Contrast and stability of the axon diameter index from microstructure imaging with diffusion MRI

Tim B. Dyrby, Lise Vejby S�gaard, Matt G. Hall, Maurice Ptito, Daniel C. AlexanderMagnetic 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the maximum gradient strength (Gmax) of an MRI scanner affects the accuracy and contrast of diffusion MRI-based axon diameter measurements. They found that increasing Gmax significantly improves the ability to differentiate between axon sizes, leading to clearer anatomical maps of white matter microstructure, and highlights the need for higher Gmax in future MRI systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diffusion MRI (dMRI) is a powerful tool for non-invasively probing the microstructure of the brain, including the diameter of axons, which are the long, slender projections of nerve cells. Accurately measuring axon diameter is crucial for understanding brain development, aging, and neurological disorders. However, existing dMRI techniques face challenges in achieving sufficient contrast and stability in these measurements, especially when dealing with a wide range of axon sizes within a single voxel. This paper specifically addresses how the limitations of scanner hardware, particularly the maximum gradient strength (Gmax), impact the sensitivity and reliability of axon diameter estimation using the ActiveAx technique.

Methods

The researchers utilized the ActiveAx technique, which employs a minimal model of white matter diffusion (MMWMD) to estimate axon diameter. This model, based on pulsed-gradient-spin-echo (PGSE) sequences, aims to provide orientationally invariant indices of axon diameter and density.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Protocol Optimization: They used an active-imaging optimization algorithm to design dMRI acquisition protocols tailored for different Gmax values (60, 140, 200, and 300 mT/m). This algorithm aims to find the optimal set of diffusion parameters (like diffusion time and gradient strength) to maximize sensitivity to axon diameter.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: To rigorously test the influence of Gmax and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), they employed Monte Carlo simulations. These simulations generated synthetic dMRI data from anatomically plausible white matter substrates with known axon diameter distributions (ADDs). This allowed for controlled experiments to isolate the effects of Gmax.
  • Ex Vivo Monkey Brain Data: Real-world validation was performed using diffusion MRI data acquired from a fixed monkey brain. This allowed them to compare simulation results with actual biological data.
  • Analysis of Regions of Interest (ROIs): They analyzed specific white matter tracts (corpus callosum, corticospinal tract, and cingulum) within the monkey brain to assess the contrast and stability of the estimated axon diameter maps across different Gmax settings.

Datasets

  • Synthetic Datasets: Monte Carlo simulations generated synthetic, noise-free dMRI data from 44 different white matter substrates with varying axon diameter distributions (ADDs) and fiber densities. These were used to systematically evaluate the impact of Gmax and SNR.
  • Fixed Monkey Brain Dataset: Diffusion MRI data was acquired from one perfusion-fixed Vervet monkey brain. This dataset served as the primary biological data for evaluating the practical performance of the optimized protocols.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gmax is King for Contrast: The most striking finding is that increasing Gmax dramatically improves the contrast between different axon diameter distributions. This means that higher Gmax allows for clearer visualization of microstructural differences in white matter.
  • SNR is Secondary to Gmax: While higher SNR is generally beneficial, the study demonstrates that Gmax has a much stronger impact on contrast than SNR. Even with lower SNR, higher Gmax can yield better differentiation of axon sizes.
  • Window of Sensitivity: Pulsed-gradient-spin-echo (PGSE) based methods have a limited window of sensitivity for axon diameters. There's a lower bound (around 2.5 µm, dependent on Gmax) below which axons are indistinguishable, and an upper bound (around 10 µm) beyond which sensitivity decreases due to trade-offs between diffusion time and T2 relaxation.
  • Trade-offs in Protocol Design: The optimization process balances the need for short echo times (TE) to maximize SNR with the requirement for long diffusion times to probe larger axon diameters. Higher Gmax allows for shorter diffusion times while still achieving sufficient diffusion weighting, thus mitigating some of these trade-offs.
  • Clinical Relevance: The findings are directly relevant to the development of future clinical MRI scanners, emphasizing the need for systems with higher gradient strengths to unlock the full potential of microstructure imaging.

