Contrastive-Adversarial and Diffusion: Exploring pre-training and fine-tuning strategies for sulcal identification

Michail Mamalakis, Héloïse de Vareilles, Shun-Chin Jim Wu, Ingrid Agartz, Lynn Egeland Mørch-Johnsen, Jane R. Garrison, Jon S. Simons, Pietro Lio, John Suckling, Graham K. MurrayarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Identifying small, highly variable brain structures like the paracingulate sulcus (PCS) remains a significant challenge in neuroimaging. This study systematically benchmarks four pre-training and four fine-tuning strategies using a Swin-UNETR architecture on the TOP-OSLO cohort. Our results indicate that combining reconstruction or adversarial pre-training with "top-level" fine-tuning—updating only the final 10% of the model—provides an optimal balance of segmentation accuracy and computational efficiency, outperforming popular methods like Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) in this specific medical imaging context.

Introduction

The paracingulate sulcus (PCS) is a secondary brain structure characterized by significant inter-individual variation in shape, size, and location. For computer vision models, identifying the PCS is a "needle-in-a-haystack" problem. While the field has seen a surge in new training paradigms—including diffusion models, contrastive learning, and parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)—there is no consensus on which combination is best suited for niche medical segmentation tasks. This paper fills that gap by evaluating these techniques to find the most efficient path to high-precision neuroimaging.

Methods

The researchers employed a Swin-UNETR architecture, a 3D transformer-based neural network, to test a matrix of strategies across two training phases:

Pre-training (Self-Supervised)

  • Simple Reconstruction: Learning to recreate the input brain image.
  • Adversarial Learning: A GAN-style setup to distinguish real from reconstructed images.
  • Contrastive Learning: Grouping similar brain features together.
  • Diffusion Denoising: Recovering images from added noise.

Fine-tuning (Task-Specific)

  • Full Tuning: Updating the entire network.
  • Decoder Tuning: Updating only the decoder portion.
  • Top-Tuning: Updating only the last 10% of the model's parameters.
  • LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation): Injecting trainable low-rank matrices into linear layers.
Overview of the pre-training and fine-tuning pipeline for multi-task learning (classification and segmentation) of the PCS region.

The study utilized the TOP-OSLO cohort, comprising T1-weighted MRI scans from 596 subjects, focusing on the white-grey surface matter of the left hemisphere.

Key Results and Insights

Performance of Pre-training Strategies

Simple reconstruction and adversarial pre-training captured structural nuances better than diffusion models. Notably, diffusion denoising was significantly more computationally expensive (nearly 3,500 seconds per epoch) compared to simple reconstruction (179 seconds) without providing a performance advantage for this task.

The "Top-Tuning" Advantage

Tuning just the top 10% of the decoder parameters achieved peak performance, with classification accuracy exceeding 60% when paired with reconstruction pre-training. This strategy maintained high segmentation fidelity while significantly reducing GPU memory requirements and training time.

Limitations of LoRA in Vision

While LoRA is a standard for fine-tuning Large Language Models, it struggled in this spatial context. The high complexity of small brain regions appears to require more substantial weight updates than the low-rank approximations LoRA provides.

Conclusion

Top-tuning consistently delivered average Dice scores exceeding 50% across pre-training simulations. By hovering around 200 seconds per epoch and keeping GPU memory allocation below 92.20%, this approach makes high-precision neuroimaging more accessible for researchers with limited hardware. Future work will focus on testing these models against Out-of-Distribution (OOD) cohorts to ensure generalizability across different scanners and populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the last decade, computer vision has witnessed the establishment of various training and learning approaches. Techniques like adversarial learning, contrastive learning, diffusion denoising learning, and ordinary reconstruction learning have become standard, representing state-of-the-art methods extensively employed for fully training or pre-training networks across various vision tasks. The exploration of fine-tuning approaches has emerged as a current focal point, addressing the need for efficient model tuning with reduced GPU memory usage and time costs while enhancing overall performance, as exemplified by methodologies like low-rank adaptation (LoRA). Key questions arise: which pre-training technique yields optimal results - adversarial, contrastive, reconstruction, or diffusion denoising? How does the performance of these approaches vary as the complexity of fine-tuning is adjusted? This study aims to elucidate the advantages of pre-training techniques and fine-tuning strategies to enhance the learning process of neural networks in independent identical distribution (IID) cohorts. We underscore the significance of fine-tuning by examining various cases, including full tuning, decoder tuning, top-level tuning, and fine-tuning of linear parameters using LoRA. Systematic summaries of model performance and efficiency are presented, leveraging metrics such as accuracy, time cost, and memory efficiency. To empirically demonstrate our findings, we focus on a multi-task segmentation-classification challenge involving the paracingulate sulcus (PCS) using different 3D Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) architectures by using the TOP-OSLO cohort comprising 596 subjects.
BibTeX
@misc{mamalakis2024contrastive,
  author = {Michail Mamalakis and Héloïse de Vareilles and Shun-Chin Jim Wu and Ingrid Agartz and Lynn Egeland Mørch-Johnsen and Jane R. Garrison and Jon S. Simons and Pietro Lio and John Suckling and Graham K. Murray},
  title = {{Contrastive-Adversarial and Diffusion: Exploring pre-training and fine-tuning strategies for sulcal identification}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.19204},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.19204},
}
Figure