Construction of pseudorabies virus variant attenuated vaccine: codon deoptimization of US3 and UL56 genes based on PRV gE/TK deletion strain

Mengwei Xu, Laixu Zhu, Aimin Ge, Yamei Liu, Saisai Chen, Ziwen Wei, Yating Zheng, Ling Tong, Zhisheng Wang, Rongmei Fei, Jichun Wang, Chuanjian ZhangFrontiers in Microbiology 2023 · DOI

This paper describes a sophisticated approach to vaccine design for Pseudorabies Virus (PRV), a major threat to the global swine industry. By combining traditional gene deletion with "codon deoptimization," the researchers created a live-attenuated vaccine that is safe even for highly vulnerable newborn piglets while maintaining the robust immune response needed to fight off virulent field variants.

TL;DR

Researchers enhanced the safety of a Pseudorabies Virus (PRV) vaccine by using codon deoptimization to "dial down" the expression of key virulence genes (US3-S and UL56). The resulting vaccine candidates proved safe for newborn piglets—a group previously at risk from existing live vaccines—while providing strong protective immunity against emerging PRV variants.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pseudorabies (or Aujeszky's disease) causes devastating neurological and respiratory issues in pigs. Since 2011, highly virulent PRV variants have emerged in China, rendering older vaccines (like the Bartha-K61 strain) less effective.

While scientists developed newer vaccines by deleting specific genes (like gE and TK), these "deletion strains" still pose a safety risk: they can be lethal to newborn piglets that haven't received maternal antibodies. The challenge is to further weaken (attenuate) the virus so it doesn't cause disease in newborns, without making it so weak that the pig's immune system fails to recognize and learn to fight it.

Methods

The authors employed a "double-layered" attenuation strategy:

  1. Gene Deletion: They started with a backbone that already had the gE and TK genes removed (PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE-AH02</sup>).
  2. Codon Deoptimization (CD): This is the "volume knob" of the study. Most amino acids are coded by multiple synonymous codons. Some codons are "preferred" by the host cell and translated quickly, while others are "rare" and translated slowly. By replacing preferred codons with rare ones in the US3-S and UL56 genes, the researchers slowed down the virus's ability to produce these virulence proteins without changing the actual protein sequence.

They used Bacterial Artificial Chromosome (BAC) technology to precisely engineer six different recombinant viruses, testing versions where either the first 10 codons or the entire gene sequences were deoptimized.

Datasets

The study did not use large-scale external datasets but relied on:

  • Parental Strain: PRV variant AH02LA, isolated from a dead newborn piglet in Anhui Province, China.
  • Reference Genome: PRV ZJ01 (GenBank: KM061380.1) was used for RFLP (Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism) analysis predictions.
  • New Sequences: The authors deposited their deoptimized sequences into GenBank (Accession numbers OR228539 through OR228542).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Threshold Effect: Deoptimizing only the first 10 codons (F10-CD) had almost no effect on mRNA or protein expression. Significant attenuation only occurred when the entire gene (T-CD) was deoptimized. This suggests that for these specific PRV genes, the cumulative effect of rare codons across the whole transcript is required to overcome the cell's translation machinery.
  • Targeting Isoforms: The researchers specifically targeted US3-S, a shorter isoform of the US3 gene that accounts for 95% of its transcription. This precision allowed them to attenuate the virus's primary virulence activity effectively.
  • Safety in the "Worst-Case" Scenario: The most significant insight was the performance in 1-day-old, antibody-negative piglets. While the standard gE/TK deletion vaccine caused fever and symptoms in these newborns, the US3-S deoptimized version (PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE</sup>-US3-S<sup>T-CD</sup>) was completely asymptomatic.

Key Results

  • Reduced Viral Fitness: Recombinant viruses with full codon deoptimization grew to significantly lower titers (roughly 1–2 log10 lower) in swine testicular (ST) cells compared to the parental vaccine strain.
  • Molecular Dampening: qRT-PCR and Western blotting confirmed that T-CD variants had significantly lower levels of mRNA and protein expression.
  • Mouse Model Safety: Mice injected with T-CD variants showed 100% survival and significantly lower viral loads in the brain compared to those given the parental gE/TK deletion strain.
  • Piglet Immunogenicity: Despite being more attenuated, the PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE</sup>-US3-S<sup>T-CD</sup> strain induced a high serum neutralization index in piglets, comparable to the more virulent parental vaccine, indicating it remains a potent immunogen.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vivo Stability: While the authors confirmed the genetic stability of the deoptimized genes over 20 passages in cell culture, they did not perform "back-passage" experiments in pigs to ensure the virus doesn't regain virulence in a live host over time.
  • Mechanistic Clarity: The study doesn't fully tease out whether the attenuation is due to slowed translation (ribosome stalling) or changes in mRNA secondary structure/stability caused by the new codons.
  • Broad Spectrum Testing: Future work is needed to see if this vaccine provides "cross-protection" against a wider variety of emerging PRV field strains beyond the one tested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since 2011, pseudorabies based on the pseudorabies virus (PRV) variant has emerged as a serious health issue in pig farms in China. The PRV gE/TK or gE/gI/TK deletion strains protect against emerging PRV variants. However, these variants may cause lethal infections in newborn piglets without PRV antibodies. Previous studies have shown that codon deoptimization of a virulence gene causes virus attenuation. Accordingly, we deoptimized US3-S (US3 gene encoding a short isoform that represents approximately 95% of the total US3 transcription) and <i>UL56</i> genes (first 10 or all codons) of PRV gE/TK deletion strain (PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE-AH02</sup>) to generate six recombinant PRVs through bacterial artificial chromosome technology. In swine testicular cells, recombinant PRVs with all codon deoptimization of <i>US3-S</i> or <i>UL56</i> genes were grown to lower titers than the parental virus. Notably, US3-S or UL56 with all codon deoptimization reduced mRNA and protein expressions. Subsequently, the safety and immunogenicity of recombinant PRVs with codon deoptimization of US3-S or UL56 are evaluated as vaccine candidates in mice and piglets. The mice inoculated with recombinant PRVs with codon deoptimization of US3-S or UL56 showed exceptional survival ability without severe clinical signs. All codons deoptimized (US3-S and UL56) significantly decreased virus load and attenuated pathological changes in the brains of the mice. Moreover, the protection efficiency offered by recombinant PRVs with codon deoptimization of US3-S or UL56 showed similar effects to PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE-AH02</sup>. Remarkably, the 1-day-old PRV antibody-negative piglets inoculated with PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE</sup>-US3-S<sup>T-CD</sup> (a recombinant PRV with all codon deoptimization of US3-S) presented no abnormal clinical symptoms, including fever. The piglets inoculated with PRV<sup>ΔTK&gE</sup>-US3-S<sup>T-CD</sup> showed a high serum neutralization index against the PRV variant. In conclusion, these results suggest using codon deoptimization to generate innovative live attenuated PRV vaccine candidates.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2023construction,
  author = {Mengwei Xu and Laixu Zhu and Aimin Ge and Yamei Liu and Saisai Chen and Ziwen Wei and Yating Zheng and Ling Tong and Zhisheng Wang and Rongmei Fei and Jichun Wang and Chuanjian Zhang},
  title = {{Construction of pseudorabies virus variant attenuated vaccine: codon deoptimization of US3 and UL56 genes based on PRV gE/TK deletion strain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2023.1248573},
}
Figure