Key Results

  • Reduced Variation: Increasing Gmax from 60 mT/m to 300 mT/m significantly reduced the within-voxel variation of the estimated axon diameter index (a').
  • Improved Contrast: Higher Gmax values (140 mT/m and above) revealed anatomical details in the fixed monkey brain that were not discernible at lower Gmax, leading to more coherent and spatially coherent axon diameter maps.
  • Lower Bound Identification: Simulations confirmed a lower bound of approximately 2.5 µm for reliably differentiating axon diameters, which is slightly dependent on Gmax.
  • Upper Bound Observation: Simulations also indicated an upper bound of around 10 µm for PGSE-based measurements, beyond which sensitivity decreases. This is due to the limited diffusion time achievable within practical scan parameters.
  • SNR vs. Gmax Impact: For Gmax = 60 mT/m, the variation in a' was substantial. Increasing Gmax to 140 mT/m and above led to a gradual decrease in this variation, even when SNR was adjusted.

Limitations and Future Work

  • T2 Relaxation: The study acknowledges that the T2 relaxation time of fixed tissue (around 50 ms) limits the achievable diffusion times, impacting sensitivity to larger axon diameters. This is particularly relevant for fixed brain tissue.
  • Upper Bound Sensitivity: While higher Gmax improves sensitivity, there's still a limit to how large an axon diameter can be reliably estimated using PGSE sequences. The study suggests that stimulated echo sequences might be beneficial for increasing sensitivity to larger axons or in scenarios with even lower T2.
  • Quantitative vs. Contrast: The authors note that while the absolute values of the axon diameter index might not be perfectly quantitative due to various factors, the contrast provided by these maps is highly valuable for understanding brain anatomy and function.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests exploring alternative gradient waveforms beyond rectangular pulses (e.g., switching or oscillating) to potentially improve sensitivity to smaller axon diameters and reduce the lower bound. Further work is also needed to correlate these findings with electron microscopy data for a more definitive validation. The translation of these findings to in vivo imaging is also a key future direction, noting that higher diffusivity and T2 in vivo might shift the sensitivity window.

Summary updated

Abstract

The ActiveAx technique fits the minimal model of white matter diffusion to diffusion MRI data acquired using optimized protocols that provide orientationally invariant indices of axon diameter and density. We investigated how limitations of the available maximal gradient strength (Gmax) on a scanner influence the sensitivity to a range of axon diameters. Multishell high-angular-diffusion-imaging (HARDI) protocols for Gmax of 60, 140, 200, and 300 mT/m were optimized for the pulsed-gradient-spin-echo (PGSE) sequence. Data were acquired on a fixed monkey brain and Monte-Carlo simulations supported the results. Increasing Gmax reduces within-voxel variation of the axon diameter index and improves contrast beyond what is achievable with higher signal-to-noise ratio. Simulations reveal an upper bound on the axon diameter (∼10 μm) that pulsed-gradient-spin-echo measurements are sensitive to, due to a trade-off between short T2 and the long diffusion time needed to probe larger axon diameters. A lower bound (∼2.5 μm) slightly dependent on Gmax was evident, below which axon diameters are identifiable as small, but impossible to differentiate. These results emphasize the key-role of Gmax for enhancing contrast between axon diameter distributions and are, therefore, relevant in general for microstructure imaging methods and highlight the need for increased Gmax on future commercial systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dyrby2012contrast,
  author = {Tim B. Dyrby and Lise Vejby S�gaard and Matt G. Hall and Maurice Ptito and Daniel C. Alexander},
  title = {{Contrast and stability of the axon diameter index from microstructure imaging with diffusion MRI}},
  booktitle = {Magnetic},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1002/mrm.24501},
}
Figure