TL;DR
This study reveals widespread contamination of 21 PFAS in shellfish and crustaceans from Zhejiang Province, China, with marine crustaceans showing the highest levels. While overall dietary exposure risks for adults are low, specific long-chain PFAS like PFUdA and PFTrDA pose potential concerns, particularly for high consumers.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), a group of persistent synthetic chemicals, are increasingly found in the environment and human bodies due to their widespread use. While their toxicity is a growing concern, understanding their presence in specific food sources and the associated human health risks is crucial for effective risk management. This paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding the contamination levels of a broad range of PFAS (21 compounds) in commercially important seafood (shellfish and crustaceans) from Zhejiang Province, a significant industrial and coastal region in China. It aims to characterize this contamination, identify potential sources, and assess the dietary exposure risks for adult consumers in this region.
Methods
The researchers analyzed 306 samples of shellfish and crustaceans collected from markets in Zhejiang Province. They employed liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) to quantify 21 specific PFAS compounds. To identify potential sources of contamination, they utilized the EPA's Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) 5.0 model, a statistical tool for source apportionment. Dietary exposure was assessed using a food consumption survey conducted between 2015-2016, which provided data on consumption amounts and frequency for adult participants. Health risks were evaluated by comparing estimated daily intakes (EDIs) of key PFAS with established health-based guidance values, calculating Hazard Quotients (HQs).
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 306 samples of shellfish and crustaceans collected from markets in Zhejiang Province between 2023 and 2024. Additionally, food consumption data from a survey of 7354 adults in Zhejiang Province, conducted between 2015 and 2016, was used for exposure assessment.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Ubiquitous Contamination: Nearly 88% of the analyzed seafood samples contained at least one PFAS, highlighting the pervasive nature of these chemicals in aquatic food sources.
- Species-Specific Accumulation: Different types of seafood exhibit distinct PFAS accumulation patterns. Crustaceans, particularly marine ones, showed higher concentrations of long-chain PFAS like PFUdA and PFTrDA, while bivalves were more contaminated with PFOA and PFOS. This suggests variations in uptake mechanisms and metabolic capacities.
- Dominance of Specific PFAS: PFOA and PFOS, historically significant PFAS, remain prevalent, but emerging concerns are raised by the high detection rates of longer-chain perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs) like PFUdA and PFTrDA in crustaceans.
- Multiple Pollution Pathways: Source apportionment suggests that PFAS contamination in these seafood products originates from a complex mix of sources, including domestic waste, industrial discharges (e.g., from textile processing and electroplating), and atmospheric deposition.
- Low Overall Risk, but Targeted Concerns: While the majority of adult consumers in Zhejiang Province have low dietary exposure risks to the four main PFAS (E4PFAS) of concern, a small but significant percentage (0.31%) exhibited exposure levels exceeding health guidelines. This subgroup, often female and with higher consumption habits, warrants attention.
- Long-Chain PFAS as Key Contributors to Risk: For both general and high-consumption groups, long-chain PFCAs like PFUdA and PFTrDA were identified as the primary contributors to exposure, suggesting that focusing solely on historically monitored PFAS might underestimate the overall risk.
Key Results
- Detection Rates: 87.9% of 306 samples contained detectable PFAS.
- Most Frequent PFAS: PFOA (64.7%), PFOS (53.8%), PFNA (52.9%), and PFDA (50.0%) were most frequently detected.
- Total PFAS Concentrations: Ranged from non-detectable to 173 ng/g wet weight, with a median of 4.11 ng/g ww.
- Median Concentration Order: Marine crustaceans > freshwater crustaceans > bivalves.
- Estimated Daily Intake (EDI) of Σ<sub>21</sub> PFAS: Ranged from 0.01 to 15.7 ng/kg bw/day for adult consumers.
- Hazard Quotient (HQ) > 1: 0.31% of the adult study population had HQ values > 1 for Σ<sub>4</sub>PFAS, indicating potential health concerns for this subgroup.
- Predominant Exposure Sources: PFUdA and PFTrDA were the primary exposure sources for both general and high-consumption populations.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Temporal Gap: The food consumption data was collected in 2015-2016, while PFAS measurements were from 2023-2024. This temporal discrepancy could introduce uncertainty, although they argue that consumption patterns in this coastal region are generally stable.
- Exposure Assessment Approach: Using the P50 concentration for exposure assessment might underestimate extreme exposure scenarios. The imputation of non-detected values also introduces potential uncertainty.
- Source Apportionment Complexity: The mixed origin of commercially sourced seafood samples complicated source apportionment.
- Focus on E4PFAS for Risk Assessment: While 21 PFAS were analyzed, the primary health risk assessment focused on E4PFAS (PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFHxS). The long-term health effects of lower-level detected PFAS and their combined toxicological effects remain largely unknown.
Future work suggested includes:
- Continued Monitoring: Ongoing surveillance of PFAS contamination in marine food products is essential.
- Enhanced Source Apportionment: Further research to pinpoint major contamination pathways is needed.
- Temporal Trend Analysis: Tracking changes in PFAS levels in relation to industrial activity and regulatory measures.
- Comprehensive Toxicity Assessment: Evaluating the combined toxicological effects of multiple PFAS.
- Focus on Vulnerable Populations: Special consideration for pregnant women and children to mitigate developmental risks.
Summary updated