Containing the Transmission of COVID-19: A Modeling Study in 160 Countries

Yan Niu, Jia Rui, Qiupeng Wang, Wei Zhang, Zhiwei Chen, Fang Xie, Zeyu Zhao, Shengnan Lin, Yuanzhao Zhu, Yao Wang, Jingwen Xu, Xingchun Liu, Meng Yang, Wei Zheng, Kaixin Chen, Yilan Xia, Lijuan Xu, Shi Zhang, Rongrong Ji, Taisong Jin, Yong Chen, Benhua Zhao, Yanhua Su, Tie Song, Tianmu Chen, Guoqing HuFrontiers in Medicine 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: It is valuable to evaluate the comparative effectiveness of COVID-19 prevention and control during the non-pharmacological intervention (NPI) phase of the pandemic across countries and identify useful experiences that could be generalized worldwide. Methods: In this study, we developed a susceptible-exposure-infectious-asymptomatic-removed (SEIAR) model to fit the daily reported COVID-19 cases in 160 countries. The time-varying reproduction number ($R_t$) estimated through fitting the mathematical model was adopted to quantify transmissibility. We defined a synthetic index ($I_{AC}$) based on the value of $R_t$ to reflect national capability to control COVID-19. Results: The goodness-of-fit tests showed that the SEIAR model fitted the data of the 160 countries well. At the beginning of the epidemic, the values of $R_t$ in the European region were generally higher than those in other regions. While all European countries eventually demonstrated the ability to control the epidemic, the Western Pacific Region performed best in continuous control (73.76% of countries), significantly outperforming the European Region (43.63%), the Region of Americas (52.53%), and other WHO regions. Conclusion: Large variations in controlling the COVID-19 epidemic existed across countries. The world could benefit from the experience of countries that demonstrated the highest containment capabilities.

Introduction

In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, before the availability of vaccines, global health security relied entirely on non-pharmacological interventions (NPIs) such as lockdowns, social distancing, and mask mandates. However, the effectiveness of these measures varied significantly between nations.

This study addresses a critical gap in comparative global research. While early studies often focused on single nations, this research provides a standardized benchmark for 160 countries. Furthermore, it addresses the limitations of standard SEIR models by explicitly accounting for asymptomatic carriers—the "silent" spreaders who played a massive role in the initial phase of the pandemic (January to August 2020).

Methodology

Study Workflow and Data Sources

The researchers utilized global COVID-19 data from the Johns Hopkins University (JHU) CSSE repository, the Esri Living Atlas, and the JHU Applied Physics Lab. Initially, 183 countries were screened; 160 were selected for final analysis after excluding those with poor data quality or poor model-fitting results.

Study workflow illustrating data collection, model fitting, and regional analysis across 160 countries.

The SEIAR Model

The core of the analysis is a modified Susceptible–Exposure–Infectious–Asymptomatic–Removed (SEIAR) model. By adding the "A" (Asymptomatic) compartment, the model acknowledges that a significant portion of the population spreads the virus without showing symptoms.

Flowchart of the SEIAR model, incorporating the asymptomatic (A) compartment and transition parameters.

To quantify success, the study introduced two primary metrics:

  1. Time-varying reproduction number ($R_t$): Tracks how transmissibility changes over time as interventions are implemented.
  2. Synthetic Index ($I_{AC}$): A novel score (0–15) aggregating the speed of control ($I_{Tn}$), the stability of control ($I_{WNi}$), and whether the epidemic was under control by the end of the study period ($I_{Cj}$).

Key Insights and Results

The Asymptomatic Factor

The study highlights that the proportion of asymptomatic infections (set at a mean of 0.2) significantly impacts $R_t$ estimations. Ignoring this group leads to a fundamental misunderstanding of the virus's "stealth" transmission dynamics.

Regional Performance Patterns

The data revealed distinct regional "epidemic personalities":

  • Europe: Faced the most aggressive initial outbreaks with the highest $R_t$ values (often exceeding 10). However, European countries showed high resilience, with 76.4% achieving $R_t < 1$ within 60 days.
  • Western Pacific Region (WPR): Emerged as the "gold standard" for stability. Approximately 73.76% of WPR countries maintained continuous control, compared to only 43.63% in Europe and 40.48% in the Eastern Mediterranean.
  • Top Tier Performers: The WPR had the highest proportion of countries achieving the maximum control capability score ($I_{AC} = 15$).

The Challenge of Sustainability

A key finding was that bringing the virus under control once is easier than maintaining that control. Many countries successfully reduced $R_t$ below 1 but suffered from high "wave numbers," indicating that interventions were either lifted prematurely or lacked long-term sustainability.

Discussion and Limitations

While the SEIAR model provided a strong fit ($R^2 > 0.5$) for 112 of the 160 countries, the study acknowledges several constraints. Parameters like the proportion of asymptomatic cases ($p$) were fixed for comparability, though they likely vary by population. Additionally, data quality varied by region, particularly in the African region.

Despite these limitations, the study provides a vital historical record of NPI effectiveness. Future research will need to integrate the impact of vaccination campaigns and more transmissible variants to build upon these findings. The world stands to benefit from the experiences of the Western Pacific and European regions in managing large-scale public health crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> It is much valuable to evaluate the comparative effectiveness of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) prevention and control in the non-pharmacological intervention phase of the pandemic across countries and identify useful experiences that could be generalized worldwide. <b>Methods:</b> In this study, we developed a susceptible-exposure-infectious-asymptomatic-removed (SEIAR) model to fit the daily reported COVID-19 cases in 160 countries. The time-varying reproduction number (<i>R</i> <sub><i>t</i></sub> ) that was estimated through fitting the mathematical model was adopted to quantify the transmissibility. We defined a synthetic index (<i>I</i> <sub><i>AC</i></sub> ) based on the value of <i>R</i> <sub><i>t</i></sub> to reflect the national capability to control COVID-19. <b>Results:</b> The goodness-of-fit tests showed that the SEIAR model fitted the data of the 160 countries well. At the beginning of the epidemic, the values of <i>R</i> <sub><i>t</i></sub> of countries in the European region were generally higher than those in other regions. Among the 160 countries included in the study, all European countries had the ability to control the COVID-19 epidemic. The Western Pacific Region did best in continuous control of the epidemic, with a total of 73.76% of countries that can continuously control the COVID-19 epidemic, while only 43.63% of the countries in the European Region continuously controlled the epidemic, followed by the Region of Americas with 52.53% of countries, the Southeast Asian Region with 48% of countries, the African Region with 46.81% of countries, and the Eastern Mediterranean Region with 40.48% of countries. <b>Conclusion:</b> Large variations in controlling the COVID-19 epidemic existed across countries. The world could benefit from the experience of some countries that demonstrated the highest containment capabilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{niu2021containing,
  author = {Yan Niu and Jia Rui and Qiupeng Wang and Wei Zhang and Zhiwei Chen and Fang Xie and Zeyu Zhao and Shengnan Lin and Yuanzhao Zhu and Yao Wang and Jingwen Xu and Xingchun Liu and Meng Yang and Wei Zheng and Kaixin Chen and Yilan Xia and Lijuan Xu and Shi Zhang and Rongrong Ji and Taisong Jin and Yong Chen and Benhua Zhao and Yanhua Su and Tie Song and Tianmu Chen and Guoqing Hu},
  title = {{Containing the Transmission of COVID-19: A Modeling Study in 160 Countries}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2021.701836},
}
Figure