Abstract
The in-plane resistivity and Hall coefficient have been measured for the single-layer compound $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_2\text{CuO}_{6+\delta}$ for the whole range of doping states. The deviation of the Hall coefficient $R_H$ from a high-temperature linear behavior and the temperature dependence of the Hall angle are both only weakly dependent on doping, contrasting with $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_{2-x}\text{La}_x\text{CuO}_{6+\delta}$ and $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_2\text{CaCu}_2\text{O}_{8+\delta}$. This is in contradiction with former proposals that the transverse transport detects the formation of incoherent Cooper pairs in the pseudogap state. Conversely, the analysis of the data using a phenomenological angle-dependent scattering rate clearly allows us to distinguish between underdoped and overdoped states, and we propose that the maximum in $R_H(T)$ simply arises due to the combination of a large $T$-independent scattering rate and an anisotropic temperature-dependent one.
Introduction
In high-temperature cuprate superconductors, the "normal state" above the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) exhibits anomalous transport properties. A persistent mystery is the behavior of the Hall coefficient ($R_H$), which often shows a distinct maximum as a function of temperature. Many theories suggest this maximum marks the onset of the "pseudogap" phase—a state where electrons form incoherent Cooper pairs before the onset of long-range superconductivity. This study investigates $\text{Bi}_2\text{Sr}_2\text{CuO}_{6+\delta}$ (Bi-2201), a single-layer cuprate with a relatively low $T_c$ (~20 K), to test whether these Hall effect anomalies truly track the pseudogap phase diagram.
Methods
The researchers utilized a single epitaxial thin film of Bi-2201, sweeping through the entire doping range from underdoped to overdoped by annealing the sample in oxygen or vacuum. They measured in-plane resistivity ($\rho$) and the Hall coefficient ($R_H$) using a 6-contact geometry. To interpret the data, they applied a phenomenological "hot spot/cold spot" model, which assumes anisotropic electron scattering across the Fermi surface—intense at "hot spots" (likely due to spin fluctuations) and weaker at "cold spots."
Key Insights and Results
The primary finding is that the temperature $T_H$, where $R_H$ deviates from high-temperature linearity, is nearly independent of doping in Bi-2201. This is a significant observation because the pseudogap is famously sensitive to doping levels.
As shown in Figure 2, $R_H$ consistently peaks between 90–100 K across all doping states. This doping independence suggests that the $R_H$ maximum is not a direct signature of the pseudogap or pre-formed Cooper pairs. Instead, the authors propose that the behavior arises from a combination of a large, temperature-independent scattering rate (disorder) and an anisotropic, temperature-dependent one. The significant disorder in Bi-2201 may be linked to its inherent incommensurate crystallographic modulation.
Figure 5 highlights the unique behavior of Bi-2201 compared to other cuprates. While $T_c$ (filled circles) follows the typical dome shape, $T_H$ (open circles) remains relatively flat in Bi-2201 (left panel). This contrasts with La-doped Bi-2201 and Bi-2212, where $T_H$ shows a much stronger dependence on doping, often tracking the pseudogap temperature.
Conclusion
The study concludes that the Hall effect anomalies in Bi-2201 are primarily driven by anisotropic scattering and structural disorder rather than pseudogap physics. By incorporating a constant disorder term into their model, the authors successfully reproduced the observed $R_H(T)$ maximum without needing to invoke superconducting fluctuations. Future research will focus on identifying the specific microscopic source of the temperature-independent scattering, whether it arises from structural modulations or specific chemical impurities.
Summary updated