Convergence and Privacy of Decentralized Nonconvex Optimization with Gradient Clipping and Communication Compression

Boyue Li, Yuejie ChiarXiv 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces PORTER, a novel framework for decentralized nonconvex optimization that combines gradient clipping and communication compression. PORTER offers two variants: PORTER-DP for privacy-preserving learning and PORTER-GC for improved training stability, both achieving theoretical convergence guarantees without requiring strong assumptions on gradient boundedness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Decentralized machine learning aims to train models across multiple agents without a central server, often modeled as a nonconvex finite-sum optimization problem. A key challenge is communication efficiency, as frequent data exchange between agents can become a bottleneck. Communication compression techniques help reduce this burden. However, the role of gradient clipping, a common practice for stabilizing training and enabling differential privacy, in conjunction with communication compression in decentralized settings has been underexplored. Existing theoretical analyses for gradient clipping often rely on strong assumptions like bounded gradients, which are not always practical. This paper bridges this gap by providing the first convergence analysis for decentralized nonconvex optimization that incorporates both gradient clipping and communication compression, without the strict bounded gradient assumption.

Methods

The paper proposes PORTER, a decentralized algorithm that integrates gradient clipping and communication compression. PORTER builds upon existing techniques like gradient tracking and error feedback to accelerate convergence. The core novelty lies in the two variants of gradient clipping:

  • PORTER-DP: Gradient clipping is applied before taking a mini-batch of stochastic gradients, and additional Gaussian noise is added to achieve local differential privacy (LDP). This variant is designed for scenarios where individual agent privacy is paramount.
  • PORTER-GC: Gradient clipping is applied after computing the mini-batch stochastic gradient. This variant aims to stabilize training and improve convergence rates, particularly in nonconvex settings.

A key contribution is the development of a novel analysis framework that establishes convergence guarantees for both PORTER variants without assuming the stringent bounded gradient assumption. This framework allows for a more nuanced understanding of the trade-offs between convergence rate, compression ratio, network connectivity, and privacy.

Datasets

  • a9a dataset: Used for logistic regression with nonconvex regularization.
  • MNIST dataset: Used for training a one-hidden-layer neural network.

The paper does not introduce new datasets but uses standard benchmarks to evaluate the proposed algorithms.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gradient clipping is beneficial for decentralized nonconvex optimization: The paper demonstrates that gradient clipping, when properly integrated, can stabilize training and enable privacy guarantees in decentralized settings, even without the strong bounded gradient assumption.
  • PORTER-DP offers a privacy-utility trade-off: The PORTER-DP variant allows for local differential privacy analysis, showing how to balance privacy guarantees with convergence performance. The analysis highlights that LDP requires larger perturbations than general DP.
  • PORTER-GC matches centralized SGD rates: The PORTER-GC variant, by clipping gradients, achieves convergence rates comparable to classical centralized SGD algorithms, even in a decentralized setting with communication compression.
  • Novel analysis framework is crucial: The development of a new theoretical framework that avoids the bounded gradient assumption is a significant contribution, enabling a more realistic analysis of these algorithms.
  • Decentralized topology adds complexity: The analysis accounts for the challenges introduced by the decentralized nature of the problem, such as the discrepancy between local and global objective functions.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantees:
    • PORTER-DP: Achieves (ε, δ)-LDP under specific Gaussian perturbation. It converges in minimum l2 gradient norm under local variance and bounded dissimilarity assumptions, with convergence rates dependent on compression ratio, mixing rate, and privacy loss.
  • PORTER-GC: Converges in minimum l2 gradient norm at an O(1/√T) rate, matching centralized SGD rates when hyperparameters are chosen appropriately.
  • Empirical Results:
    • Logistic Regression: PORTER-DP shows competitive or superior test accuracy compared to a server/client LDP algorithm (SoteriaFL-SGD) under strict privacy constraints, highlighting its communication efficiency.
  • Neural Network Training: PORTER-DP demonstrates similar train utility and competitive test accuracy to SoteriaFL-SGD, further emphasizing its efficiency in decentralized settings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bounded Gradient Assumption: While the paper moves beyond the strict bounded gradient assumption, some analyses still rely on related assumptions like bounded local variance and bounded gradient dissimilarity.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: The performance of PORTER, like many optimization algorithms, is sensitive to hyperparameter choices (e.g., clipping threshold, learning rate, compression ratio).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more sophisticated compression operators and further investigating the interplay between gradient clipping, communication compression, and other decentralized optimization techniques. They also point to the potential for applying these findings to more complex deep learning architectures and real-world distributed systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Achieving communication efficiency in decentralized machine learning has been attracting significant attention, with communication compression recognized as an effective technique in algorithm design. This paper takes a first step to understand the role of gradient clipping, a popular strategy in practice, in decentralized nonconvex optimization with communication compression. We propose PORTER, which considers two variants of gradient clipping added before or after taking a mini-batch of stochastic gradients, where the former variant PORTER-DP allows local differential privacy analysis with additional Gaussian perturbation, and the latter variant PORTER-GC helps to stabilize training. We develop a novel analysis framework that establishes their convergence guarantees without assuming the stringent bounded gradient assumption. To the best of our knowledge, our work provides the first convergence analysis for decentralized nonconvex optimization with gradient clipping and communication compression, highlighting the trade-offs between convergence rate, compression ratio, network connectivity, and privacy.
BibTeX
@misc{li2023convergence,
  author = {Boyue Li and Yuejie Chi},
  title = {{Convergence and Privacy of Decentralized Nonconvex Optimization with Gradient Clipping and Communication Compression}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.09896},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09896},
}
Figure