Controls of soil organic matter on soil thermal dynamics in the northern high latitudes

Dan Zhu, Philippe Ciais, Gerhard Krinner, Fabienne Maignan, Albert Jornet Puig, Gustaf HugeliusNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Soil organic matter (SOM) plays a critical, often overlooked, role in regulating soil thermal dynamics in the Arctic. This study demonstrates that SOM content is the primary driver of variations in soil thermal diffusivity, a key factor in permafrost extent. Understanding this coupling is essential for accurately projecting future permafrost thaw and its associated climate feedbacks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Arctic is warming at an accelerated rate, leading to permafrost thaw and the potential release of vast amounts of stored soil organic carbon (SOC). This release could create a significant positive feedback loop, amplifying climate change. However, current climate models show wide discrepancies in their projections of future permafrost extent and the magnitude of carbon release. A major source of this uncertainty lies in how these models simulate soil temperature, which is governed by soil thermal dynamics. Specifically, the role of soil organic matter (SOM) – a substantial component of Arctic soils – in influencing these thermal processes has not been fully quantified. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by investigating the dominant factors controlling soil thermal diffusivity and their impact on permafrost dynamics.

Methods

The researchers derived soil thermal diffusivity ($D$) from depth-specific monthly soil temperature measurements collected at approximately 200 sites across high-latitude regions. They employed a method based on Fourier's Law of heat conduction, assuming a sinusoidal temperature oscillation at the surface. This approach allows for the calculation of $D$ by analyzing the dampening of temperature amplitude with depth. To ensure the validity of their measurements, they filtered out sites where non-conductive processes, such as latent heat exchange during freezing and thawing (the "zero curtain effect"), significantly distorted the sinusoidal temperature profiles.

They then correlated the derived $D$ values with various soil properties, including SOC content, soil texture, bulk density, and soil moisture, using data from global and regional soil databases. To assess the impact of these findings on climate modeling, they analyzed outputs from CMIP5 Earth System Models, comparing their simulated permafrost extents with their parameterized thermal diffusivities. Finally, they used the ORCHIDEE-MICT land surface model to simulate the effects of SOM on soil thermal properties and SOC accumulation, comparing scenarios with and without SOM's influence.

Datasets

  • In-situ Soil Temperature Data:
    • Russian Historical Soil Temperature Data (RHST)
    • International Polar Year (IPY) Thermal State of Permafrost data
  • Soil Property Databases:
    • WISE (World Inventory of Soil Emission Potentials) 30sec v1.0 soil database
    • NCSCD (Northern Circumpolar Soil Carbon Database)
  • Ancillary Datasets:
    • ESA CCI SM v02.2 product (soil moisture)
    • ERA-Interim/Land product (soil moisture)
    • CMIP5 model outputs (for climate simulations)
    • CRU TS v3.24 climate dataset (used for filtering soil temperature data)

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather synthesized and analyzed existing observational and model data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SOM as the Dominant Thermal Regulator: The most striking finding is that soil organic carbon (SOC) density is the dominant factor controlling the variability of soil thermal diffusivity across different sites. This suggests that the amount of organic matter in the soil has a much larger impact on how quickly heat moves through it than factors like soil texture or moisture content.
  • Insulating Effect of SOM: Soils with higher SOC content exhibit lower thermal diffusivity. This means SOM acts as an insulator, slowing down the propagation of heat, particularly during the summer, which helps to keep deeper soils cooler and potentially preserves permafrost.
  • Model Parameterization Matters: Differences in how CMIP5 models parameterize thermal diffusivity are a major driver of the discrepancies in their simulated present-day permafrost extents. This highlights the critical need for accurate representation of soil thermal properties in climate models.
  • SOC-Thermics Coupling is Crucial for Future Projections: The strong link between SOC and soil thermal dynamics is not just an academic curiosity; it's essential for projecting future permafrost changes. As warming air temperatures lead to changes in SOC (potentially through increased decomposition or altered vegetation), this will, in turn, influence soil temperatures and permafrost thaw rates in a non-linear fashion.

Key Results

  • A significant negative correlation was found between soil thermal diffusivity and soil organic carbon density ($r = -0.60$, $p < 0.001$ for WISE data; $r = -0.62$, $p < 0.001$ for NCSCD data).
  • Analysis of CMIP5 models revealed that the parameterization of thermal diffusivity explains 69% of the variation in simulated permafrost area relative to regions with mean annual air temperature below 0°C (Fig. 2b).
  • Simulations with the ORCHIDEE-MICT model showed that including the SOM insulation effect increased modelled present-day permafrost area by 33% (+3.4 million km²) and permafrost carbon stock (0-3 m depth) by 39% (+230 Pg C) compared to a scenario without SOM's thermal influence.
  • The study suggests that a loss of approximately 0.2 million km² of permafrost area could occur for every 1 kg C m⁻³ reduction in SOC, on average.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Scale Mismatch: A key limitation acknowledged is the spatial-scale mismatch between local soil temperature observations and the broader-scale soil property databases used. While efforts were made to reduce uncertainty (e.g., by excluding sites with large SOC density differences between databases), this remains a source of potential error.
  • Ground Ice Influence: The presence of ground ice can significantly alter soil thermal properties and contribute to scatter in observations. While the study found that the SOC-D correlation was unlikely confounded by ice content, it's a complex factor that adds to the heterogeneity of permafrost soils.
  • Model Simplifications: The study notes that CMIP5 models often do not explicitly represent the impact of SOM on soil physical properties, and that some models have simplified representations of snow thermodynamics.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need to explicitly represent the coupling between SOC and soil thermal dynamics in models used for permafrost projections. They also highlight the complex interactions between aboveground features (vegetation, snow cover), fire disturbances, and permafrost thaw, suggesting that future models should integrate these processes more comprehensively. The long-term response of soil carbon to warming remains a significant area of uncertainty, requiring further research into SOC formation and decomposition dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Permafrost warming and potential soil carbon (SOC) release after thawing may amplify climate change, yet model estimates of present-day and future permafrost extent vary widely, partly due to uncertainties in simulated soil temperature. Here, we derive thermal diffusivity, a key parameter in the soil thermal regime, from depth-specific measurements of monthly soil temperature at about 200 sites in the high latitude regions. We find that, among the tested soil properties including SOC, soil texture, bulk density, and soil moisture, SOC is the dominant factor controlling the variability of diffusivity among sites. Analysis of the CMIP5 model outputs reveals that the parameterization of thermal diffusivity drives the differences in simulated present-day permafrost extent among these models. The strong SOC-thermics coupling is crucial for projecting future permafrost dynamics, since the response of soil temperature and permafrost area to a rising air temperature would be impacted by potential changes in SOC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2019controls,
  author = {Dan Zhu and Philippe Ciais and Gerhard Krinner and Fabienne Maignan and Albert Jornet Puig and Gustaf Hugelius},
  title = {{Controls of soil organic matter on soil thermal dynamics in the northern high latitudes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-11103-1},
}
Figure