Convergence Rates of Accelerated Markov Gradient Descent with Applications in Reinforcement Learning

Thinh T. Doan, Lam M. Nguyen, Nhan H. Pham, Justin RombergarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Accelerated Stochastic Gradient Descent (ASGD), particularly Nesterov’s accelerated method, is a cornerstone of modern optimization. It is widely celebrated for its superior convergence rates compared to standard Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD). However, the vast majority of theoretical guarantees for ASGD rely on a critical assumption: that gradient samples are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.).

In many real-world applications, most notably Reinforcement Learning (RL), this assumption is fundamentally violated. In RL, an agent’s experience is generated through trajectories where the next state is highly dependent on the current state and action. This creates "Markovian" noise—data that is both dependent and biased. This paper addresses this theoretical gap by providing the first finite-time convergence analysis for Accelerated Markov Gradient Descent (AMGD), demonstrating that acceleration is not only viable but highly effective in Markovian environments.

The Challenge of Markovian Noise

In standard supervised learning, we sample data points randomly from a fixed dataset. In contrast, an RL agent interacts with an environment modeled as a Markov Decision Process (MDP). The gradients computed for policy updates or value function estimation are derived from these sequential interactions.

This introduces two primary difficulties:

  1. Dependence: A gradient at time $t+1$ is strongly correlated with the gradient at time $t$.
  2. Bias: The distribution of states visited early in training may differ significantly from the stationary distribution of the underlying Markov chain.

While standard SGD has been analyzed under Markovian conditions, the behavior of accelerated methods remained a theoretical mystery. The interaction between the "memory" of the momentum term and the "memory" of the Markovian process requires a sophisticated approach to ensure stability and convergence.

Algorithmic Framework: AMGD

The authors introduce and analyze Accelerated Markov Gradient Descent (AMGD), adapting Nesterov-style acceleration to handle biased, dependent samples. The study covers two primary variants:

  • Nonconvex AMGD: Designed for complex landscapes typical of deep neural networks.
  • Convex/Strongly Convex AMGD: Tailored for problems like linear value function approximation.

The analysis hinges on the geometric mixing time ($\tau$) of the underlying Markov chain. This parameter quantifies how quickly the process reaches its steady state. By analyzing the algorithm's progress over time windows related to this mixing time, the authors show that the Markovian noise eventually averages out, allowing the acceleration benefits to manifest much as they do in the i.i.d. case.

Theoretical Guarantees

The paper’s primary contribution is the derivation of finite-time convergence rates for nonconvex, convex, and strongly convex functions under Markovian noise. The findings reveal that the "Markovian Tax"—the performance penalty for using dependent data—is surprisingly small.

Key theoretical insights include:

  • Near-Optimal Rates: AMGD achieves convergence rates nearly identical to the i.i.d. setting. The only difference is a logarithmic factor ($\log K$) that accounts for the mixing time of the Markov chain.
  • Initial Condition Efficiency: In convex settings, acceleration provides a much better rate on the initial condition ($O(1/k^2)$ vs $O(1/k)$). This is crucial for RL, where rapid progress in early episodes can significantly improve overall sample efficiency.
  • Robustness to Nonconvexity: The analysis proves that acceleration remains theoretically sound even in complex, nonconvex landscapes, providing a rigorous justification for its use in deep RL.

Empirical Evaluation in Reinforcement Learning

The authors validated AMGD across a variety of Reinforcement Learning benchmarks, focusing on Temporal Difference (TD) learning and Policy Gradient methods.

TD Learning (Policy Evaluation)

Using GridWorld environments ($10 \times 10$ and $50 \times 50$), the authors implemented TD(0)-Acc. The accelerated variant reached lower Mean Squared Bellman Error (MSBE) significantly faster than standard TD(0), demonstrating that the theoretical speedup translates directly to classic RL algorithms.

Policy Gradient (REINFORCE)

The authors integrated acceleration into the REINFORCE algorithm (REINFORCE-Acc) and tested it on OpenAI Gym and Mujoco tasks. Environments included discrete tasks like Acrobot and CartPole, as well as continuous control tasks like Swimmer, Walker2d, HalfCheetah, and Ant.

In the Swimmer-v2 environment, REINFORCE-Acc reached peak performance in approximately half the episodes required by the standard algorithm. Similar dramatic improvements in reward growth and sample efficiency were observed in high-dimensional tasks like HalfCheetah and Ant.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work bridges the gap between accelerated optimization theory and the practical realities of Reinforcement Learning. By proving that the "Markovian Tax" is minimal, the authors provide a theoretical foundation for using Nesterov-style acceleration in dependent-data settings.

While the results are promising, the authors note certain limitations. The current analysis relies on the assumption that the Markov chain is ergodic with a finite state space. Additionally, accelerated methods can be sensitive to hyperparameter selection. Future research may focus on extending these guarantees to continuous state spaces and exploring more automated ways to tune step sizes in RL contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motivated by broad applications in machine learning, we study the popular accelerated stochastic gradient descent (ASGD) algorithm for solving (possibly nonconvex) optimization problems. We characterize the finite-time performance of this method when the gradients are sampled from Markov processes, and hence biased and dependent from time step to time step; in contrast, the analysis in existing work relies heavily on the stochastic gradients being independent and sometimes unbiased. Our main contributions show that under certain (standard) assumptions on the underlying Markov chain generating the gradients, ASGD converges at the nearly the same rate with Markovian gradient samples as with independent gradient samples. The only difference is a logarithmic factor that accounts for the mixing time of the Markov chain. One of the key motivations for this study are complicated control problems that can be modeled by a Markov decision process and solved using reinforcement learning. We apply the accelerated method to several challenging problems in the OpenAI Gym and Mujoco, and show that acceleration can significantly improve the performance of the classic temporal difference learning and REINFORCE algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{doan2020convergence,
  author = {Thinh T. Doan and Lam M. Nguyen and Nhan H. Pham and Justin Romberg},
  title = {{Convergence Rates of Accelerated Markov Gradient Descent with Applications in Reinforcement Learning}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2002.02873},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2002.02873},
}
Figure