Contraction dynamics of biological muscles : mechanical and thermodynamical prediction, and experimental verification

Daniel HäufleOPUS 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the unique dynamic properties of biological muscles, particularly their non-linear force-velocity relationship, contribute to stable and efficient movement control, using hopping as a model system. It proposes a novel information-theoretic measure for quantifying control effort, demonstrating that muscles significantly reduce this effort compared to artificial actuators, and presents a new macroscopic model for artificial muscles that replicates these beneficial properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how biological systems generate complex and elegant movements is a fundamental challenge. While physics provides the underlying principles, isolating and studying the specific mechanisms of biological movement generation is difficult due to ethical constraints and the interconnected nature of biological systems. This thesis aims to bridge this gap by investigating the role of intrinsic muscle properties in movement control, proposing a new way to quantify control effort, and developing a bio-inspired artificial muscle concept. Specifically, it addresses:

  • The contribution of muscle dynamics to movement stability: How do the inherent properties of muscles, like their force-velocity relationship, help stabilize movements like hopping?
  • The concept of "exploitive actuation": Can biological systems achieve efficient control by leveraging their mechanical properties, thus reducing the need for complex neural control?
  • Quantifying control effort: How can we objectively compare the control effort required by biological systems versus artificial actuators, given their vastly different mechanisms?
  • The physical origin of muscle properties: Can the characteristic hyperbolic force-velocity relationship of muscles be explained by simpler mechanical components, and can this be replicated in artificial actuators?

Methods

The paper employs a multi-faceted approach, combining theoretical modeling, numerical simulations, and experimental validation, following a "test trilogy" methodology:

  • Simulation Studies:
    • Hopping Models: One-dimensional hopping models were developed with varying levels of detail for muscle properties (from simple linear to complex Hill-type models). These models were used to investigate the influence of muscle properties and different control strategies (feed-forward, feedback, and combined) on hopping stability and performance.
  • Information Theory for Control Effort: A novel measure of control effort was developed based on information theory. This quantifies the amount of information required by a controller to achieve a task, allowing for system-independent comparisons between different actuators (e.g., muscle vs. DC motor).
  • Artificial Muscle Model: A macroscopic model of a contractile element was developed, based on the interaction of three mechanical components (active element, parallel damper, serial element), to explain the physical origin of the hyperbolic force-velocity relation.
  • Hardware Experiments:
    • Artificial Muscle Prototype: A hardware prototype of the proposed artificial muscle model was built, implementing the three mechanical components using electric motors and a spring.
  • Quick Release Experiments: Isotonic and inertial mass quick release experiments were performed on the hardware prototype and compared to numerical simulations and biological data to validate the model and investigate the force-velocity characteristics.
  • Behavioral Comparison:
    • Biological Data: Results from biological muscle experiments (e.g., force-velocity data of rat gastrocnemius muscle) were used to compare and validate the models.
  • Hopping Performance: Simulated and experimental hopping performance was compared to human hopping data.

Datasets

  • Biological Muscle Data: Data from existing literature on rat gastrocnemius muscle force-velocity relationships (van Zandwijk et al., 1996) was used for comparison and parameter identification.
  • Human Hopping Data: Data on human hopping performance and frequency from existing literature was used for comparison.
  • DC Motor Parameters: Parameters for a commercially available DC motor were used for the EFB model.

No new datasets were explicitly introduced for training in the machine learning sense, but experimental data was collected from the developed hardware.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Muscle Properties are Key to Stability: The non-linear, hyperbolic force-velocity relationship of muscles is crucial for stabilizing periodic movements like hopping, more so than the specific control strategy employed.
  • Exploitive Actuation Reduces Control Effort: Biological systems can achieve efficient movement by leveraging their intrinsic mechanical properties, significantly reducing the need for complex neural control. This is quantified by the information-theoretic measure of control effort.
  • Information Theory as a Universal Control Effort Metric: The proposed information-theoretic approach provides a system-independent way to compare control effort across vastly different actuators (e.g., biological muscles vs. DC motors), revealing muscles to be significantly more efficient.
  • A Simple Mechanical Origin for Complex Muscle Behavior: The hyperbolic force-velocity relationship, a hallmark of muscle function, can be explained by the dynamic interaction of just three fundamental mechanical components (active element, parallel damper, serial element).
  • Bio-Inspired Artificial Muscles are Feasible: The proposed macroscopic model for artificial muscles, based on these three components, can replicate key muscle properties and serves as a promising design concept for future bio-inspired actuators.

