TL;DR
This paper presents a novel method for constraining the CKM angle $\gamma$ by analyzing neutral $B$ meson decays into $D^0$ mesons and $K^{*0}$ resonances. Using a large dataset from the BABAR experiment, they demonstrate that this approach can provide competitive precision for $\gamma$ determination, comparable to analyses of charged $B$ decays.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The CKM matrix describes the flavor mixing of quarks in the Standard Model of particle physics. The unitarity of this matrix leads to a geometric representation called the Unitarity Triangle, whose angles encode fundamental CP-violating phases. Measuring these angles, particularly the angle $\gamma$, is crucial for testing the Standard Model and searching for new physics. While various methods exist to determine $\gamma$, they often suffer from large uncertainties or rely on specific theoretical assumptions. This paper addresses the challenge of precisely measuring $\gamma$ by exploring a new channel: neutral $B$ meson decays ($B^0$ and $\overline{B}^0$) that decay into a $D^0$ or $\overline{D}^0$ meson and a $K^{*0}$ or $\overline{K}^{*0}$ resonance. The $D^0$ meson is further reconstructed in its $K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ decay mode, allowing for a Dalitz analysis. This approach leverages the interference between different decay amplitudes to extract information about $\gamma$.
Methods
The core of this paper is a Dalitz analysis of the $D^0 \to K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ decay. A Dalitz plot visualizes the distribution of decay products in a two-body decay (or a three-body decay where two particles are treated as a resonance). By analyzing the amplitude and phase of the different contributions to the $D^0$ decay, particularly the interference between $b \to c$ and $b \to u$ transitions in the parent $B^0$ decay, the CKM angle $\gamma$ can be extracted.
Key methodological aspects include:
- Dalitz Plot Analysis: The $D^0 \to K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ decay is analyzed using a Dalitz plot, which maps the invariant masses of the $K_S\pi^+$ and $K_S\pi^-$ pairs. This allows for the disentanglement of different resonant contributions (e.g., $K^*(892)^0$) and the extraction of interference terms.
- Flavor Tagging: Neutral $B$ mesons are produced in pairs from the $e^+e^- \to B\overline{B}$ process. The flavor of the other $B$ meson in the pair is used to tag the flavor of the signal $B^0$ meson (i.e., whether it is a $B^0$ or a $\overline{B}^0$).
- K*0 Reconstruction: The $K^{*0}$ resonance is reconstructed from its decay into $K^+\pi^-$ or $K^-\pi^+$. The analysis accounts for the finite width of the $K^{*0}$ resonance.
- Likelihood Fit: An unbinned extended maximum likelihood fit is performed on the variables $M_{ES}$ (beam-energy substituted mass), $F$ (Fisher discriminant for background rejection), and $\Delta t$ (time difference between the two $B$ decays). This fit simultaneously extracts signal yields, background contributions, and CP parameters, including $\gamma$.
- Parameterization of Amplitudes: The decay amplitudes for $D^0 \to K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ are described using an isobar model, incorporating various resonances. The strong phase difference between the $b \to c$ and $b \to u$ amplitudes is crucial for $\gamma$ extraction.
- Systematic Uncertainty Evaluation: A thorough evaluation of systematic uncertainties is performed, considering contributions from the Dalitz model for the signal, PDF shapes, peaking backgrounds, the parameter $k$, efficiency variations, and Dalitz background parameters.
Datasets
The analysis utilizes a data sample of $371 \times 10^6$ $B\overline{B}$ pairs collected by the BABAR detector at the PEP-II storage ring. A small fraction of the data (35 fb$^{-1}$) was taken at an energy 40 MeV below the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance, which is used to study continuum ($e^+e^- \to q\overline{q}$) backgrounds. Monte Carlo (MC) simulations are extensively used to model signal and background processes, determine selection efficiencies, and evaluate systematic uncertainties.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Neutral $B$ Decays as a Probe for $\gamma$: This paper demonstrates the viability of using neutral $B$ meson decays, specifically $B^0 \to D^0 K^{*0}$ and its charge conjugate, for determining $\gamma$. This complements existing methods that primarily rely on charged $B$ decays.
- Dalitz Analysis Power: The Dalitz analysis of the $D^0 \to K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ decay is shown to be a powerful tool for disentangling different decay amplitudes and extracting interference effects sensitive to $\gamma$.
- Interference of $b \to c$ and $b \to u$ Amplitudes: The key to measuring $\gamma$ lies in the interference between the dominant $b \to c$ transition and the suppressed $b \to u$ transition in the $B^0$ decay. The Dalitz analysis of the daughter $D^0$ meson allows for the precise measurement of this interference.
- Importance of $r_S$: The analysis highlights the dependence of the $\gamma$ measurement on $r_S$, the ratio of the magnitudes of the $b \to u$ and $b \to c$ amplitudes. This parameter needs to be determined or constrained to obtain a precise value for $\gamma$.
- Complementarity with Other Methods: The results are compared with those from charged $B$ decays, showing consistency and suggesting that this neutral $B$ decay channel can contribute significantly to improving the precision of $\gamma$ measurements.
Key Results
The paper presents constraints on $\gamma$, $\delta_S$ (a strong phase difference), and $r_S$ from a three-dimensional likelihood fit.
- At 68% probability, the results are:
- $\gamma = (162 \pm 56)^\circ$ or $(342 \pm 56)^\circ$
- $\delta_S = (62 \pm 57)^\circ$ or $(242 \pm 57)^\circ$
- $r_S < 0.30$
- At 95% probability, the constraints are:
- $\gamma \in [77^\circ, 247^\circ]$ or $[257^\circ, 426^\circ]$
- $\delta_S \in [-23^\circ, 147^\circ]$ or $[157^\circ, 327^\circ]$
- $r_S < 0.55$
- The statistical uncertainty on $\gamma$ is approximately $56^\circ$.
- The paper demonstrates that the precision of the $\gamma$ measurement is comparable to that obtained from a single charged $B$ channel analysis.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistical Uncertainty: The primary limitation is the statistical uncertainty on $\gamma$, which is still relatively large ($56^\circ$ at 68% CL). This is attributed to the relatively small signal yield and high background level in the analyzed decays.
- Dependence on $r_S$: The precision of the $\gamma$ measurement is sensitive to the value of $r_S$. While the analysis provides a constraint on $r_S$, combining it with external measurements of $r_S$ (e.g., from ADS methods) is shown to improve the precision.
- Dalitz Model Systematics: The Dalitz model used to describe the $D^0 \to K_S \pi^+\pi^-$ decay is identified as a significant source of systematic uncertainty, as observed in previous analyses.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that with larger datasets, this method can provide a significant contribution to the precise determination of $\gamma$. They also highlight the potential for this technique to achieve precision comparable to that of charged $B$ decay channels. Further refinement of the Dalitz model and improved background rejection techniques could also lead to more precise results.
Summary updated