Constraints on the progenitor systems of type Ia supernovae

M. Stritzinger, B. Leibundgut, Stefanie Walch, Gabriella ContardoSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the bolometric light curves of 16 Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) to constrain their progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms. They find significant variations in ejected mass and synthesized $^{56}$Ni, suggesting that not all SNe Ia originate from a single progenitor model, and that sub-Chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs might be involved in some cases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Type Ia supernovae are crucial cosmological tools, but their fundamental nature – specifically, the progenitor systems and the physics of their explosions – remains poorly understood. While the leading model involves the thermonuclear explosion of a carbon-oxygen white dwarf near the Chandrasekhar mass, observed SNe Ia exhibit a wide range in luminosity (a factor of ten). This heterogeneity challenges a single, self-consistent explosion model and raises concerns about the reliability of SNe Ia as standard candles for cosmology. The authors aim to shed light on these issues by analyzing detailed photometric data to derive key physical parameters of the supernovae.

Methods

The core of the study involves constructing UVOIR (ultraviolet to near-infrared) bolometric light curves from observed photometric data. These light curves are then used to derive several global parameters:

  • $^{56}$Ni Mass: This is estimated from the peak bolometric luminosity using Arnett's Rule, which relates luminosity to the instantaneous energy deposition rate from radioactive decays.
  • Total Ejected Mass ($M_{ej}$): This is determined by fitting a radioactive decay energy deposition function to the post-maximum phase of the UVOIR light curve. This fitting process yields a "fiducial time" ($t_0$), the epoch when the ejecta becomes optically thin. This $t_0$ is then used in a parameterized model (Jeffery 1999) to calculate $M_{ej}$.
  • γ-ray Escape Fraction: This is calculated by comparing the observed UVOIR light curve to theoretical models assuming either complete trapping or complete escape of γ-rays.

The authors also discuss the impact of distance uncertainties and different distance measurement methods (Cepheid, SBF, CMB) on their derived parameters.

Datasets

The study utilizes observational data from sixteen well-observed SNe Ia. The photometric data, primarily in (U)BVRI bands, were compiled from various sources, with a focus on events having pre-maximum to ~100 days post-maximum light coverage. Galactic reddening values were taken from Schlegel et al. (1998), and host galaxy reddenings were selected from Phillips et al. (1999) or adopted from the literature. Distances were primarily derived from literature values, with a preference for Cepheid distances, and CMB velocities were used when direct distance measurements were unavailable.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diversity in Ejected Mass: The analysis reveals that the total ejected mass in SNe Ia can vary by at least a factor of two. This is a significant finding, as it challenges the notion of a uniform explosion outcome.
  • Sub-Chandrasekhar Progenitors Possible: The observed range in ejected mass, particularly the lower values, suggests that some SNe Ia might originate from progenitors with masses below the Chandrasekhar limit. This is a departure from the dominant theoretical paradigm.
  • $^{56}$Ni Mass Variation Implies Diverse Burning: The significant range in the synthesized $^{56}$Ni mass (a factor of ten) points to variations in the nuclear burning mechanisms during the explosion. This suggests that the explosion itself, rather than just the progenitor mass, plays a crucial role in determining the nucleosynthesis.
  • No Clear Correlation Between $M_{ej}$ and $^{56}$Ni Mass: Interestingly, the study finds little to no correlation between the total ejected mass and the amount of $^{56}$Ni produced. This further supports the idea that different explosion physics or initial conditions lead to diverse outcomes.
  • γ-ray Escape Fraction Varies with Luminosity: Less luminous SNe Ia show a higher γ-ray escape fraction at later times, indicating differences in their ejecta opacity and structure.

Key Results

  • The $^{56}$Ni mass among the observed SNe Ia ranges from approximately 0.1 to 1.0 solar masses.
  • The total ejected mass ($M_{ej}$) varies by at least a factor of two, with some events showing $M_{ej}$ values significantly below the canonical 1.4 solar mass Chandrasekhar limit.
  • The fiducial time ($t_0$), indicating when the ejecta becomes optically thin, varies by a factor of 1.6 across the sample.
  • The γ-ray escape fraction evolves with time and is found to be higher for less luminous events at 60 days past maximum light.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Distance and Extinction Uncertainties: The derived parameters, particularly $^{56}$Ni mass and ejected mass, are sensitive to uncertainties in host galaxy distances and extinction.
  • Model Parameterization: The use of a parameterized model for ejected mass (Jeffery 1999) relies on assumptions about the y-ray opacity, ejecta velocity, and the distribution of $^{56}$Ni. While these are based on existing models, they may not perfectly capture the complexity of real SN Ia explosions.
  • Early-Time γ-ray Escape: The y-ray escape fraction is unreliable during the first three weeks after maximum light due to the ejecta being optically thick.

Future work suggested includes:

  • 3D Radiative Transfer Calculations: Comparing UVOIR light curves to detailed 3D radiative transfer models would provide more robust constraints on progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms.
  • Investigating Sub-Chandrasekhar Models: Further theoretical work on sub-Chandrasekhar mass models is needed to understand their viability and how they might explain the observed diversity.
  • Understanding Burning Mechanisms: More detailed modeling of the explosion mechanism is required to explain the wide range in synthesized $^{56}$Ni and the resulting luminosity variations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bolometric light curves provide a valuable insight into the nature of type Ia supernovae. We present an analysis of sixteen well-observed type Ia supernovae. Constraints are placed on several global parameters concerning the progenitor system, explosion mechanism, and subsequent radiation transport. By fitting a radioactive decay energy deposition function to the quasi-exponential phase (50 to 100 days after maximum light), it is found that the ejected mass varies by at least a factor of two. This result suggests that a sub Chandrasekhar mass white dwarf could be the progenitor system of some type Ia supernovae. We find that the range in the amount of synthesized $\rm ^{56}Ni$ indicates a significant variation in the burning mechanism. In order to explain a factor of ten range in the observed bolometric luminosity, more detailed modeling of the explosion mechanism is required.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{stritzinger2006constraints,
  author = {M. Stritzinger and B. Leibundgut and Stefanie Walch and Gabriella Contardo},
  title = {{Constraints on the progenitor systems of type Ia supernovae}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361:20053652/pdf},
}
Figure