Contribution of DNA breathing to physical interactions with transcription factors

W. R. Butt, Ben Lai, Tsu-Pei Chiu, Manish Bhattarai, Sheng Qian, A. R. Bishop, Jubao Duan, Boian S. Alexandrov, Remo Rohs, Xin HebioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how "DNA breathing" – the transient opening of DNA double helix – influences transcription factor (TF) binding. By analyzing both in vitro and in vivo data, the researchers found that DNA breathing features near TF binding sites are correlated with binding affinity, suggesting it plays a significant role in gene regulation beyond just sequence recognition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gene expression is tightly controlled by transcription factors (TFs) binding to specific DNA sequences. Traditionally, this binding has been understood primarily through the recognition of short DNA "motifs." However, genetic studies have revealed that DNA variations outside these core motifs can significantly impact TF binding and gene regulation. This suggests that other factors, beyond just the DNA sequence itself, are at play. One such factor is the physical properties of DNA. While DNA shape has been explored, this paper focuses on "DNA breathing," a dynamic process where the DNA double helix transiently opens due to thermal motion, forming temporary "bubbles." Despite its potential importance, the role of DNA breathing in TF-DNA interactions has been underexplored, especially across a wide range of TFs. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically investigating the relationship between DNA breathing features and TF binding.

Methods

The researchers employed two main approaches to quantify DNA breathing and its correlation with TF binding:

  • DNA Flipping Probability: This feature captures the likelihood of individual base pairs within the DNA helix transiently flipping out. It's calculated based on molecular dynamics simulations of DNA.
  • DNA Bubble Propensity: This feature quantifies the probability of DNA bubble formation at specific locations, considering both the displacement of base pairs and the length of the opened region. This is also derived from molecular simulations.

These DNA breathing features were then correlated with TF binding data obtained from two types of experiments:

  • Genomic-context protein-binding microarray (gcPBM): An in vitro method that measures TF binding affinity to short DNA fragments in a more natural genomic context.
  • ChIP-seq: An in vivo method that identifies DNA regions bound by TFs within a cell.

To analyze the data, they used statistical methods including correlation analysis and linear regression, carefully controlling for the influence of known TF binding motifs.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  • gcPBM dataset: This dataset contained approximately 23,000 sequences, each 36 bp long, with measured binding affinities for three bHLH TF complexes (MAX, MAD, MYC). This dataset provided in vitro binding data.
  • ChIP-seq dataset: This larger dataset comprised over 880,000 sequences, each 200 bp long, with TF binding status (bound or unbound) derived from ChIP-seq experiments for 64 different TFs. This dataset provided in vivo binding data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DNA breathing isn't just a curiosity; it's a player in TF binding: The study provides strong evidence that the dynamic opening and closing of DNA (breathing) is not merely a passive physical property but actively influences how TFs interact with DNA.
  • Beyond sequence: Physical DNA properties matter: This work reinforces the growing understanding that TF binding is a complex interplay of sequence recognition and physical DNA characteristics, moving beyond a purely motif-centric view.
  • Different TFs, different mechanisms: The impact of DNA breathing on TF binding is not uniform. Some TFs seem to benefit from increased DNA breathing, potentially facilitating binding, while others might be hindered, suggesting diverse structural readout mechanisms.
  • Bubbles can enhance or interfere: The presence of DNA bubbles near TF binding sites can either promote or impede binding, depending on the specific TF, highlighting the nuanced role of this phenomenon.

Key Results

  • In vitro (gcPBM):
    • For MAX and MYC, higher average DNA flipping probability at motif sites correlated positively with binding affinity.
  • The presence of DNA bubbles generally correlated with higher TF binding affinity for MAD, MAX, and MYC.
  • Even after controlling for the influence of TF motifs, DNA bubble propensity remained significantly correlated with binding affinity for MAX and MYC.
  • In vivo (ChIP-seq):
    • Analysis of 44 TFs revealed that DNA flipping probability profiles at motif positions were significantly correlated with TF binding status for 39 of them.
  • MAFK showed the strongest positive correlation, while ZBTB7A exhibited the most negative correlation between flipping probability and binding.
  • Bubble propensity analysis on a subset of TFs also showed correlations with binding, with MAFK showing a positive association and ZBTB7A a negative one.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical vs. Causal Proof: The study demonstrates strong statistical correlations between DNA breathing features and TF binding. However, it acknowledges that direct proof of causality is still lacking.
  • Conclusive evidence for some TFs: For certain TFs, it remains inconclusive whether higher or lower DNA breathing correlates with higher binding affinity.
  • Future Directions:
    • Genetic Variation Studies: Investigating genetic variants that affect DNA breathing (beyond direct motif recognition) and their impact on TF binding would provide stronger causal evidence.
  • Quantitative Models: Developing predictive models that quantitatively incorporate DNA breathing features into TF-DNA interaction predictions, potentially using deep learning or biophysical principles, is a promising avenue.
  • TF Family and Structure-Based Analysis: Exploring DNA breathing from the perspective of TF families and their specific binding structures could help explain the observed variations in breathing's role across different TFs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Interaction between transcription factors (TFs) and DNA plays a key role in regulating gene expression. It is generally believed that these interactions are controlled through recognition of DNA core motifs by TFs. Nevertheless, several studies pointed out the limitation of this view, in particular, DNA sequence variants influencing TF binding are often located outside of core motifs. One possible explanation is that the physical properties of DNA may play a role in TF-DNA interactions. Recent studies have supported the importance of DNA shape features, especially in flanking regions of core motifs. Another important physical property of DNA is DNA breathing, the spontaneous opening of double-stranded DNA through thermal motions. But there have been few genomic studies of the role of DNA breathing in TF-DNA interactions. In this work, we analyzed in vitro TF-DNA binding data of three TFs and found that DNA breathing features inside or near core motifs are correlated with binding affinity. This suggests that these TFs may prefer locally and temporally melted DNA formed through breathing. We extended the analysis to 44 TFs with in vivo ChIP-seq binding data. We found that for a large proportion of TFs, their breathing features in or near core motifs are associated with binding, but the sign and magnitude of these associations vary substantially across TF families. Altogether, our study supports the hypothesis that DNA breathing features near binding motifs contribute to TF-DNA interactions.
BibTeX
@misc{butt2025contribution,
  author = {W. R. BUTT and Ben Lai and Tsu-Pei Chiu and Manish Bhattarai and Sheng Qian and A. R. Bishop and Jubao Duan and Boian S. Alexandrov and Remo Rohs and Xin He},
  title = {{Contribution of DNA breathing to physical interactions with transcription factors}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.01.20.633840},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure