TL;DR
This paper investigates potential new interactions between neutrinos and exotic fermions (like dark matter candidates) using data from neutrino-electron scattering experiments. By analyzing data from CHARM-II, TEXONO, and Borexino, the researchers place stringent constraints on the strength of these new interactions, ruling out many possibilities and providing crucial guidance for future searches for new physics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Standard Model of particle physics, while incredibly successful, doesn't explain phenomena like neutrino oscillations (which imply neutrinos have mass) or the existence of dark matter. These observations strongly suggest the existence of new particles and interactions beyond the Standard Model. Neutrino-electron scattering experiments offer a unique window into these possibilities, as they are sensitive to subtle interactions that can modify the scattering process. Specifically, this paper addresses how to constrain the properties of hypothetical "exotic fermions" – particles that interact with both neutrinos and electrons – by analyzing existing neutrino-electron scattering data. This is particularly relevant given recent hints of new physics from dark matter direct detection experiments like XENON1T, which observed an excess of electron recoil events.
Methods
The authors employ a theoretical framework that extends the Standard Model by introducing an "exotic fermion" ($\chi$) that can interact with neutrinos and electrons through various types of operators. These interactions are categorized into two main types: dimension-5 dipole operators (related to electromagnetic and magnetic dipole moments) and dimension-6 four-fermion operators (scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, axialvector, and tensor interactions). They then calculate the differential cross-sections for neutrino-electron scattering processes involving these new interactions. The core of their analysis involves comparing these theoretical predictions with experimental data from three key neutrino-electron scattering experiments:
- CHARM-II: Used high-energy muon neutrino and antineutrino beams.
- TEXONO: Utilized reactor antineutrinos.
- Borexino: Focused on low-energy solar neutrinos.
By performing a $\chi^2$ analysis, they derive upper bounds on the coupling coefficients of these new interactions as a function of the exotic fermion's mass ($m_\chi$). They also explore scenarios where these interactions are "flavor-universal" (the same for all neutrino flavors) and "flavor-dependent" (different for different neutrino flavors).
Datasets
The paper utilizes publicly available experimental data from the following neutrino-electron scattering experiments:
- CHARM-II: Differential cross-section measurements for $\nu_\mu + e^- \rightarrow \nu_\mu + e^-$ and $\bar{\nu}_\mu + e^- \rightarrow \bar{\nu}_\mu + e^-$.
- TEXONO: Event rates for $\bar{\nu}_e + e^- \rightarrow \bar{\nu}_e + e^-$ in different recoil energy bins.
- Borexino: Measured event rates for solar neutrino-electron scattering, considering different solar neutrino sources (pp, $^7$Be, pep, and $^{8}$B).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Neutrino experiments as dark matter probes: The study highlights how precision neutrino experiments, traditionally used to study neutrino properties, can also be powerful tools for searching for dark matter and other new physics.
- Complementarity of experiments: Different neutrino experiments probe different energy ranges and neutrino flavors, making them complementary in constraining new physics. Low-energy experiments like Borexino are particularly sensitive to electromagnetic dipole interactions at low masses, while higher-energy experiments like CHARM-II are better for other interaction types.
- Flavor dependence matters: The constraints on new interactions can be significantly weakened if they are flavor-dependent, meaning they affect different neutrino flavors differently. This is because experiments often focus on specific neutrino flavors.
- XENON1T excess connection: The paper explores whether the vector coefficients preferred by the XENON1T excess are compatible with neutrino-electron scattering data, finding that they are indeed allowed. This suggests a potential link between dark matter signals and neutrino physics.
Key Results
- Stringent flavor-universal bounds: For flavor-universal interactions, CHARM-II provides the strongest bounds for scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, axialvector, and tensor interactions up to $m_\chi \approx 50$ MeV, with limits on coupling coefficients around $| \epsilon | \sim 1$ or less. Borexino sets the strongest bounds for electromagnetic dipole interactions at low masses ($m_\chi < 1$ MeV), with limits around $| \epsilon_{M,E} | < 1.3 \times 10^{-6}$ for $m_\chi \leq 0.1$ MeV.
- Flavor-dependent bounds can be avoided: If interactions are flavor-dependent, the stringent bounds from CHARM-II (for $\nu_\mu$) or TEXONO (for $\bar{\nu}_e$) can be circumvented. Borexino, due to flavor oscillations of solar neutrinos, can constrain combinations of flavor-dependent couplings.
- XENON1T favored region is allowed: The vector interaction coefficients favored by the XENON1T excess are found to be consistent with the constraints from neutrino-electron scattering experiments.
Limitations and Future Work
- Model dependence of flavor-dependent bounds: The analysis of flavor-dependent bounds is illustrated with specific examples (scalar and vector interactions) and assumes real coupling coefficients. A full exploration of all flavor-dependent scenarios would be more complex.
- UV completion for DM: The paper discusses the implications of the exotic fermion as a dark matter candidate but notes that the calculation of the final DM abundance relies on the details of the "UV completion" (the underlying theory at higher energies).
- Future detectors: The authors mention that future experiments like the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) detector will be able to probe significantly larger parameter spaces, potentially testing the XENON1T favored region more comprehensively. Further studies on the detection of sub-MeV dark matter absorbed by electrons are also suggested.
Summary updated