Convalescent Plasma Efficacy in Life-Threatening COVID-19 Patients Admitted to the ICU: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Mohamed Abuzakouk, Khaled Saleh, Manuel Algora, Ahmad Nusair, Jawahir Alameri, Fatema Alshehhi, Sara Alkhaja, Mohamed Badr, Khaled Abdallah, Bruno De Oliveira, Nadeem Ashraf, Yeldho Varghese, Dnyaseshwar Munde, Shameen Salam, Baraa Abduljawad, Hussam Elkambergy, Ali S. Wahla, Ahmed Taha, Jamil Dibu, Ahmed Bayrlee, Fadi Hamed, Laila AbdelWareth, Nadeem Rahman, Jorge A. Guzmán, Jihad MallatJournal of Clinical Medicine 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This retrospective study investigated the efficacy of convalescent plasma (CP) in critically ill COVID-19 patients admitted to the ICU. The findings indicate that CP, even with high neutralizing antibody titers, was not associated with improved clinical outcomes, including time to improvement or hospital mortality, in this severe patient population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented a significant challenge to healthcare systems worldwide, with a critical need for effective treatments, especially for patients with severe and life-threatening disease. Convalescent plasma (CP), derived from recovered individuals, was explored as a potential therapeutic option due to its theoretical ability to provide passive immunity. While early studies and observational data suggested potential benefits, particularly with high-titer plasma, robust evidence for its efficacy in the most severely ill patients, those requiring intensive care unit (ICU) admission, was limited. This paper aims to fill that gap by evaluating CP's effectiveness in critically ill COVID-19 patients, a group that often experiences hyperinflammation and organ dysfunction, making them less responsive to antibody-based therapies.

Methods

This study employed a retrospective, single-center cohort design. The researchers analyzed data from 110 adult patients admitted to the ICU with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection and life-threatening pneumonia. Patients were divided into two groups: those who received convalescent plasma (CP group) and those who did not (non-CP group).

The primary outcome measured was the time to clinical improvement within 28 days. This was defined as either patient discharge alive or a reduction of at least two points on a six-point disease severity scale. Secondary outcomes included hospital mortality, ICU and hospital length of stay, and viral clearance.

To account for potential confounding factors, the researchers utilized multivariable Cox proportional hazards regression models. They also employed inverse probability weighting (IPW) to estimate the average treatment effects (ATE) of CP, a statistical technique designed to create comparable groups by weighting individuals based on the probability of receiving the treatment. Antibody titers in the CP were assessed, and a subset of patients receiving CP with high neutralizing antibody titers (≥1:160) was analyzed separately.

Datasets

The study utilized data from patients admitted to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) at Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi between March 1, 2020, and May 29, 2020. This retrospective cohort comprised 110 adult patients with confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection and life-threatening COVID-19 pneumonia. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Severity Matters: The study strongly suggests that the timing and severity of illness are crucial factors in CP efficacy. In critically ill patients with advanced disease, the benefits of passive antibody transfer might be overshadowed by overwhelming inflammation and organ damage.
  • High Titer Not Enough: Even when CP with high neutralizing antibody titers was administered, it did not translate into improved clinical outcomes. This implies that simply having antibodies isn't sufficient if the underlying disease process is too advanced.
  • Safety Profile: Convalescent plasma was found to be well-tolerated in this patient population, with no observed mild or serious transfusion-related adverse events. This is an important finding, as safety is a primary concern for any therapeutic intervention.
  • Antiviral Activity Questioned: The lack of difference in viral clearance rates between CP and standard care groups suggests that CP may not have a significant direct antiviral effect in this severely ill cohort.

