Consumer behavior in online shopping is affected by sales tax

Liran Einav, Dan Knoepfle, Jonathan Levin, Neel SundaresanLondon 2014

This summary covers the research presented in the article "Consumer behavior in online shopping is affected by sales tax," based on the 2014 American Economic Review paper "Sales Taxes and Internet Commerce" by Liran Einav, Dan Knoepfle, Jonathan Levin, and Neel Sundaresan.

TL;DR

This research quantifies how sales tax disparities drive consumers from brick-and-mortar stores to online marketplaces. By analyzing massive datasets from eBay, the authors demonstrate that while tax avoidance is a significant driver of e-commerce, consumers are surprisingly less sensitive to taxes than to base prices and maintain a strong, counter-intuitive preference for local sellers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the "nexus" rule—which required a physical presence in a state before a retailer was obligated to collect sales tax—created a significant price gap between offline and online retail. With states losing an estimated $10 billion annually in "missing" taxes, policymakers have long debated how much this tax-free status actually fuels the growth of e-commerce.

The authors tackle three primary questions:

  1. How sensitive are consumers to sales tax when choosing between offline and online options?
  2. How does the application of tax at checkout affect the final decision to purchase?
  3. How do taxes influence the "geography" of e-commerce (i.e., does the internet truly eliminate the importance of physical distance)?

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged econometric approach using high-granularity data:

  • Longitudinal Analysis: They tracked state and local tax changes over time to see if residents increased their (untaxed) online spending on eBay when their local brick-and-mortar tax rates rose.
  • Natural "Micro-Experiments": The authors utilized eBay browsing data to observe "friction" at the point of sale. They compared instances where a buyer clicked an item and saw a tax added (because the seller was in the same state) versus instances where no tax was applied (out-of-state seller). This allowed them to isolate the effect of the tax from the base price.
  • Spatial Modeling: They estimated the trade-offs retailers face when deciding where to locate distribution centers, weighing the benefits of being near customers (faster/cheaper shipping) against the costs of establishing "nexus" and being forced to collect taxes.

Datasets

The study relies exclusively on data from eBay’s marketplace.

  • Why eBay? Unlike Amazon (which at the time of the study was transitioning toward collecting taxes in more states), eBay provided a massive, decentralized network of both professional and casual sellers across every state. This provided a "cleaner" environment to study interstate commerce and the specific impact of the 1998 Internet Tax Nondiscrimination Act.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tax Salience is Low: One of the most striking findings is that consumers are much more sensitive to the "sticker price" than to taxes. The researchers found that tax sensitivity is only about one-third as strong as sensitivity to the base retail price. This suggests that taxes are often treated as a "hidden" cost that doesn't deter buyers as much as a direct price hike would.
  • The "Home-State Bias": Contrary to the idea of a "frictionless" global internet, online shoppers exhibit a strong preference for buying from sellers within their own state or nearby regions. This preference is so strong that it often offsets the financial incentive to shop out-of-state to avoid taxes.
  • The Nexus Trade-off: Large retailers face a strategic "calculus." For example, Amazon historically located distribution centers just across state lines (e.g., in Nevada near the California border) to remain close to customers while avoiding the legal requirement to collect California sales tax.

Key Results

  • Elasticity: For every 1 percentage point increase in a state’s sales tax, online purchasing by residents of that state increases by 1% to 2%.
  • Potential Impact of Policy Change: If the law changed to require tax collection on all internet purchases, the authors estimate that online spending would drop by 8% to 9% in states with a typical 5-6% sales tax.
  • Location Sensitivity: The "home-state" preference is powerful. The authors estimate that if a California seller moved to Oregon to avoid tax liability, the loss of "local" California customers who prefer buying from their own state could nearly offset the entire tax benefit of the move.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Platform Specificity: The data is limited to eBay. Consumer behavior on a platform known for unique or used goods might differ from behavior on "commodity" platforms like Amazon or specialized D2C (Direct-to-Consumer) sites.
  • Evolution of Shipping: The study was conducted when shipping times were longer. In the current era of "Same-Day" or "Next-Day" delivery, the trade-off between tax avoidance and proximity (speed) has likely shifted even further in favor of proximity.
  • Legal Landscape: Since this paper's publication, the 2018 Supreme Court ruling in South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc. has largely rendered the "physical nexus" argument moot, allowing states to mandate tax collection based on economic activity. Future research could apply these methods to see if the "home-state bias" persists now that the tax advantage has largely vanished.

Summary updated

Abstract

Profits from the sales tax make up a large percentage of overall revenues in many states, making the estimated $10 billion lost each year to tax-free internet purchases particularly concerning. Liran Einav, Dan Knoepfle, Jonathan Levin, and Neel Sundaresan examine just how much the presence (or lack thereof) of a sales tax influences consumer behavior. He finds that online purchasing goes up by 1-2 percent for each percentage point increase in the state sales tax, and that an online sales tax does lead to a decline in purchases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{einav2014consumer,
  author = {Liran Einav and Dan Knoepfle and Jonathan Levin and Neel Sundaresan},
  title = {{Consumer behavior in online shopping is affected by sales tax}},
  booktitle = {London},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure