Control Strategies in Multi-Player Pursuit and Evasion Game

Jung Soon Jang, Claire J. TomlinAIAA 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, computationally efficient method for designing control strategies in multi-player pursuit-evasion games. Instead of complex Hamilton-Jacobi-Isaacs (HJI) equation solving, it uses direct differentiation of value functions to generate simple, real-time implementable control laws. A key innovation is a new method for computing "reachable sets" using ordinary differential equations, which guarantees a minimum separation distance between players.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinating multiple autonomous agents, like drones or vehicles, for tasks such as formation flying or conflict resolution is a significant challenge. Pursuit-evasion games, where one or more "pursuers" try to intercept an "evader," are a fundamental problem in this domain. Traditional approaches to solving these games often rely on complex partial differential equations (PDEs) like the Hamilton-Jacobi-Isaacs (HJI) equations. While mathematically rigorous, these methods suffer from the "curse of dimensionality," making them computationally expensive and impractical for real-time implementation, especially in multi-player scenarios. Furthermore, ensuring a guaranteed minimum separation distance between players, crucial for safety, is difficult to achieve with these methods. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a simpler, more computationally tractable approach to multi-player pursuit-evasion control that guarantees safety.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its novel approach to deriving control strategies. Instead of solving the full HJI equations, the authors derive control laws by directly differentiating chosen "value functions" associated with each player. These value functions represent the players' objectives (e.g., minimizing distance to the evader for pursuers, maximizing distance for the evader). This direct differentiation yields analytical expressions for control inputs, which are simpler and more amenable to real-time implementation.

A significant innovation is the method for computing "reachable sets." These sets define regions in the state space from which capture is guaranteed or evasion is possible. The authors propose a method to compute a forward reachable set using a set of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) by propagating the dynamics forward in time. This is computationally much cheaper than traditional backward reachable set computations. To ensure a fixed minimum separation distance, they introduce a "reflection" technique for the reachable set, iteratively adjusting it until the desired safety margin is met.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a theoretical framework and demonstrates its effectiveness through simulations of a three-player pursuit-evasion game.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Value Function Differentiation for Simplicity: Deriving control strategies by differentiating value functions, rather than solving HJI equations, leads to significantly simpler and more practical control laws. This bypasses the computational burden of PDEs.
  • Forward Reachable Sets via ODEs: Computing reachable sets using ODEs propagated forward in time is a computationally efficient alternative to traditional backward methods. This makes real-time implementation more feasible.
  • "Reflection" for Guaranteed Separation: The novel "reflection" technique for reachable sets is crucial for guaranteeing a fixed minimum separation distance, independent of initial conditions, which is a critical safety requirement.
  • Flexibility in Performance Measures: The framework allows for exploring different value functions, enabling players to optimize for various performance metrics beyond just minimizing/maximizing distance.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates its approach through simulations of a three-player pursuit-evasion game. The proposed control strategies, derived from value function differentiation and combined with the computed reachable sets, successfully prevented capture in several scenarios. Specifically, the simulations showed that:

  • In symmetric initial configurations, the evader could maintain a straight-line path and avoid capture.
  • In asymmetric configurations, the evader could still evade by reacting to the nearest threat, especially when pursuers were on the boundary of the reachable set.
  • The framework can adapt to changing numbers of players, with the evader adjusting its strategy when new pursuers are introduced.
  • The paper also shows that using a different pursuer value function (focused on "leading" the evader) can lead to faster capture, highlighting the impact of objective functions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-Optimal Strategies: The paper acknowledges that the derived strategies are not necessarily optimal in the game-theoretic sense. They are designed for safety and implementability rather than achieving the absolute best outcome for each player.
  • No Explicit Cooperation: The current strategies are derived assuming individual players minimize their own value functions, without explicit cooperation among pursuers.
  • Future Work: The authors are actively studying cooperative strategies where individual pursuers consider the control strategies of others to maximize collective benefits. This is a natural next step to enhance the overall performance and coordination of the multi-agent system.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a new methodology for solving multi-player pursuit and evasion games. The proposed control strategies are derived from direct difierentiation of chosen value (or level set) functions, instead of solving the associated Hamilton Jacobi Isaacs (HJI) equations. The corresponding strategies ofier a simple form of the control laws that can be implemented on real-time control systems for autonomous vehicles. In order to guarantee a minimum separation distance between players, a new method to compute a reachable set, which only requires a set of ordinary difierential equations, is developed. We also explore difierent value functions which lead to difierent performance measures for some players. We illustrate our approach on a three player pursuit and evasion game and present simulation results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jang2005control,
  author = {Jung Soon Jang and Claire J. Tomlin},
  title = {{Control Strategies in Multi-Player Pursuit and Evasion Game}},
  booktitle = {AIAA},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2005-6239},
}
Figure