Construction of an Evaluation Model for the Protective Efficacy of Ovine Brucellosis Vaccines

Shufeng Niu, Yong Meng, Churiga Man, Wei-Wei Wu, Wenxin Zheng, Dongling Wu, Changsuo Zhang, Chuanyu He, Jianliang Cao, Hailong Zhao, Huan Wang, Mengqi Zhang, Guanghua He, Jun Chen, Li Zhang, Dan Tian, Qiaoling Chen, Hongyan Gao, Li Du, Si Chen, Fengyang WangResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Introduction

Brucellosis remains one of the most significant zoonotic diseases globally, posing severe risks to both public health and the livestock economy. In regions like China, where mutton sheep farming is a critical economic pillar, the control and eradication of Brucella infections are paramount. Vaccination is the primary strategy for disease management; however, evaluating vaccine efficacy in sheep presents substantial challenges.

The traditional "gold standard" for assessing protection—measuring the total bacterial load in an animal following a virulent challenge—is logistically complex and often impractical for large-scale studies. Conversely, relying solely on serological assays (antibody titers) is frequently misleading, as high antibody levels do not necessarily correlate with cellular immunity or actual protection against this intracellular pathogen. This study addresses the need for a comprehensive, multi-dimensional evaluation model that integrates bacteriological, immunological, and pathological data.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a controlled experimental study using 33 healthy Xinjiang fine-wool sheep. The subjects were challenged with a highly virulent strain of Brucella melitensis (M28) via conjunctival instillation. Post-infection, the team tracked 35 distinct indicators across three primary domains:

  1. Bacteriological Indicators: Bacterial loads were measured in nine target tissues, including the spleen and various lymph nodes (parotid, submandibular, prescapular, and inguinal).
  2. Immunological Indicators: Serum antibody levels were assessed using RBT, SAT, cELISA, and iELISA. Additionally, cytokine levels (IFN-γ, IL-6, IL-12, IL-17, and Neopterin) were monitored to evaluate the host's immune response.
  3. Pathological Indicators: The study utilized gross anatomical scoring (evaluating visible changes in organ size and color) and detailed histopathological examinations.

To synthesize this data into a predictive model, the researchers compared two statistical techniques: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for dimensionality reduction and Stepwise Regression Analysis for optimized variable selection.

Results and Discussion

The study successfully developed a high-precision evaluation model, with the Stepwise Regression Model (R) emerging as the superior tool compared to the PCA-based approach.

Model Performance

The Stepwise Regression Model achieved an exceptional Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.974 and a correlation coefficient (Rho) of 0.864. This indicates a near-perfect ability to distinguish between protected and unprotected states. In contrast, the PCA model (F) yielded an AUC of 0.905 and a Rho of 0.768. The final optimized model distilled the 35 initial indicators down to 9 essential metrics:

  • Serological: SAT, cELISA, and cELISA (BS)
  • Immunological: IL-12 and IL-17
  • Bacteriological: Left parotid and left submandibular lymph node loads
  • Pathological: Left and right parotid lymph node gross anatomical scores

Immunological Dynamics

A key insight from the model was the "tug-of-war" between IL-12 and IL-17. IL-12 was found to negatively regulate bacterial load, supporting its role in driving the protective Th1 immune response. Conversely, IL-17 levels were positively correlated with bacterial load, suggesting that IL-17 might suppress effective pathogen clearance in the context of ovine brucellosis. Furthermore, the study noted an "IgG lag," where iELISA results (measuring IgG) were negatively correlated with bacterial load because IgG production often peaks after the initial bacterial surge.

Practicality of Indicators

The model favored gross anatomical scores over histopathology. Gross scores provided better inter-individual differentiation and are more practical for clinical or field settings. Additionally, the study confirmed that bacterial loads in superficial lymph nodes (parotid and submandibular) serve as effective proxies for the animal's overall infection status, simplifying the data collection process for future evaluations.

Conclusion

This study provides the first comprehensive evaluation system for sheep brucellosis vaccine efficacy. By moving beyond simple antibody testing and integrating multiple biological dimensions, the Stepwise Regression Model offers a robust and highly accurate standard for livestock disease control. Future research will focus on validating this model in vaccinated cohorts and exploring its application in automated diagnostic systems to accelerate eradication efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> This study developed a comprehensive model for evaluating sheep brucellosis vaccine efficacy by integrating bacteriological, immunological, and pathological indicators.Thirty-three healthy Xinjiang fine-wool sheep were challenged <italic>via</italic> conjunctival instillation with <italic>Brucella melitensis</italic> strain M28, and paired lymph nodes, spleen, and serum were collected post-infection. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) identified three principal components (81.935% variance), whose comprehensive score (F) strongly correlated with average bacterial load ( <italic>P</italic> &lt; 0.01, AUC = 0.905); key indicators included left submandibular, left prescapular, and left inguinal lymph node bacterial loads, and cELISA antibody titers. An optimized stepwise regression model retained 9 indicators (SAT, cELISA, cELISA (BS), IL-12, IL-17, left parotid lymph node bacterial loads, left submandibular lymph node bacterial loads, left parotid lymph node gross anatomical scores, right parotid lymph node gross anatomical scores). This model (R) demonstrated superior predictive accuracy (AUC = 0.974, Rho = 0.864 vs. PCA's 0.905 and 0.768) and revealed IL-17 positively and IL-12 negatively regulated bacterial load. This study presents the first comprehensive system for sheep brucellosis vaccine efficacy, offering robust technical support for eradication efforts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{niu2025construction,
  author = {Shufeng Niu and Yong Meng and Churiga Man and Wei-Wei Wu and Wenxin Zheng and Dongling Wu and Changsuo Zhang and Chuanyu He and Jianliang Cao and Hailong Zhao and Huan Wang and Mengqi Zhang and Guanghua He and Jun Chen and Li Zhang and Dan Tian and Qiaoling Chen and Hongyan Gao and Li Du and Si Chen and Fengyang Wang},
  title = {{Construction of an Evaluation Model for the Protective Efficacy of Ovine Brucellosis Vaccines}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-7705539/v1},
}
Figure