Construction of Mahadevtar Tunnel and Challenges Faced During its Stabilization

Pramod Krishna Adhikari, Pragati Adhikari, Bo Zhang, Ping ChenKTFT 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The Mahadevtar tunnel, a key component of the Kathmandu-Terai Fast Track (Package 1), traverses complex lithology within the Upper Nawakot and Bhimphedi Groups, separated by the Mahabharat Thrust. Excavated using the New Austrian Tunnelling Method (NATM), the project encountered significant variations in rock composition compared to initial designs. Challenges included weathered and jointed rock masses, fault zones, and groundwater inflow, leading to overbreak and collapses. Stabilization was achieved through adaptive support measures, including additional ribs, rock bolts, and specialized grouting protocols.

Introduction: The Himalayan Engineering Challenge

Tunnelling through the Lesser Himalayan succession is an engineering feat defined by active tectonics and geological uncertainty. The Mahadevtar Tunnel project addresses the high degree of unpredictability inherent in this region. The primary challenge lies in the "prediction gap": initial design reports based on preliminary investigations often failed to reflect the actual lithology encountered during excavation. For instance, expected thick bands of limestone were frequently replaced by weaker phyllite and slate, necessitating a shift from rigid design to a highly adaptive "design-as-you-go" approach.

Methodology: Adaptive Tunnelling with NATM

The project utilized the Sequential Excavation Method (SEM), also known as the New Austrian Tunnelling Method (NATM). Unlike traditional methods, NATM treats the surrounding rock mass as a primary structural component rather than just a load to be supported.

Technical Framework

  • Rock Mass Rating (RMR) System: Engineers used the RMR system (Bieniawski, 1989) to classify rock quality in real-time based on uniaxial compressive strength, Rock Quality Designation (RQD), and groundwater conditions.
  • Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR): To mitigate the "surprise factor," GPR was employed to detect geological anomalies, cavities, and water-bearing zones up to 30 meters ahead of the excavation face.
  • 7-Step Stabilization Protocol: For sections experiencing collapse or extreme instability, a rigorous sequence was implemented:
  • Sealing the face with shotcrete and muck.
  • Roofing with hollow steel pipes (spilling rods).
  • Installing steel ribs.
  • Deploying long-penetration rock bolts (>2m).
  • Installing perforated fore poles for grouting.
  • Partial excavation using breakers to avoid explosive-induced vibration.
  • Transitioning back to full excavation once the face stabilized.

Key Insights and Geological Discrepancies

One of the most striking findings was the massive disparity between design predictions and reality. In the exit right tunnel, the design predicted that nearly 47% of the rock would fall into the very poor "P-5-1" class; in reality, only 9.74% did, while the "P-4-2" class was far more prevalent.

Kinematic analysis further revealed that while plane failure was rare, wedge and toppling failures were the primary drivers of instability. This was particularly evident in the entrance tunnel where joint patterns were unfavorable. The tunnel was treated as a "living" structure, with continuous monitoring via Multi-Point Borehole Extensometers (MPBX), strain gauges, and load cells to adjust support measures dynamically.

Results and Stabilization Success

Despite encountering the daunting Mahabharat Thrust—where the rock was described as "dark black, easily crushable by hand, and haphazardly jointed"—the team successfully stabilized the section using the 7-step protocol.

Support diversity was a hallmark of the project's success, ranging from P-3 (relatively solid) to P-6 (extremely weak portal zones). Water management also played a critical role, particularly in the marble sections of the entrance tunnel, where specific drainage and grouting strategies were required to handle significant seepage.

Limitations and Future Recommendations

The unpredictability of the underground environment remains the primary hurdle for Himalayan infrastructure. The authors conclude that initial geological investigations were inadequate for such complex terrains. Future work should prioritize:

  • Enhanced Pre-construction Surveys: Increased investment in deep-borehole investigations and advanced geophysical surveys during the design phase.
  • Refined Adaptive Methods: Better integration of real-time GPR data into the daily excavation cycle to minimize risks at the tunnel face.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Madadevtar tunnel, constructed by China State Construction Engineering Corp. Ltd. as the main contractor for Package 1, is situated in a lithology comprising rock from the Upper Nawakot and Bhimphedi Group. These rock successions are separated by the Mahabharat Thrust. The excavation method employed is the New Austrian Tunnelling Method (NATM), resulting in two fully lined tubes. During design and construction, variations in rock composition were encountered. Similarly, the expected support types for detailed design and construction also exhibited some diversity. Challenges during construction included weathered and jointed rock masses, fault and shear zones, and groundwater inflow. Overbreak and collapses occurred due to weak rock and joint conditions. Addressing these issues involved installing additional ribs, rock bolts, grouting, and replacing sections in some parts of left and right tunnels.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adhikari2024construction,
  author = {Pramod Krishna Adhikari and Pragati Adhikari and Bo Zhang and Ping Chen},
  title = {{Construction of Mahadevtar Tunnel and Challenges Faced During its Stabilization}},
  booktitle = {KTFT},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3126/ktftj.v4i1.70451},
}
Figure