Contextual, Radiological Anatomy (RA) Learning needs Evaluation for Curricular Improvement

Reshma Mohamed Ansari, Hong Han, Sara Idris, Atikah Abdul LatiffIIUM 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the learning needs and perceptions of medical students regarding Radiological Anatomy (RA) at the University of Cyberjaya, Malaysia. Through a survey of 405 students across all five years of the MBBS program, researchers identified a significant perceived deficit in RA teaching during the transition to clinical years (Year 3). While pre-clinical education is predominantly formal, clinical years rely more on informal bedside teaching. The findings suggest a need for a more integrated, longitudinal RA curriculum that emphasizes clinical correlates and small-group learning.

Introduction

In modern medicine, diagnostic imaging has largely superseded physical dissection as the primary method for visualizing internal anatomy in a clinical setting. However, as medical curricula evolve and traditional gross anatomy hours are reduced, a "knowledge gap" often emerges. Students frequently master anatomical theory in pre-clinical years but struggle to apply this knowledge to X-rays, CT scans, and MRIs during clinical rotations. This study investigates this disconnect at the University of Cyberjaya (UoC), Malaysia, seeking to align student learning time (SLT) and teaching methods with the practical demands of the medical profession.

Methods

The researchers conducted a single-institution, cross-sectional survey of 405 medical students (80% response rate) across all five years of study. The survey utilized an adapted instrument from Newcastle University, featuring both closed-ended Likert scale questions and open-ended feedback. The tool was validated for content and internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha = 0.764). Data were analyzed using SPSS, employing non-parametric tests (Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis) to identify significant differences in preferences based on gender and academic year.

Key Findings

The "Year 3 Slump"

A critical finding of the study is the perceived inadequacy of teaching time during the transition from classroom to clinic. While the majority of students felt their overall learning time was adequate, 62% of Year 3 students reported it was "too little." This suggests that as students begin to encounter real patients and diagnostic images, they feel underprepared by their earlier foundational training.

Formal vs. Informal Instruction

The delivery of RA teaching shifts dramatically as students progress. Pre-clinical students (57.5%) reported receiving mostly formal instruction. In contrast, clinical students indicated a reliance on informal teaching or an even mix of both (56.6%). This "fleeting" nature of bedside RA teaching in later years may contribute to the perceived lack of preparation.

Table 1 & 2: Student perceptions on the adequacy and type of radiological anatomy teaching across different years and phases of study.

Modality and Teacher Preferences

  • X-Ray Dominance: Despite the availability of advanced imaging, students overwhelmingly preferred learning via X-ray (Mean = 4.49/5.0). Ultrasound scored the lowest, likely due to the difficulty novices face with spatial orientation in live 2D feeds.
  • Clinical Context: Students expressed a strong preference for "live" instruction and small-group sessions (e.g., Problem-Based Learning, clinical correlates) over self-directed e-learning.
  • The Teacher Tug-of-War: There is a clear desire for a dual-instruction model. Students value anatomists for foundational facts but crave the clinical context and "real-world" interpretation tips provided by radiologists.

Conclusion

The study provides a clear mandate for curriculum review. The stark contrast between student needs—particularly in Year 3—and current teaching practices suggests that RA should be more formally integrated into the clinical years. By emphasizing clinical correlates and increasing the involvement of radiologists in early education, institutions can better bridge the gap between anatomical theory and diagnostic practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: As a part of the MBBS curriculum review exercise, University of Cyberjaya (UoC), Malaysia had come up with a study to investigate the feedback and learning needs pertaining to radiological anatomy (RA) in pre-clinical teaching. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A single-institutional survey of all five-year medical students was done using an adapted instrument which had both open and close-ended questions on the radiological anatomy teaching received so far and the perception on the teaching methods and content. 405 respondents out of 503 (80%) (year 1=115, year 2= 78, year 3=79, year 4=78, year 5=55) replied. There were totally 136 male and 269 female respondents. RESULTS: Though the overall student learning time (SLT) was adequate, year 3 students (62%) reported inadequate radiological anatomy SLT. Pre[1]clinical students (57.5%) reported more of formal radiological anatomy teaching while clinical students indicated informal teaching (Informal: 15.1 %, Even mix of formal and informal: 56.6 %). Female students reported higher response of adequate SLT (69.1%) and formal teaching (46.9%) compared to males. Small group learning such as gross anatomy practical sessions, problem-based learning, clinical skills teaching, and clinical correlates sessions were recommended. Abdomen and thorax were the most preferred regions where radiological anatomy could be explored further. X-ray followed by CT and MRI were the most favoured radiological modalities to learn topographical anatomy. CONCLUSION: The study provided sound feedback on the existing radiological anatomy teaching practices. Data shows stark contrast between the needs of the students and the current practices indicating that it is quite substantial for curriculum review.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ansari2023contextual,
  author = {Reshma Mohamed Ansari and Hong Han and Sara Idris and Atikah Abdul Latiff},
  title = {{Contextual, Radiological Anatomy (RA) Learning needs Evaluation for Curricular Improvement}},
  booktitle = {IIUM},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.31436/imjm.v22i2.2148},
}
Figure