Contrasting effects of CO 2 fertilization, land-use change and warming on seasonal amplitude of Northern Hemisphere CO 2 exchange

Ana Bastos, Philippe Ciais, Frédéric Chevallier, Christian Rödenbeck, Ashley P. Ballantyne, Fabienne Maignan, Yi Yin, Marcos Fernández‐Martínez, Pierre Friedlingstein, Josep Peñuelas, Shilong L. Piao, Stephen Sitch, William K. Smith, Xuhui Wang, Zaichun Zhu, Vanessa Haverd, Etsushi Kato, Atul K. Jain, Sebastian Lienert, Danica Lombardozzi, Julia E. M. S. Nabel, Philippe Peylin, Benjamin Poulter, Dan ZhuAtmospheric 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

The seasonal amplitude of atmospheric CO2 in the Northern Hemisphere has been increasing, but the drivers behind this trend have been debated. This study integrates atmospheric inversion data and land-surface models to show that CO2 fertilization is the primary driver, while warming has a negative effect, and land-use change plays a minimal role. These findings are crucial for refining our understanding of the global carbon cycle and improving climate models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Earth's atmosphere acts as a giant sink and source for carbon dioxide (CO2), and understanding how this exchange is changing is vital for predicting future climate. One observed phenomenon is the increasing "seasonal-cycle amplitude" (SCA) of atmospheric CO2 in the Northern Hemisphere's high latitudes. This means the difference between the lowest CO2 concentration in summer (when plants absorb CO2) and the highest in winter (when plants release CO2) is growing. While this suggests increased CO2 uptake by ecosystems, the exact reasons for this trend have been unclear and hotly debated. Potential drivers include increased CO2 fertilization (plants growing more due to higher CO2), land-use changes (like deforestation or agricultural expansion), and warming temperatures. This paper aims to disentangle these factors by comparing different data sources and models.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach, combining two main types of data and analysis:

  • Atmospheric Inversions (Top-Down): These methods use atmospheric CO2 concentration measurements from monitoring stations and atmospheric transport models to infer where CO2 is being absorbed or released at the Earth's surface. Two inversion systems (CAMS and CarboScope) were used to estimate CO2 fluxes from 1980 to 2015.
  • Land-Surface Models (LSMs) (Bottom-Up): These are complex computer models that simulate the exchange of energy, water, and carbon between the land surface and the atmosphere. The study utilized an ensemble of 11 state-of-the-art LSMs from the TRENDY intercomparison project. These models were run with different "factorial simulations" to isolate the effects of:
  • CO2 fertilization (Simulation S1)
    • Climate change (difference between S2 and S1)
    • Land-use and land-cover change (LULCC) (difference between S3 and S2)
  • Statistical Attribution: General linear models (GLMs) were used to statistically link the observed trends in SCANBP (Seasonal Cycle Amplitude of Net Biome Productivity) to various potential drivers (e.g., temperature, precipitation, CO2 concentration, land-use changes) derived from the LSMs and inversion data.

Datasets

The study relied on several key datasets:

  • Atmospheric CO2 Concentration Data: Used by the inversion systems to estimate surface fluxes.
  • Atmospheric Transport Model Outputs: Used by inversions to simulate how CO2 moves through the atmosphere.
  • Land-Surface Model Outputs: Specifically, Net Biome Productivity (NBP) from the TRENDYv6 simulations (S0, S1, S2, S3) for the period 1980-2015.
  • Land-Use and Land-Cover Change Data: Primarily the LUH2v2h dataset, which provides historical land-use states and transitions.
  • Satellite-Based Vegetation Data: Including Leaf Area Index (LAI), Net Primary Production (NPP), and Above-Ground Biomass (AGB) stocks from datasets like GIMMS LAI3g, MODIS NPP, and ESA-CCI land cover. These were used for validation and to assess trends in vegetation activity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CO2 Fertilization Reigns Supreme: The most significant finding is the strong evidence pointing to CO2 fertilization as the dominant driver of the increasing seasonal CO2 exchange amplitude in the Northern Hemisphere. This suggests that plants are responding positively to rising atmospheric CO2 levels by taking up more carbon during the growing season.
  • Warming's Double-Edged Sword: Counterintuitively, warming temperatures, particularly during the growing season, appear to have a negative effect on SCANBP trends. This challenges the simple assumption that warmer conditions automatically lead to greater CO2 uptake. The paper suggests this might be due to increased respiration or soil moisture limitations.
  • Land-Use Change is a Minor Player: Contrary to some previous hypotheses, this study found little evidence to support land-use change as a major contributor to the observed SCANBP trends, especially in high latitudes where natural ecosystems dominate.
  • Model Biases and Turnover Times: The study highlights that land-surface models often struggle to accurately capture SCANBP trends, particularly the negative impact of warming. The authors suggest that the sensitivity of simulated microbial respiration to temperature in LSMs could be a key factor in explaining these biases and that SCANBP trends might serve as a valuable constraint for improving estimates of model turnover times for carbon.

