Controlled microcrystallization for in situ photocrystallography: optimizing crystal size and habit

S. A. Lewis, Ben A. Coulson, Kenneth D. Harris, Anna J. Warren, Mark R. Warren, Lauren E. HatcherCrystEngComm 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a precise "fast antisolvent" crystallization method to engineer the size and shape of sodium nitroprusside (SNP) microcrystals. By shifting the crystal habit from long needles to tiny 50 μm plates, they significantly improved the reproducibility and quality of in situ photocrystallography data, while also discovering a previously unknown metastable solvate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photocrystallography—the study of crystal structures while they are being excited by light—is a powerful tool for understanding materials like optical switches and solar energy converters. However, it faces a major physical hurdle: light penetration.

If a crystal is too large or the wrong shape (e.g., a thick needle), the excitation light cannot reach the center of the material. This results in an uneven "excited state population," where the surface of the crystal has transformed but the core remains in the ground state, leading to messy, averaged data. Traditionally, researchers just picked the "best-looking" small crystals from a random batch. This paper addresses the need for a systematic, reproducible way to grow "designer" microcrystals—specifically thin plates roughly 50 μm wide—to ensure uniform light penetration and more reliable data.

Methods

The authors used Sodium Nitroprusside Dihydrate (SNP·2H2O), a classic inorganic photoswitch, as their test subject. They explored several crystallization strategies:

  • Slow Evaporation (Standard): The "natural" way SNP grows, which typically results in large, millimeter-scale "laths" (long, flat needles).
  • Fast Evaporative (Drop Casting): Rapidly drying a droplet to force quick nucleation.
  • Fast Antisolvent Crystallization (Novel Approach): This was the most successful method. A saturated aqueous solution of SNP was swiftly injected into a stirring antisolvent (like acetonitrile) at a controlled temperature (40 °C).

The team used Single Crystal X-ray Diffraction (SCXRD) and Face Indexing to map exactly how the crystals grew along different axes, and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to verify the final dimensions.

Datasets

As a chemistry and crystallography paper, the "datasets" consist of experimental batches and structural data:

  • Crystallographic Information Files (CIFs): New structural data for SNP and its new solvate were deposited at the Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre (CCDC 2440144).
  • Experimental Batches: Results from dozens of trials varying solvent, temperature, and concentration are summarized in Tables 1 and 2 of the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Breaking the Chain: The authors realized that SNP naturally grows into long needles because of "chains" of sodium cations and water molecules that propagate quickly in one direction ([100]). By using acetonitrile as an antisolvent, they likely disrupted these chains, slowing down growth in the "long" direction and forcing the crystal to grow into an oblate (plate-like) habit.
  • Reproducibility is Key: Controlled crystallization didn't just make the crystals smaller; it made them consistent. In steady-state photocrystallography tests, the engineered crystals showed a very narrow variation in excited-state population (11% ± 1%), whereas uncontrolled crystals showed much higher variability.
  • Serendipitous Discovery: While experimenting with methanol as a solvent, the team discovered a previously unknown 1:1 methanol:water solvate of SNP. This new phase is metastable and quickly transforms back to the standard dihydrate when exposed to air, explaining why it hadn't been found before.

Key Results

  • Target Achieved: The fast antisolvent method using acetonitrile at 40 °C successfully produced batches of rectangular plates with an average size of (51 ± 8) μm in the longest dimension.
  • Habit Shift: The crystal form was successfully shifted from prolate (needle-like, aspect ratio ~6:1) to oblate (plate-like, aspect ratio ~1.4:1).
  • Data Quality: The engineered microcrystals are perfectly sized for modern "fixed-target" serial crystallography grids used at synchrotrons and X-ray Free Electron Lasers (XFELs).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scale: The current methodology was optimized for small laboratory scales (approx. 5 mL). Scaling this up for industrial or high-throughput applications might require more complex flow-chemistry setups.
  • Metastability: The newly discovered methanol solvate is highly sensitive to the environment. The authors suggest that future work using Process Analytical Technology (PAT), like in-line Raman spectroscopy, could help track these transient phases in real-time during the crystallization process.
  • Generalization: While successful for SNP, the "rules" for disrupting growth chains might differ for other inorganic photoswitches, requiring bespoke optimization for each new material.

Summary updated

Abstract

Advanced microcrystallization of inorganic functional materials enables precise control of crystal particle attributes, influencing their useful behaviours e.g. photoswitch population.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lewis2025controlled,
  author = {S. A. Lewis and Ben A. Coulson and Kenneth D. Harris and Anna J. Warren and Mark R. Warren and Lauren E. Hatcher},
  title = {{Controlled microcrystallization for <i>in situ</i> photocrystallography: optimizing crystal size and habit}},
  booktitle = {CrystEngComm},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1039/d5ce00367a},
}

Loading related content...

Figure