Constraints on a mixed inflaton and curvaton scenario for the generation of the curvature perturbation

G. Lazarides, Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Roberto TrottaPhysical 2004 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper investigates a supersymmetric (SUSY) grand unified theory (GUT) where the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) field—traditionally introduced to resolve the strong $CP$ problem—serves as a "curvaton" to generate primordial density fluctuations. Unlike standard models where either the inflaton or the curvaton dominates, this study explores a mixed scenario where both contribute to the total curvature perturbation. By confronting the model with first-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) data, we analyze the resulting adiabatic and isocurvature perturbations. Our results indicate that while the model is theoretically robust, the data strongly favors an inflaton-dominated perturbation spectrum. Bayesian model comparison reveals that curvaton-dominant scenarios are significantly disfavored compared to the standard scale-invariant inflaton model.

Introduction

In the standard cosmological paradigm, a single scalar field, the inflaton, is responsible for both the exponential expansion of the early universe and the generation of primordial density seeds. However, the curvaton hypothesis provides an alternative mechanism where a second light field generates these perturbations after inflation ends. This paper explores a well-motivated particle physics framework—a Supersymmetric Left-Right symmetric GUT—where the Peccei-Quinn field acts as this curvaton. This model is particularly elegant as it simultaneously addresses the strong $CP$ problem and the $\mu$ problem of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM).

Theoretical Framework and the PQ Curvaton

The model utilizes a SUSY GUT structure where the PQ symmetry is broken, leading to the existence of axions. In this context, the PQ field remains light during inflation and acquires fluctuations. After inflation, these fluctuations are converted into curvature perturbations.

A unique feature of this framework is the mixed nature of the perturbations. Because both the inflaton and the PQ field (curvaton) are active, the total curvature perturbation is a combination of both. Furthermore, the model predicts the existence of isocurvature perturbations—fluctuations in the ratio of species densities (specifically axions vs. photons)—which are partially correlated with the adiabatic (total density) perturbations. This correlation creates a distinct signature in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) power spectrum.

Methodology

To test the viability of this mixed scenario, the authors employed a rigorous statistical approach:

  1. Numerical Inference: A Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis was performed using a modified version of the cosmomc package to explore the high-dimensional parameter space.
  2. Datasets: The model was constrained using the WMAP first-year data (TT and TE spectra), supplemented by small-scale CMB data from the ACBAR and CBI experiments, and BOOMERANG data for specific peak analysis.
  3. Bayesian Model Comparison: To evaluate whether the added complexity of the curvaton was statistically justified, the authors calculated Bayes factors using the Laplace approximation. This method penalizes models with extra parameters that do not significantly improve the fit to the data, effectively applying "Occam's Razor."

Results and Discussion

The analysis focused on two primary parameter sets, representing different physical regimes:

Model A: Inflaton-Dominant Regime

In this scenario, the inflaton provides the majority of the primordial perturbation. The analysis found that the curvaton's contribution to the adiabatic amplitude must be less than 67% at the 95% confidence level. While this model can fit the CMB data reasonably well, it is statistically disfavored. The Bayesian evidence shows odds of approximately 50 to 1 against this model when compared to a simpler, scale-invariant inflaton-only model.

Model B: Curvaton-Dominant Regime

In this case, the curvaton is the primary source of the universe's density fluctuations. However, this regime is strongly disfavored by the data, with odds of $10^7$ to 1 against it relative to the standard inflaton model.

The Reionization Mimic

One interesting finding was the "reionization mimic" effect. A modest curvaton contribution can produce CMB signatures similar to a larger optical depth (indicating later reionization). While this helps the model fit certain aspects of the spectrum, it is insufficient to overcome the statistical penalty of the model's complexity. The study also established quantitative bounds: for the best-fitting cases, the amplitude of the partial curvature perturbation from the curvaton must remain below $43.2 \times 10^{-5}$.

Conclusion

The investigation demonstrates that while a mixed inflaton-curvaton scenario within a SUSY GUT is theoretically appealing—solving multiple high-energy physics problems simultaneously—it is not preferred by cosmological observations. The WMAP data suggests that the perturbations in our universe are dominated by the adiabatic component originating from the inflaton. Future observations with higher precision, such as those from the Planck satellite, would likely provide even tighter constraints on the isocurvature modes and non-Gaussianities predicted by such mixed models.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a simple supersymmetric grand unified model which naturally solves the strong $CP$ and $\ensuremath{\mu}$ problems via a Peccei-Quinn symmetry and leads to the standard realization of hybrid inflation. We show that the Peccei-Quinn field of this model can act as a curvaton. In contrast to the standard curvaton hypothesis, both the inflaton and the curvaton contribute to the total curvature perturbation. The model predicts the existence of an isocurvature perturbation, too, which has mixed correlation with the adiabatic one. The cold dark matter of the Universe is mostly constituted by axions, which are produced at the QCD phase transition, plus a small amount of lightest sparticles. The predictions of the model are confronted with the first-year Wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe and other cosmic microwave background radiation data. We analyze in detail two representative choices of parameters for our model and derive bounds on the curvaton contribution to the adiabatic perturbation. We find that, for the choice which provides the best fitting of the data, the curvaton contribution to the amplitude of the adiabatic perturbation must be smaller than about $67%$ and the amplitude of the partial curvature perturbation from the curvaton smaller than $43.2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}5}$ (both at $95%$ confidence level). The best-fit power spectra are dominated by the adiabatic part of the inflaton contribution. We use Bayesian model comparison to show that this choice of parameters is disfavored with respect to the pure inflaton scale-invariant case with odds of about 50 to 1. For the second choice of parameters examined, the adiabatic mode is dominated by the curvaton, but this choice is strongly disfavored relative to the pure inflaton scale-invariant case (with odds of about ${10}^{7}$ to 1). We conclude that in the present framework the perturbations must be dominated by the adiabatic component from the inflaton.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lazarides2004constraints,
  author = {G. Lazarides and Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Roberto Trotta},
  title = {{Constraints on a mixed inflaton and curvaton scenario for the generation of the curvature perturbation}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.70.123527},
}
Figure