TL;DR
This study leverages wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) to track Hepatitis A (HAV) and Hepatitis E (HEV) viruses in Munich over three years, including COVID-19 lockdowns. While HEV showed consistent circulation with higher wastewater concentrations during non-lockdown periods, HAV was detected sporadically, suggesting a greater reliance on travel for its spread in this non-endemic region.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) has gained prominence for monitoring pathogens like SARS-CoV-2. However, its application to fecal-oral transmitted diseases, beyond poliovirus, is less explored. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the feasibility and insights gained from using WBE to monitor HAV and HEV, two significant human pathogens, in a large urban population. Specifically, it aims to understand how COVID-19 lockdown measures, designed to reduce transmission, impacted the circulation of these viruses, as reflected in wastewater and official case data. The study also highlights the challenge of underreporting for these diseases, particularly HEV, where subclinical infections are common.
Methods
The researchers collected 186 wastewater samples from two sites in Munich between July 2020 and November 2023. Samples were processed using centrifugation to concentrate viruses, followed by RNA extraction. Viral RNA from HAV and HEV was then quantified using RT-qPCR. To account for variations in wastewater flow and dilution, viral loads were normalized using Pepper Mild Mottle Virus (PMMoV), a common fecal indicator. For comparison, official notification data for HAV and HEV cases in Munich and Bavaria were obtained, along with data on the stringency of COVID-19 lockdown measures. Statistical analyses, including ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis tests, and correlation analyses (Pearson and Spearman), were employed to assess seasonality, differences between lockdown and non-lockdown periods, and the correlation between wastewater concentrations and reported cases.
Datasets
- Wastewater Samples: 186 wastewater samples collected from July 2020 to November 2023 from two sites in Munich: Schmidbartlanger (spot samples) and WWTP Gut Grosslappen (24-h composite samples).
- Notification Data: Official data on clinically or laboratory-diagnosed Hepatitis A and E cases in Munich and Germany, obtained from the Robert Koch Institute and the Munich Health Department.
- Lockdown Stringency Data: Data derived from official documentation on the stringency of COVID-19 lockdown measures in Bavaria.
Key Insights and Ideas
- HEV's Pervasive Circulation: The consistently high detection rates and concentrations of HEV in wastewater underscore its widespread circulation in the Munich population, even during periods of reduced social contact. This strongly suggests a significant burden of subclinical infections that go undetected by clinical surveillance.
- Lockdowns' Nuanced Impact: While HEV wastewater concentrations showed a trend towards being higher during non-lockdown periods, the effect was more pronounced at the larger WWTP Gut Grosslappen than at the smaller Schmidbartlanger site. This suggests that broader public health interventions might have a more detectable impact on overall viral load in larger, more representative wastewater systems.
- HAV's Sporadic Nature: The low detection rate and sporadic nature of HAV in wastewater, contrasted with its travel-associated epidemiology, points towards the limitations of WBE for detecting rare events in large catchment areas. It also raises questions about the role of local foodborne transmission in regions where HAV is not endemic.
- WBE as a Complementary Tool: The study reinforces WBE's value in complementing traditional surveillance by providing a continuous, population-level view of viral circulation, especially for pathogens with high rates of asymptomatic infection.
Key Results
- HEV Detection: 87.6% of wastewater samples were positive for HEV RNA, with concentrations ranging from 9.0 × 10¹ to 2.5 × 10⁵ copies/L.
- HAV Detection: Only 7.5% of wastewater samples were positive for HAV RNA, with viral loads between 4.6 × 10¹ and 2.4 × 10³ copies/L.
- Lockdown Impact on HEV: Higher HEV concentrations were observed in wastewater from the Gut Grosslappen WWTP during non-lockdown periods compared to lockdown periods (mean 4.0 × 10⁴ vs. 1.8 × 10⁴ copies/L, respectively). This difference was statistically significant.
- Lockdown Impact on HAV: No significant differences in HAV concentration or reported cases were found between lockdown and non-lockdown periods.
- Correlation with Cases: A small but significant positive correlation was found between weekly mean HEV concentration at Schmidbartlanger and reported HEV cases in Munich (r = 0.26). No significant correlation was observed for Gut Grosslappen.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Sampling Frequency: Samples were collected weekly or bi-weekly, which may lead to increased variability and miss short-term fluctuations.
- Catchment Area Size: The large catchment areas of the sampling sites can lead to dilution artifacts, making it challenging to detect sporadic cases of HAV.
- Sample Type Variability: Comparing spot samples with 24-h composite samples can introduce variability.
- Frozen Sample Impact: While mitigated, there's a possibility that deeply frozen samples might show slightly lower viral loads.
- Underreporting: Both HAV and HEV are known to be significantly underreported, particularly asymptomatic HEV infections, which limits the direct comparison with wastewater data.
Future work could involve using smaller catchment areas with compound samplers to better detect sporadic HAV cases. Further investigation into the role of local foodborne transmission for HAV in non-endemic regions is also warranted. The study also suggests that WBE can be a valuable tool for detecting larger food-related outbreaks of HAV.
Summary updated