Key Results

  • Both atmospheric inversions and land-surface models consistently show increasing SCANBP trends at higher latitudes (north of 40° N).
  • CO2 fertilization was identified as the most important factor explaining SCANBP trends in both latitudinal bands (L>40N and L25-40N) across inversions and LSMs.
  • Warming showed a statistically significant negative correlation with SCANBP trends, particularly in the mid-latitudes.
  • Land-use change was found to have a negligible contribution to SCANBP trends, with some models even indicating a slight negative effect.
  • LSMs generally reproduced the latitudinal patterns of SCANBP trends but often underestimated their magnitude compared to inversions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Uncertainties: The study acknowledges that LSMs have limitations in representing complex processes like soil insulation effects, seasonal acclimation of respiration, and the interaction between carbon and nitrogen cycles. These can lead to biases in simulated SCANBP trends.
  • Data Sparsity: While atmospheric inversion networks have improved, they still have limitations in constraining fluxes at very fine spatial scales.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further development of LSMs is needed to better represent processes like soil respiration's response to temperature and water limitations. They also propose that SCANBP trends could be a valuable metric for constraining model turnover times of short-lived carbon pools, which are crucial for accurately simulating the carbon cycle's response to climate change. Investigating the complex interactions between warming, soil moisture, and respiration in high-latitude ecosystems is highlighted as a key area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Continuous atmospheric CO2 monitoring data indicate an increase in the amplitude of seasonal CO2-cycle exchange (SCANBP) in northern high latitudes. The major drivers of enhanced SCANBP remain unclear and intensely debated, with land-use change, CO2 fertilization and warming being identified as likely contributors. We integrated CO2-flux data from two atmospheric inversions (consistent with atmospheric records) and from 11 state-of-the-art land-surface models (LSMs) to evaluate the relative importance of individual contributors to trends and drivers of the SCANBP of CO2 fluxes for 1980–2015. The LSMs generally reproduce the latitudinal increase in SCANBP trends within the inversions range. Inversions and LSMs attribute SCANBP increase to boreal Asia and Europe due to enhanced vegetation productivity (in LSMs) and point to contrasting effects of CO2 fertilization (positive) and warming (negative) on SCANBP. Our results do not support land-use change as a key contributor to the increase in SCANBP. The sensitivity of simulated microbial respiration to temperature in LSMs explained biases in SCANBP trends, which suggests that SCANBP could help to constrain model turnover times.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bastos2019contrasting,
  author = {Ana Bastos and Philippe Ciais and Frédéric Chevallier and Christian Rödenbeck and Ashley P. Ballantyne and Fabienne Maignan and Yi Yin and Marcos Fernández‐Martínez and Pierre Friedlingstein and Josep Peñuelas and Shilong L. Piao and Stephen Sitch and William K. Smith and Xuhui Wang and Zaichun Zhu and Vanessa Haverd and Etsushi Kato and Atul K. Jain and Sebastian Lienert and Danica Lombardozzi and Julia E. M. S. Nabel and Philippe Peylin and Benjamin Poulter and Dan Zhu},
  title = {{Contrasting effects of CO <sub>2</sub> fertilization, land-use change and warming on seasonal amplitude of Northern Hemisphere CO <sub>2</sub> exchange}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-19-12361-2019},
}
Figure