enabled by flash irreversible generation of cationic and anionic species}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-48723-1},
}
Figure