Key Results

  • No Significant Clinical Improvement: The primary outcome, time to clinical improvement within 28 days, was not significantly different between the CP group (43.7% improvement) and the non-CP group (61.5% improvement) in univariate analysis (HR: 0.75, p=0.35). After adjusting for confounders, CP was still not independently associated with clinical improvement (HR: 0.53, p=0.14). The ATE analysis also showed no significant association.
  • No Difference in Mortality: Hospital mortality rates were similar between the CP group (31.2%) and the non-CP group (19.2%), with a p-value of 0.17.
  • No Impact on Viral Clearance: CP treatment did not lead to higher rates of negative SARS-CoV-2 PCR tests on day 14 compared to standard care.
  • High Titer CP Ineffective: Even when analyzing only patients who received CP with high neutralizing antibody titers (≥1:160), no significant association with improved clinical outcomes was found.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Single-Center Retrospective Design: This limits the generalizability of the findings, as management and outcomes can vary between institutions.
  • Timing of Antibody Assessment: CP antibody titers were measured after administration, not before, and neutralizing antibody activity was inferred rather than directly measured.
  • Small Sample Size for High Titer CP: The number of patients receiving high-titer CP was relatively small, potentially limiting the power to detect a difference.
  • Lack of Pre- and Post-CP Antibody Measurement in Recipients: The study did not measure antibody levels in patients before and after CP infusion.
  • Potential for Bias: Despite multivariable analysis, residual confounding and selection bias cannot be entirely ruled out.

Future work could focus on prospective, randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in specific patient subgroups, such as those with less severe disease or those who are immunocompromised and may not respond well to vaccination. The ongoing CONFIDENT trial, investigating CP in critically ill patients requiring mechanical ventilation, is mentioned as a crucial next step in understanding CP's role. The authors also note that with the advent of highly effective vaccines, the role of CP may be limited to non-vaccinated or immunocompromised individuals.

Summary updated

Abstract

(1) Background: There are limited data regarding the efficacy of convalescent plasma (CP) in critically ill patients admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) due to coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). We aimed to determine whether CP is associated with better clinical outcome among these patients. (2) Methods:&nbsp;A&nbsp;retrospective single-center study including adult patients with laboratory-confirmed SARS-CoV-2 infection admitted to the ICU for acute respiratory failure. The primary outcome was time to clinical improvement, within 28 days, defined as patient discharged alive or reduction of 2 points on a 6-point disease severity scale. (3)&nbsp;Results:&nbsp;Overall, 110 COVID-19 patients were admitted. Thirty-two patients (29%) received CP; among them, 62.5% received at least one CP with high neutralizing antibody titers (≥1:160). Clinical improvement occurred within 28 days in 14 patients (43.7%) of the CP group vs. 48 patients (61.5%) in the non-CP group (hazard ratio (HR): 0.75 (95% CI: 0.41-1.37), <i>p</i> = 0.35). After adjusting for potential confounding factors, CP was not independently associated with time to clinical improvement (HR: 0.53 (95% CI: 0.23-1.22), <i>p</i> = 0.14). Additionally, the average treatment effects of CP, calculated using the inverse probability weights (IPW), was not associated with the primary outcome (-0.14 days (95% CI: -3.19-2.91 days), <i>p</i> = 0.93). Hospital mortality did not differ between CP and non-CP groups (31.2% vs. 19.2%, <i>p</i> = 0.17, respectively). Comparing CP with high neutralizing antibody titers to the other group yielded the same findings. (4) Conclusions: In this study of life-threatening COVID-19 patients, CP was not associated with time to clinical improvement within 28 days, or hospital mortality.
BibTeX
@article{abuzakouk2021convalescent,
  author = {Mohamed Abuzakouk and Khaled Saleh and Manuel Algora and Ahmad Nusair and Jawahir Alameri and Fatema Alshehhi and Sara Alkhaja and Mohamed Badr and Khaled Abdallah and Bruno De Oliveira and Nadeem Ashraf and Yeldho Varghese and Dnyaseshwar Munde and Shameen Salam and Baraa Abduljawad and Hussam Elkambergy and Ali S. Wahla and Ahmed Taha and Jamil Dibu and Ahmed Bayrlee and Fadi Hamed and Laila AbdelWareth and Nadeem Rahman and Jorge A. Guzmán and Jihad Mallat},
  title = {{Convalescent Plasma Efficacy in Life-Threatening COVID-19 Patients Admitted to the ICU: A Retrospective Cohort Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm10102113},
}
Figure