Key Results

  • Hopping Stability: Combining feed-forward and feedback control strategies, along with a realistic Hill-type muscle model, significantly improved hopping stability compared to using either strategy alone.
  • Reduced Control Effort: The muscle-driven hopping model required only 34 bits of information to control, compared to 798 bits for a DC-motor driven system with a traditional PD controller.
  • Artificial Muscle Validation: The developed macroscopic model for artificial muscles successfully predicted hyperbolic force-velocity relationships in both numerical simulations and hardware experiments, validating the concept.
  • Parameter Identification: The study demonstrated how parameters of the artificial muscle model could be derived from biological muscle data, bridging the gap between theoretical models and experimental validation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: While the model captures key muscle properties, it neglects others like force-length dependency, force enhancement/depression, and activation dynamics in some stages. The hardware implementation also had limitations, such as internal friction and inertia, which led to deviations from theoretical predictions.
  • Biological Relevance of Parameters: The exact physical realization of the serial element (SE) and its role in the model's dynamics (represented by parameter κv) requires further investigation.
  • Generalizability: While the model shows promise for artificial muscles, further work is needed to incorporate more complex biological phenomena and to test its applicability in more sophisticated robotic systems.
  • Test Trilogy Application: The full "test trilogy" (simulation, hardware, and behavioral comparison) was not applied to all aspects of the thesis, particularly for the contractile element model. Future work could involve more comprehensive behavioral comparisons.
  • Energy Management: While the study highlights the importance of energy management in hopping, further research is needed to fully understand how biological systems optimize this process and how it can be replicated in machines.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biological movement generation is a dynamical process involving not only biomechanical structures, e.g., muscles, bones, ligaments, etc. but also metabolic energy processing, physiological sensing, and neuronal control. In this thesis, a physics approach to study these complex interactions is presented. It builds upon the results of physiological experiments with isolated animal muscles over the course of which their distinct dynamic properties have been described in great detail. Derived from previous simulation studies, the hypotheses posed were that the dynamic properties of muscles strongly contribute to generation and control of movements, they allow very simple control strategies, and thus reduce control effort in comparison to (technical) systems whose actuators do not have similar dynamic properties. Hopping was used as a template model to study the relation of muscle properties, control strategies, and interaction with the environment. It was found that the typical non-linear force-velocity relation of the biological muscle is important for hopping stability. Additionally, stability could be improved by combining feed-forward and feedback control strategies. The results highlight the importance of the muscle properties, especially that of the force-velocity relation for the control of periodic movements. If an organism exploits the muscle properties, the control effort was expected to be less than in a (technical) system without these properties. To quantify control effort, a new measure based on information theory was developed. Applied to hopping models this method revealed that the required information to control hopping can be as low as I=34bit with a muscle vs. I=798bit with a DC-motor. Concerning the muscle, the control strategy was particularly designed to exploit the muscle properties. In case of the DC-motor, a typical engineering control approach was chosen, where a negative-feedback controller was used to enforce a predefined trajectory regardless of the actuator properties. This shows that the approach to control effort based on information theory is applicable to and comparable across completely different actuator designs and control approaches. So far, biomechanical muscle models incorporated the force-velocity relation as a phenomenological fit to experimental data, i.e. a hyperbolic function. Only microscopic muscle models proposed a physical origin of the hyperbolic force-velocity relation. However, microscopic muscle models can neither be used in simulation studies of complex human movements, nor as a blueprint for the construction of artificial muscles. A different macroscopic model predicted the hyperbolic force-velocity relation from an arrangement of three macroscopic physical components: a mechanical energy source (active element AE), a parallel damper element (PDE), and a serial element (SE) that exhibits operating points with hyperbolic force-velocity dependency. To verify the contraction dynamics of this model, the analytical model was compared to a numerical simulation and a hardware implementation. The analytical model only predicts the operating points at steady state, whereas the numerical model includes the dynamics of the contraction, and the hardware implementation is used to verify the real world functionality of the concept. The same experiments as usually performed with biological muscles were conducted, i.e. quick release experiments against different loads. A similar hyperbolic force-velocity relation was found in the numerical model and the hardware implementation. However, deviations from the analytical prediction were found. To resolve these discrepancies, two types of quick release experiments were performed. These experiments represent two extreme cases of the contraction dynamics, i.e. against a constant force (isotonic) and against an inertial mass. Both experiments revealed hyperbolic force-velocity relations. Interestingly, the analytical model not only predicts these extreme cases, but additionally all contraction states in between as well. It was possible to validate these predictions with the numerical model and the hardware experiment. These results prove that the origin of the hyperbolic force-velocity relation can be mechanically explained on a macroscopic level by the dynamical interaction of three mechanical elements. Thus, the concept can be seen as a starting point for the development of muscle-like bionic actuators. With these studies, this thesis contributes to the understanding of the role that muscles play in the control of periodic movements, and proposes a design concept allowing a transfer of their beneficial properties into technical systems. By using information theory to quantify the control effort, technical biological systems can be compared and key characteristics can be identified. These new insights and methods contribute to the integrated view of biological movement generation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{haufle2013contraction,
  author = {Daniel Häufle},
  title = {{Contraction dynamics of biological muscles : mechanical and thermodynamical prediction, and experimental verification}},
  booktitle = {OPUS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.18419/opus-5084},
}

Loading related content...

Figure