Construction Method of a Guaranteed Grid Considering the Specific Recovery Process

Shengfeng Zhang, Jie Zhao, Yixuan Weng, Dichen Liu, Weizhe Ma, Yuhui MaSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method for designing power grids that not only ensures reliable power supply under normal conditions but also prioritizes rapid and successful recovery after blackouts. By considering the specific steps and influencing factors of the recovery process, the authors develop an optimization framework that significantly improves grid resilience and reduces outage durations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional power grid planning often focuses on ensuring sufficient power supply capacity and operational stability during normal conditions. However, this approach can fall short when blackouts occur, especially in areas prone to natural disasters. Existing methods for "guaranteed grids" (those designed for high reliability) often overlook the crucial details of the grid's recovery process. This oversight can lead to suboptimal grid structures that are slow to restore, have a low success rate for bringing critical units back online, and ultimately result in prolonged and costly outages. The paper aims to bridge this gap by explicitly incorporating the dynamics of grid recovery into the design phase, ensuring that a grid is not only robust but also inherently resilient and quick to rebound from disruptions.

Methods

The proposed method employs a two-stage optimization approach:

  1. Normal Scenario Optimization: A multi-objective optimization model is developed to optimize the grid structure for normal operation. This model considers three key objectives:
  2. Power Supply Capacity: Ensuring sufficient power to meet important load demands and maintain power balance.
  3. Smooth Transmission: Minimizing line congestion and ensuring power flow within limits.
  4. Safety Margin: Guaranteeing stable operation by maintaining adequate margins between electrical quantities and operational limits. This stage utilizes a Discrete Particle Swarm Optimization (DPSO) algorithm to find a Pareto non-dominated solution set.

  5. Recovery Scenario Re-Optimization: The Pareto solutions from the normal scenario are then re-optimized to account for power failure recovery. This stage introduces a "recovery index" that quantifies both the recovery time and the recovery success rate.

  6. Recovery Index: This index is formulated to penalize longer recovery times and lower success rates.
  7. Dijkstra Algorithm: This classic shortest path algorithm is adapted to find the optimal recovery path. It's used to identify paths that maximize the recovery success rate and minimize recovery time, considering factors like line charging overvoltage and transformer parameters. The algorithm is further enhanced with an "equivalent node" concept to simplify complex network topologies during recovery path analysis.

Datasets

The paper uses the IEEE-30 node system as a standard benchmark for evaluating its proposed method. This system is a well-established testbed for power system analysis and optimization. The authors also mention an "actual power grid calculation example" in Guangdong Province, China, which consists of 138 nodes and 319 branches, to demonstrate the practical applicability of their approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Recovery is not just about capacity: The paper highlights that simply having enough power generation capacity isn't enough for effective recovery. The process of recovery, including the sequence of operations, the path taken, and the influence of specific equipment, is critical.
  • Black start power location matters: The position of the black start power supply significantly impacts the recovery path, time, and success rate, underscoring the need to consider this in grid design.
  • Quantifying recovery is key: Developing a concrete "recovery index" that combines success rate and time allows for a more holistic optimization than considering these factors in isolation.
  • Dijkstra for resilience: Adapting Dijkstra's algorithm, typically used for shortest paths, to find optimal recovery paths (maximizing success, minimizing time) is a clever application of a well-known tool to a new problem domain.
  • Trade-offs are inherent: The study demonstrates that there are trade-offs between normal operation objectives (e.g., power supply capacity vs. safety margin) and recovery performance, necessitating a balanced optimization approach.

Key Results

The proposed method, when applied to the IEEE-30 node system, demonstrated significant improvements in recovery capability.

  • Option 2 emerged as the optimal scheme, achieving a recovery success rate of 0.96 and a total recovery time of 1.12 (units not explicitly stated, but implied to be normalized or relative). This option was found to be superior to schemes that only considered normal operation or other existing methods.
  • Compared to a scheme with a higher power supply capacity (Option 1), Option 2, despite a 15.5% lower power supply capacity, achieved a 24.4% increase in recovery success rate.
  • The method effectively adjusted the optimal scheme based on the location of the black start power supply, showing that the proposed strategy is adaptable to equipment parameter changes and placement.
  • The analysis of the Guangdong Province grid example further validated the method's applicability to larger, real-world systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Sensitivity: While the paper mentions adjusting weights (e.g., $\beta_2$) based on demand, the sensitivity of the optimization to these weights and other parameters could be further explored.
  • Dynamic Disturbances: The current model primarily focuses on recovery after a blackout. Future work could investigate how the grid structure might be optimized to withstand and recover from dynamic disturbances during operation.
  • Advanced Recovery Scenarios: The paper could be extended to consider more complex recovery scenarios, such as cascading failures or the integration of advanced grid technologies like energy storage systems.
  • Real-time Optimization: While this paper focuses on grid construction, future research could explore real-time or near-real-time optimization of recovery strategies based on evolving grid conditions during an outage.

Summary updated

Abstract

For the planning of the guaranteed power grid, only the operation capacity of the target grid is considered. The recovery process and steps of the backbone grid are not considered enough, which leads to two defects: the minimum guaranteed power grid is not conducive to the unit recovery and the recovery time is too long. In this paper, a method of constructing the grid with the specific recovery process is proposed. Considering the influence of the grid structure and the position of the black start power supply on the recovery steps, the recovery success rate and the recovery time of the grid, the optimization of the grid structure of the guaranteed grid can meet the demand of power supply and at the same time make the recovery of the target grid less time-consuming and achieve a higher recovery success rate in the event of a blackout. In this method, two aspects are considered: the power failure recovery scenario in the recovery process of the target grid and the normal power supply scenario, reflecting the power supply performance after the recovery of the target grid. In the normal power supply scenario, a three-objective optimization model including power supply capacity, smooth transmission and safety margin is constructed, with power supply capacity and safe operation as constraints. In the scenario of power failure recovery, the process of power grid recovery and the mechanism affecting the success of recovery are analyzed to form the line recovery index. The Dijkstra algorithm is used to search for the optimal recovery path and calculate the recovery index, so as to reoptimize the backbone power grid. The validity of the method is verified by standard and practical examples.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2020construction,
  author = {Shengfeng Zhang and Jie Zhao and Yixuan Weng and Dichen Liu and Weizhe Ma and Yuhui Ma},
  title = {{Construction Method of a Guaranteed Grid Considering the Specific Recovery Process}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12093935},
}
Figure