Abstract
We consider a simplified model for Majorana fermion dark matter and explore constraints from direct, indirect and LHC collider searches. The dark matter is assumed to couple to the Standard Model through a vector mediator with axial-vector interactions. We provide detailed analyses of LHC monojet searches and IceCube limits on dark matter annihilation in the Sun. In particular, we develop a method for calculating limits on simplified WIMP dark matter models from public IceCube data, which are only available for a limited number of Standard Model final states. We demonstrate that LHC and IceCube searches for Majorana dark matter are complementary and derive new limits on the dark matter and mediator masses, including in addition constraints from LHC dijet searches, direct detection and the dark matter relic density.
Introduction
Dark matter (DM) remains one of the most significant mysteries in modern physics. To identify this elusive substance, researchers employ three primary strategies: direct detection of DM-nucleus scattering, indirect detection of annihilation products (such as neutrinos from the Sun), and direct production at high-energy colliders like the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Historically, these searches were often compared using Effective Field Theories (EFTs), which assume the mediator particle is extremely heavy. However, EFTs can be misleading at the high energies of the LHC. This paper moves beyond the EFT paradigm by using a simplified model that explicitly includes a vector mediator, revealing a powerful complementarity between collider and astrophysical searches.
The Simplified Model Approach
The researchers focused on a model where Majorana fermion dark matter ($\chi$) interacts with Standard Model quarks via a vector mediator ($V$) with axial-vector couplings. Unlike EFTs, this approach accounts for the dynamical effects of the mediator, such as resonance enhancement and kinematic thresholds. A key parameter in this model is the mediator's total width ($\Gamma_V$), which is determined by its couplings to both dark matter and quarks.
As shown in Figure 1, the width-to-mass ratio saturates at high mass ratios. This relationship is crucial because it defines the regions of parameter space where the model is physically consistent, a detail often overlooked in simpler EFT treatments.
Methodology and Datasets
The study integrated data from several major experimental efforts:
- LHC Run 1: Mono-jet and di-jet search data from ATLAS and CMS (8 TeV) were used to constrain DM production.
- IceCube: 317 days of data from the 79-string and 86-string configurations. The authors developed a novel weighted-average method to map public IceCube data onto complex final states like top quarks ($t\bar{t}$) or mediator pairs ($VV$).
- LUX: Spin-dependent WIMP-neutron scattering limits provided a benchmark for direct detection.
- Planck: Cosmological observations were used to determine the required dark matter relic density ($\Omega_{DM}h^2$).
Key Results: The Power of Complementarity
The analysis demonstrates that the LHC and IceCube are highly complementary. The LHC is most sensitive to light dark matter (below ~100 GeV) through mono-jet signatures. Conversely, IceCube becomes most powerful at intermediate and high masses (200 GeV to 1 TeV), particularly near the threshold where DM can annihilate into heavy top quarks, producing high-energy neutrinos that are easier to detect.
As illustrated in Figure 6, combining these searches effectively "closes the net" on large swaths of the parameter space. For certain coupling strengths, mediator masses up to 1 TeV are excluded for light dark matter. The study also validated the new IceCube re-interpretation method, showing excellent agreement with internal IceCube analyses.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
By moving beyond simplified EFT assumptions, this research provides a more accurate and comprehensive map of the Majorana dark matter landscape. The results highlight that no single search strategy is sufficient; rather, the combination of collider and astrophysical data is essential for a robust search. Future data from LHC Run 2 (13 TeV) and upgraded neutrino observatories are expected to further constrain the remaining parameter space, potentially leading to a definitive discovery of the mediator particle or the dark matter itself.
Summary updated