Construction of Open Innovation Ecology on the Internet: A Case Study of Xiaomi (China) Using Institutional Logic

Jaime Ortiz, Hao Ren, Kei Li, An ZhangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how core internet companies can effectively build "open innovation ecologies" by motivating users and partners to participate in innovation. Using Xiaomi as a case study, it identifies three key innovation characteristics (iterative, social, joint) and proposes three institutional mechanisms (following, leading, symbiotic) to foster them, all guided by shifting administrative and social institutional logics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid evolution of the internet has blurred the lines between companies, users, and partners, leading to the rise of "open innovation ecologies." While the importance of collaborative innovation is recognized, there's a significant gap in understanding how core enterprises can strategically design and manage these ecologies to effectively motivate diverse participants. Existing research often focuses on resource-based or competitive strategies, neglecting the crucial role of institutional design in fostering user and partner engagement within these complex, dynamic online environments. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating the mechanisms and institutional logic that enable successful open innovation ecology construction.

Methods

The study employs an exploratory single case study method, focusing on Xiaomi, a prominent Chinese internet enterprise known for its open innovation practices. This approach was chosen because open innovation ecology is a relatively new and under-researched phenomenon, making it suitable for in-depth qualitative exploration. The researchers used a "phenomenon-mechanism-reason" framework to guide their analysis.

  • Phenomenon: They first identified the components of Xiaomi's open innovation ecology and the characteristics of user and partner innovation.
  • Mechanism: Next, they analyzed the institutional practices Xiaomi uses to ensure effective participation.
  • Reason: Finally, they delved into the underlying institutional logic driving these practices.

Data was collected through triangulation, involving in-depth interviews with Xiaomi employees and users, analysis of internal and external documents (reports, articles, website content), and site visits for direct observation.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper as datasets for training or evaluation. The study relies on qualitative data gathered through interviews, internal company documents, and external materials related to Xiaomi's operations and innovation activities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Three Pillars of Innovation: Xiaomi's open innovation ecology is characterized by three distinct but interconnected innovation types:
  • Iterative Innovation: Continuous product improvement driven by user feedback, exemplified by the daily beta updates of the MIUI operating system.
  • Social Innovation: Engaging a broad user base through social media and offline activities to gather ideas and foster a sense of community involvement.
  • Joint Innovation: Collaborative development with external partners (eco-chain companies) based on shared advantages and mutual benefit.
  • Institutional Mechanisms for Engagement: To support these innovation types, Xiaomi employs three key institutional practices:
  • Following Mechanism: Primarily for iterative innovation, this involves actively incorporating user suggestions into product updates.
  • Leading Mechanism: Crucial for social innovation, this allows the core enterprise to define participation parameters and guide user input.
  • Symbiotic Mechanism: Essential for joint innovation, this fosters resource and risk sharing between Xiaomi and its partners.
  • Shifting Institutional Logics: The study highlights that different innovation communities within Xiaomi's ecology are governed by distinct, yet complementary, institutional logics:
  • Research Community (MIUI): Dominated by social logic, emphasizing user-driven innovation and responsiveness.
  • Development Community (Mobile Phones): Primarily driven by administrative logic, focusing on structured processes and user suggestion compilation.
  • Application Community (Eco-chain Products): A balance of social and administrative logic, where symbiotic relationships and shared responsibility are key.
  • The Importance of Adaptability: Successfully constructing an open innovation ecology requires core enterprises to accurately understand and adapt to the changing rules of these multi-institutional logics across different innovation contexts.

Key Results

The study identifies three main characteristics of innovation within Xiaomi's open innovation ecology: iterative innovation, social innovation, and joint innovation. It also proposes three new institutional practices—following, leading, and symbiotic mechanisms—as effective means to guarantee user and partner interaction and innovation. Furthermore, it reveals that core enterprises utilize two types of institutional logic—administrative logic and social logic—which shift depending on the innovation community and its characteristics. The study concludes that a deep understanding of these changing institutional logics is fundamental for successful open innovation ecology construction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge two main limitations:

  1. Single Case Study: The research relies solely on Xiaomi due to its large-scale internet background and prominent open innovation characteristics. This limits the generalizability of the findings. Future research should conduct multiple-case studies involving small and medium-sized internet companies to broaden the conclusions.
  2. Exploratory Method: The study used an exploratory case study based on interview data and theoretical analysis, rather than an empirical quantitative approach. Future research should quantitatively test the results to validate the findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

The characteristics of collaborative innovation and interactions among core enterprises, users, and partners are critical. Research is lacking on how to construct open innovation ecology through institutional design. This study explores how core enterprises effectively motivate users and partners to participate in innovation activities on the Internet and successfully constructing open innovation ecology, using the institutional logic theory and an exploratory case study of Xiaomi, a famous Chinese Internet enterprise. The findings are as follows: (1) three main characteristics of innovation carried out by core enterprises, users, and partners in the open innovation ecology—iterative innovation, social innovation, and joint innovation; (2) three new institutional practices—following, leading, and symbiotic mechanisms—which provide an effective institutional guarantee for interaction and innovation; (3) two kinds of institutional logic—administrative logic and social logic, which core enterprises follow to construct open innovation ecology on the Internet, and its change in innovation characteristics. Therefore, a full understanding of the changing rules of the institutional logic is fundamental for successfully building open innovation ecology. This study enriches both the open innovation ecology theory as well as the institutional logic theory. In addition, Xiaomi’s open innovation ecological development model proves that core enterprises can take the approach of building open innovation ecology. It provides a strong example to other enterprises on innovations on the Internet.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ortiz2019construction,
  author = {Jaime Ortiz and Hao Ren and Kei Li and An Zhang},
  title = {{Construction of Open Innovation Ecology on the Internet: A Case Study of Xiaomi (China) Using Institutional Logic}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11113225},
}
Figure