Constraining torsion with Gravity Probe B

Yi Mao, Max Tegmark, Alan H. Guth, Serkan CabiPhysical 2007 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: It is well-entrenched folklore that all torsion gravity theories predict observationally negligible torsion in the solar system, since torsion (if it exists) couples only to the intrinsic spin of elementary particles, not to rotational angular momentum. We argue that this assumption has a logical loophole which can and should be tested experimentally, and consider nonstandard torsion theories in which torsion can be generated by macroscopic rotating objects. In the spirit of $\mathrm{\text{action}}=\mathrm{\text{reaction}}$, if a rotating mass like a planet can generate torsion, then a gyroscope would be expected to feel torsion. An experiment with a gyroscope (without nuclear spin) such as Gravity Probe B (GPB) can test theories where this is the case. Using symmetry arguments, we show that to lowest order, any torsion field around a uniformly rotating spherical mass is determined by seven dimensionless parameters. These parameters effectively generalize the parametrized post-Newtonian formalism and provide a concrete framework for further testing Einstein's general theory of relativity (GR). We construct a parametrized Lagrangian that includes both standard torsion-free GR and Hayashi-Shirafuji maximal torsion gravity as special cases. We demonstrate that classic solar system tests rule out the latter and constrain two observable parameters. We show that Gravity Probe B is an ideal experiment for further constraining nonstandard torsion theories, and work out the most general torsion-induced precession of its gyroscope in terms of our torsion parameters.

Introduction: Challenging the Torsion Folklore

In Einstein’s General Relativity (GR), gravity is described solely by the curvature of spacetime, while a geometric property called torsion is assumed to be zero. Standard "folklore" in physics suggests that even if torsion exists, it only couples to the intrinsic spin of elementary particles. Because the total spin of a planet like Earth is negligible compared to its mass, torsion should be observationally invisible in the solar system.

This paper identifies a logical loophole in this assumption. Following the principle of "action = reaction," if a rotating mass can generate a torsion field, then a rotating gyroscope should be able to detect it. By moving beyond the assumption that torsion only couples to microscopic spin, the authors open a new experimental window into the geometry of spacetime using macroscopic rotation as a source.

A Hierarchy of Gravity Theories

To address the lack of a rigorous experimental framework for testing torsion, the authors employ a mix of geometric modeling and phenomenological parametrization. They demonstrate that any torsion field around a uniformly rotating spherical mass is determined by exactly seven dimensionless parameters. This framework effectively extends the standard Parametrized Post-Newtonian (PPN) formalism used to test GR.

Hierarchy of metric-affine gravity theories and their constraints.

As shown in the hierarchy above, standard General Relativity (Riemannian geometry) is just one branch of a much larger family of metric-affine theories. By relaxing constraints on non-metricity ($Q$), curvature ($R$), and torsion ($S$), one can explore a variety of alternative models, such as Weitzenböck or Einstein-Weyl spaces. The authors specifically construct the Einstein-Hayashi-Shirafuji (EHS) theory as a "toy model" to interpolate between standard GR and maximal torsion theories.

Testing Non-Standard Torsion with Gravity Probe B

The primary laboratory for this investigation is the Gravity Probe B (GPB) satellite. Unlike classic solar system tests that rely on light deflection or time delay, GPB measures the precession of high-precision gyroscopes. If torsion couples to macroscopic rotation, it would manifest as an anomalous precession—a change in the direction or rate of the gyroscope's spin that GR cannot explain.

Comparison of various gravity theories, their dynamical degrees of freedom, and sources.

The table above highlights how different theories, such as Hayashi-Shirafuji or Teleparallel gravity, utilize different dynamical degrees of freedom (like tetrads or gauge fields) and sources (spin vs. rotational). By analyzing how a gyroscope moves—whether it follows autoparallels (straight paths according to the connection) or extremals (shortest paths according to the metric)—the authors can distinguish between these theoretical frameworks.

Key Results and Insights

The study yields several critical findings for experimental gravity:

  • Ruling out Maximal Torsion: Classic solar system tests, including Shapiro time delay (Cassini) and light deflection (VLBI), already rule out "maximal torsion" theories like the original Hayashi-Shirafuji model.
  • GPB Precision: Preliminary data from GPB can constrain geodetic torsion parameters to the 1% level. As data analysis matures, this precision could reach $10^{-4}$, making GPB an unparalleled "torsion laboratory."
  • Anomalous Precession: Torsion can induce precession terms that are orthogonal to those predicted by GR. These "smoking gun" signals would be definitive evidence of new physics.

Limitations and Future Scope

While the EHS model serves as a powerful pedagogical tool, the authors acknowledge it contains internal theoretical "pathologies" and should not be viewed as a final physical theory. Furthermore, there is currently no theoretical consensus on whether a rotating macroscopic object should follow an autoparallel or an extremal path in a torsion field. Future work will involve extending this seven-parameter framework to other high-gravity environments, such as binary pulsars and gravitational wave observations, to further tighten the constraints on the geometry of our universe.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is well-entrenched folklore that all torsion gravity theories predict observationally negligible torsion in the solar system, since torsion (if it exists) couples only to the intrinsic spin of elementary particles, not to rotational angular momentum. We argue that this assumption has a logical loophole which can and should be tested experimentally, and consider nonstandard torsion theories in which torsion can be generated by macroscopic rotating objects. In the spirit of $\mathrm{\text{action}}=\mathrm{\text{reaction}}$, if a rotating mass like a planet can generate torsion, then a gyroscope would be expected to feel torsion. An experiment with a gyroscope (without nuclear spin) such as Gravity Probe B (GPB) can test theories where this is the case. Using symmetry arguments, we show that to lowest order, any torsion field around a uniformly rotating spherical mass is determined by seven dimensionless parameters. These parameters effectively generalize the parametrized post-Newtonian formalism and provide a concrete framework for further testing Einstein's general theory of relativity (GR). We construct a parametrized Lagrangian that includes both standard torsion-free GR and Hayashi-Shirafuji maximal torsion gravity as special cases. We demonstrate that classic solar system tests rule out the latter and constrain two observable parameters. We show that Gravity Probe B is an ideal experiment for further constraining nonstandard torsion theories, and work out the most general torsion-induced precession of its gyroscope in terms of our torsion parameters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2007constraining,
  author = {Yi Mao and Max Tegmark and Alan H. Guth and Serkan Cabi},
  title = {{Constraining torsion with Gravity Probe B}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.76.104029},
}
Figure