Constraint of accessible chromatins maps regulatory loci involved in maize speciation and domestication

Y Liu, Xiang Gao, Hongjun Liu, Xuerong Yang, Xiao Liu, Fang Xu, Yuzhi Zhu, Qingyun Li, Liangliang Huang, Fang� Yang, Jinsheng Lai, Junpeng ShiNature Communications 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Comparative genomic studies can identify genes under evolutionary constraint or specialized for trait innovation. Growing evidence suggests that evolutionary constraint also acts on non-coding regulatory sequences, exerting significant impacts on fitness-related traits, although it has yet to be thoroughly explored in plants. Using the assay for transposase-accessible chromatin by sequencing (ATAC-seq), we profile over 80,000 maize accessible chromatin regions (ACRs), revealing that ACRs evolve faster than coding genes, with about one-third being maize-specific and regulating genes associated with speciation. We highlight the role of transposable elements (TEs) in driving intraspecific innovation of ACRs and identify hundreds of candidate ACRs potentially involved in transcriptional rewiring during maize domestication. Additionally, we demonstrate the importance of accessible chromatin in maintaining subgenome dominance and controlling complex trait variations. This study establishes a framework for analyzing the evolutionary trajectory of plant regulatory sequences and offers candidate loci for downstream exploration and application in maize breeding.

Introduction: The Regulatory Landscape of Maize

While protein-coding genes provide the fundamental blueprints for plant development, the "switches" that control their expression—cis-regulatory elements—remain poorly understood in complex genomes like maize. Over 85% of the maize genome consists of repetitive transposable elements (TEs), which historically complicated the identification of functional regulatory sequences. This study addresses this gap by mapping Accessible Chromatin Regions (ACRs), which represent physically "open" DNA available for transcription factor binding, to uncover how regulatory architecture drives maize evolution and domestication.

Mapping the "Switches": Methods and Datasets

To create a comprehensive regulatory map, researchers performed ATAC-seq across 12 diverse maize tissues, capturing critical developmental stages from the embryo to the shoot apical meristem.

Tissue sampling strategy for ATAC-seq across the maize life cycle, including reproductive and vegetative organs.

This effort resulted in a non-redundant map of 80,365 ACRs. To understand their evolutionary history, the team integrated these data with comparative genomics across 34 grass species (Poaceae) and 53 diverse maize reference genomes. Advanced techniques like 3D genomics (ChIA-PET and HiChIP) were used to link distal enhancers to their target genes, while GWAS integration helped connect these "open" regions to complex physical traits.

Evolutionary Dynamics and the Role of TEs

A key finding of the study is that regulatory elements evolve much faster than coding genes. Only about 1% of maize ACRs are universally constrained across the grass family, while roughly 36% are entirely maize-specific. Interestingly, transposable elements, often dismissed as "junk DNA," appear to be primary drivers of this regulatory innovation.

Genomic distribution of ACRs (genic, proximal, distal) and the contribution of various transposable element families to the regulatory landscape.

Nearly half of the maize-specific ACRs are derived from TEs, particularly the Ty3/Gypsy superfamily. These TE-derived ACRs provide a mechanism for rapid regulatory "rewiring," allowing the plant to adapt and specialize. Analysis of the distribution shows that while a significant portion of ACRs are genic, many distal and proximal elements are heavily influenced by TE insertions.

Subgenome Dominance and Domestication

Maize is a paleopolyploid, possessing two subgenomes (m1 and m2) from an ancient hybridization event. The study reveals that the dominant subgenome (m1) exhibits significantly higher chromatin accessibility and a greater density of subgenome-specific transcription factor binding sites, providing a physical basis for its higher expression levels.

Furthermore, the researchers identified 856 ACRs specifically associated with maize domestication. These regions, present in modern maize but absent in its wild relative, teosinte, are linked to critical traits such as kernel size and branching patterns. For instance, a specific ACR upstream of the bHLH68 gene was found to be fixed during domestication, playing a role in drought tolerance and growth regulation.

Conclusion

This comprehensive map of maize ACRs provides a powerful framework for studying plant regulatory evolution. While the current map is estimated to be 85% saturated, future work focusing on rare cell types and functional validation via CRISPR-Cas9 will further refine our understanding of how these genomic "switches" can be leveraged for crop improvement and breeding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Comparative genomic studies can identify genes under evolutionary constraint or specialized for trait innovation. Growing evidence suggests that evolutionary constraint also acts on non-coding regulatory sequences, exerting significant impacts on fitness-related traits, although it has yet to be thoroughly explored in plants. Using the assay for transposase-accessible chromatin by sequencing (ATAC-seq), we profile over 80,000 maize accessible chromatin regions (ACRs), revealing that ACRs evolve faster than coding genes, with about one-third being maize-specific and regulating genes associated with speciation. We highlight the role of transposable elements (TEs) in driving intraspecific innovation of ACRs and identify hundreds of candidate ACRs potentially involved in transcriptional rewiring during maize domestication. Additionally, we demonstrate the importance of accessible chromatin in maintaining subgenome dominance and controlling complex trait variations. This study establishes a framework for analyzing the evolutionary trajectory of plant regulatory sequences and offers candidate loci for downstream exploration and application in maize breeding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025constraint,
  author = {Y Liu and Xiang Gao and Hongjun Liu and Xuerong Yang and Xiao Liu and Fang Xu and Yuzhi Zhu and Qingyun Li and Liangliang Huang and Fang� Yang and Jinsheng Lai and Junpeng Shi},
  title = {{Constraint of accessible chromatins maps regulatory loci involved in maize speciation and domestication}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-57932-1},
}
Figure