Contextualizing the tone of the operating room in practice: drawing on the literature to connect the dots

Hillary Lia, Melanie Hammond Mobilio, Frank Rudzicz, Carol‐Anne MoultonFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The study of teamwork in the operating room has made significant strides in uncovering key constructs which shape safe and effective intraoperative care. However, in recent years, there have been calls to understand teamwork in the operating room more fully by embracing the complexity of the intraoperative environment. We propose the construct of tone as a useful lens through which to understand intraoperative teamwork. In this article, we review the literature on culture, shared mental models, and psychological safety, linking each to the construct of tone. By identifying tone as a theoretical orientation to demonstrate the overlap between these concepts, we aim to provide a starting point for new ways to understand intraoperative team dynamics.

Introduction: Beyond Checklists and Leadership Styles

While teamwork is universally recognized as a cornerstone of safe surgical practice, academic research has historically focused on relatively static or isolated factors, such as leadership hierarchies or adherence to surgical safety checklists. However, practitioners—surgeons, nurses, and anesthesiologists—frequently describe their environment in more fluid terms: the "tone" or "vibe" of the room. This affective atmosphere can range from tranquil and focused to tense and fragmented, yet it has remained largely unarticulated in formal surgical literature.

This paper addresses the need for a formal language to describe the moment-to-moment "affective atmosphere" of the operating room (OR). Without a clear definition and theoretical grounding, it is difficult to study how this atmosphere emerges from team interactions or how it impacts a team's ability to adapt to sudden intraoperative complications. This analysis seeks to move "tone" from a peripheral anecdotal observation to a central, measurable construct in surgical team dynamics.

Theoretical Framework: Tone as a Team Emergent State

To formalize the concept of tone, we utilize a conceptual analysis synthesizing several key psychological frameworks. Central to this is the framing of tone as a Team Emergent State (TES). In this view, tone is a property that emerges from the bottom-up—driven by individual interactions—but eventually becomes a global, coherent state that influences the team from the top-down.

Emotions as Social Information (EASI)

The mechanism through which tone is established and shifted is explained by Emotions as Social Information (EASI) theory. In the high-stakes environment of the OR, outward emotional expressions—a surgeon’s sharp sigh, an anesthetist’s calm reassurance, or a nurse’s focused silence—serve as critical "data" for other team members. These signals influence subsequent behaviors and cognitions, defining what is acceptable in the moment (e.g., whether social chatter is appropriate or if total focus is required).

The "Mortar" Between the Bricks

We propose that tone acts as the "mortar" connecting the "bricks" of established teamwork constructs:

  • Culture: While culture is relatively stable and resistant to rapid change, tone is highly volatile. Tone is the mechanism through which abstract cultural norms are enacted in real-time.
  • Shared Mental Models (SMM): Tone is rooted in a shared understanding of procedural requirements. A shift in tone often signals a shift in the team's collective understanding of the current surgical phase or risk level.
  • Psychological Safety: There is a reciprocal relationship here. High psychological safety helps set a positive tone, while a positive, open tone makes it safer for junior members to speak up or challenge errors.

Discussion: The Dynamics of the OR

A key finding of this analysis is the inherent dynamism of tone. Unlike organizational culture, tone can shift instantly in response to a surgical complication or a change in staffing. While the attending surgeon is often seen as the primary "tone-setter," our framework emphasizes that other team members, such as the circulating nurse, often establish the initial tone before the surgeon even enters the sterile field.

By formalizing tone as a dynamic construct describing the affective atmosphere among team members, we provide a roadmap for understanding why some teams maintain coordination during crises while others "fall apart."

Conclusion and Future Directions

As a conceptual analysis, this work provides the theoretical foundation for future empirical validation. We suggest a mixed-methods approach to further explore this construct:

  1. Qualitative Observation: Immersive studies to capture how OR staff experience and describe shifts in tone.
  2. Quantitative Analysis: Utilizing video and audio data to correlate specific emotional expressions with measurable shifts in team coordination and patient outcomes.

Ultimately, understanding tone allows for the development of advanced team skills training, enabling OR staff to recognize, manage, and "reset" a negative atmosphere before it compromises patient safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study of teamwork in the operating room has made significant strides in uncovering key constructs which shape safe and effective intraoperative care. However, in recent years, there have been calls to understand teamwork in the operating room more fully by embracing the complexity of the intraoperative environment. We propose the construct of tone as a useful lens through which to understand intraoperative teamwork. In this article, we review the literature on culture, shared mental models, and psychological safety, linking each to the construct of tone. By identifying tone as a theoretical orientation to demonstrate the overlap between these concepts, we aim to provide a starting point for new ways to understand intraoperative team dynamics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lia2023contextualizing,
  author = {Hillary Lia and Melanie Hammond Mobilio and Frank Rudzicz and Carol‐Anne Moulton},
  title = {{Contextualizing the tone of the operating room in practice: drawing on the literature to connect the dots}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1167098},
}
Figure