TL;DR
This paper explores how commodifying traditional knowledge (TK), specifically Naxi Dongba papermaking in China, can potentially aid in resource conservation. Through a survey of tourists, it reveals a significant willingness to pay for authentic, sustainably produced Dongba paper, suggesting its potential as a "credence good" that requires third-party certification for consumer trust.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper tackles the complex challenge of conserving indigenous resources and traditional knowledge (TK) in the face of globalization and development. While commodification of TK is proposed as a potential solution, it's a contested approach with trade-offs. Specifically, the study addresses the lack of understanding regarding how consumers, particularly domestic tourists who are the primary market for indigenous products, perceive and value these commodified TK products. The case of Dongba papermaking, a sacred Naxi tradition facing extinction, serves as a lens to examine consumer awareness, willingness to pay for authenticity and sustainability, and trust in various assurance mechanisms.
Methods
The study employed a socio-economic survey methodology. A questionnaire was administered to 415 domestic tourists visiting Lijiang, a major tourist destination in Southwest China. The survey aimed to gauge:
- Knowledge of Naxi Culture: Assessed through a series of questions of increasing difficulty about the local ethnic group, their religion, and the plant used for papermaking.
- Willingness to Pay (WTP): Explored through questions about willingness to pay a price premium for sustainably produced Dongba paper and specific price points.
- Perceptions of Authenticity and Assurance: Investigated through preferences for third-party labelling and hypothetical funding allocation to various stakeholders for TK preservation.
The data was analyzed using descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, and univariate analysis to identify trends and relationships between variables like knowledge, support for TK, and WTP.
Datasets
The study utilized a primary dataset collected through a survey of 415 domestic tourists in Lijiang, China. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dongba Paper as a Credence Good: The paper argues that Dongba paper, due to its complex production process and the information asymmetry between producers and consumers, functions as a "credence good." This means consumers cannot easily verify its authenticity or quality themselves, necessitating external assurance.
- Consumer Demand for Authenticity and Sustainability: Despite limited knowledge of Naxi culture, a significant majority of tourists expressed support for preserving TK and were willing to pay a premium for authentically produced Dongba paper. This highlights a growing consumer interest in unique, culturally significant products.
- Contradictory Trust in Government: A striking finding is the paradoxical attitude towards the Chinese government. While preferred as the strongest guarantor of authenticity through labelling, the government received the least trust for its ability to manage and fund conservation efforts. This points to a nuanced consumer perspective on government intervention.
- The Role of Third-Party Assurance: The study underscores the critical need for third-party certification and labelling to build consumer trust and ensure that price premiums genuinely benefit TK preservation and resource conservation.
Key Results
- Limited Cultural Knowledge: Only 3% of respondents could identify the plant used for Dongba papermaking, indicating a general lack of deep cultural knowledge among tourists.
- High Support for TK Preservation: 55% of respondents supported a price increase for TK-derived paper using original materials for plant resource preservation.
- Willingness to Pay: 49% of respondents claimed to be willing to pay a premium for TK-derived Dongba paper, with a significant portion willing to pay an extra five RMB.
- Preference for Government Labelling: 50% of respondents preferred a government-approved label for TK-derived products, but paradoxically, government institutions received the least hypothetical funding allocation for conservation.
- Farmers as Preferred Fund Recipients: Direct payment to farmers who provide the plant material was the most frequent choice for hypothetical funding allocation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Sample Representativeness: The study acknowledges that the purposive sampling method might not be statistically representative of all tourists, and potential biases could exist.
- Contradictory Trust: The paper highlights the contradictory attitudes towards government assurance, suggesting a need for further exploration of how to build trust in conservation funding mechanisms.
- Future Research: The authors suggest future research should investigate the indigenous perspective on Dongba papermaking, including the views of producers, religious practitioners, and the broader Naxi community. This would provide a more holistic understanding of the commodification process and its impact. Additionally, exploring how to foster greater trust in government or alternative institutions for funding conservation is crucial.
Summary updated