Controlling gain one photon at a time

Gregory W. Schwartz, Fred RiekeeLife 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

The primate retina can adjust its sensitivity (gain) to light incredibly quickly, even at the dimmest levels where individual photons are detected. This gain control is triggered by the absorption of single photons, not by averaging over many, and appears to be localized in the rod bipolar pathway, suggesting a sophisticated mechanism for rapid adaptation to changing light conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sensory systems, like our eyes, need to process an enormous range of input intensities. For example, the difference between a whisper and a rock concert is vast. To handle this, neurons must constantly adjust their sensitivity, a process called "gain control" or "adaptation." This is particularly challenging in low-light conditions, where visual signals are weak and prone to noise. The retina, specifically the rod photoreceptor pathway, is responsible for vision in dim light. It needs to be highly sensitive to detect single photons but also needs to prevent saturation when light levels increase even slightly. The core problem this paper addresses is how the primate retina achieves rapid and reliable gain control at the very onset of detectable light, where photon arrivals are infrequent and noisy.

Methods

The researchers used electrophysiological recordings from ex vivo primate retinas, specifically focusing on On parasol ganglion cells. These cells are known to receive significant input from rod photoreceptors at low light levels and are thus good indicators of rod pathway function.

Key techniques included:

  • Whole-cell voltage clamp and cell-attached recordings: To measure both synaptic currents and spike outputs from ganglion cells.
  • Controlled light stimulation: Precisely controlled flashes and backgrounds of varying intensities were presented to the retina.
  • Response analysis: Quantifying gain by measuring the response amplitude (spike count or integrated current) relative to the flash strength. Noise was measured as the standard deviation of the current before the flash.
  • Stimulus manipulation: Varying background intensity, flash strength, spatial patterns of light, and temporal sequences of light changes to probe different aspects of gain control.
  • Modeling: Using a Poisson distribution to model photon absorption and estimate the rod convergence and integration time required for observed gain changes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used ex vivo primate retinas as the biological system for their experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Single photons trigger gain changes: Surprisingly, the gain of retinal signals begins to decrease as soon as background lights are detectable, even at levels where only a tiny fraction of rods absorb a photon. This implies that individual photon absorptions, rather than a large average of photon counts, can initiate gain adjustments.
  • Rapid adaptation: Gain changes occur very quickly (within seconds) following changes in background light, demonstrating a remarkable speed in the adaptation process. This rapid response is crucial for maintaining visual performance in dynamic environments.
  • Mean, not noise, drives gain control: The study provides strong evidence that gain control is driven by the mean photon absorption rate, not by the fluctuations (noise) in photon arrivals. Experiments with fluctuating backgrounds showed that increased noise actually led to increased gain, contradicting models based on noise.
  • Spatial integration is key: The rapid gain changes require integration of signals from hundreds of rods, suggesting a mechanism located downstream of individual photoreceptors, likely in the rod bipolar pathway.
  • Novel site of gain control: The evidence points to a gain control site within the rod bipolar pathway, specifically at or downstream of the All amacrine cell, and importantly, before rod and cone signals are mixed in the cone bipolar cells. This is a novel finding, as previous studies had identified gain control sites at the photoreceptor and the rod bipolar-All amacrine synapse.

Key Results

  • Gain reduction near behavioral threshold: Retinal gain begins to decrease at background light levels of approximately 0.01-0.02 isomerizations per rod per second (R*/rod/s), which closely matches the onset of changes in human behavioral threshold.
  • Weber-like gain control: Over a wide range of backgrounds (~1000-fold), the gain of the retinal signal followed a modified Weber function, indicating a coordinated gain control across different light levels.
  • Rapid kinetics: Gain decreased with a time constant of ~0.1 seconds upon light onset and increased with a time constant of ~0.4 seconds upon light offset.
  • Spatial pooling: Gain changes transferred across the receptive field over distances of at least 100 µm, requiring integration of signals from hundreds of rods.
  • Rod-specific gain control: Gain changes in the rod pathway did not transfer to the cone pathway, indicating that the gain control mechanism acts specifically on rod signals before they are combined with cone signals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nonlinear processing in darkness: The paper mentions a nonlinear processing step that reduces gain in the dark, which is only partially captured in their figures due to experimental procedures. This is the subject of ongoing research.
  • Mechanistic details: While the study identifies a likely location for gain control (All amacrine cell or its gap junctions with cone bipolar cells), the precise molecular mechanisms are not detailed. Future work could involve recordings from these specific cell types to uncover these details.
  • Post-retinal contributions: The study suggests that post-retinal mechanisms contribute to the extended Rose-deVries region observed in human behavioral studies, implying that the retina alone doesn't account for all observed behavioral adaptation.
  • Modeling complexity: The paper uses a simplified model for gain reduction per photon. More complex models could be explored to fully capture the observed gain changes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Adaptation is a salient property of sensory processing. All adaptational or gain control mechanisms face the challenge of obtaining a reliable estimate of the property of the input to be adapted to and obtaining this estimate sufficiently rapidly to be useful. Here, we explore how the primate retina balances the need to change gain rapidly and reliably when photons arrive rarely at individual rod photoreceptors. We find that the weakest backgrounds that decrease the gain of the retinal output signals are similar to those that increase human behavioral threshold, and identify a novel site of gain control in the retinal circuitry. Thus, surprisingly, the gain of retinal signals begins to decrease essentially as soon as background lights are detectable; under these conditions, gain control does not rely on a highly averaged estimate of the photon count, but instead signals from individual photon absorptions trigger changes in gain. DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.00467.001.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schwartz2013controlling,
  author = {Gregory W. Schwartz and Fred Rieke},
  title = {{Controlling gain one photon at a time}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.00467},
}
Figure