Constraining the Cosmic-Ray Energy Based on Observations of Nearby Galaxy Clusters by LHAASO

Z. Cao, F Aharonian, Y. Bai, Y. W. Bao, D. Bastieri, Xiao-Jun Bi, Y. J. Bi, Weixin Bian, A.v Bukevich, Chufan Cai, Weiwei Cao, Jin Chang, A. M. Chen, E. S. Chen, H. X. Chen, Liang Chen, Long Chen, M. J. Chen, Q. H. Chen, Shaomin Chen, T. L. Chen, Xiang‐Bai Chen, Y. Chen, Ning Cheng, Y. D. Cheng, M. C. Chu, Maxwell Cui, S. W. Cui, X. H. Cui, Yongde Cui, B. Z. Dai, H. L. Dai, Z. G. Dai, Danzengluobu Danzengluobu, Yingxue Diao, X. Q. Dong, K. K. Duan, J. H. Fan, Y. Z. Fan, Jun Fang, Ke Fang, C. Feng, Hansheng Feng, Lei Feng, S. H. Feng, X. T. Feng, Y. Feng, S. Gabici, Bo Gao, C. D. Gao, Qi Gao, Wenqiang Gao, M. M. Ge, Tingting Ge, Li‐Sheng Geng, Gwenael Giacinti, G. H. Gong, Q. B. Gou, M. H. Gu, Fulai Guo, Jian‐Hua Guo, Xiaolong Guo, Y. Q. Guo, Y. A. Han, O. A. Hannuksela, M. Zahid Hasan, Han He, Hao-Ning He, Jiayu He, Xiaoying He, Y. He, S. Hernández-Cadena, Y. K. Hor, B. W. Hou, C. Hou, X. T. Hou, H. B. Hu, S. C. Hu, Chun-Hao P. Huang, D. H. Huang, J. J. Huang, T. Q. Huang, X. T. Huang, Y. Huang, X. L. Ji, H. Y. Jia, K. JiaThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses data from the LHAASO observatory to set new, model-independent upper limits on the high-energy cosmic ray (CR) content in the Coma, Perseus, and Virgo galaxy clusters. The lack of detected diffuse gamma-ray emission implies that the energy budget for CRs above 10 TeV is significantly lower than previously thought, placing tighter constraints on models of CR acceleration and propagation in these massive structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Galaxy clusters are thought to be cosmic accelerators, capable of boosting charged particles to extremely high energies (cosmic rays). When these cosmic rays interact within the cluster's gas, they can produce gamma rays. Detecting these gamma rays allows scientists to infer the energy and distribution of these cosmic rays. However, disentangling diffuse gamma-ray emission from point sources and understanding the underlying acceleration mechanisms has been challenging. This paper aims to address this by using the sensitive LHAASO observatory to search for diffuse gamma-ray emission from nearby, well-studied galaxy clusters, thereby constraining the energy density of cosmic rays within them.

Methods

The researchers employed a likelihood-fitting approach to analyze gamma-ray data from the LHAASO observatory. They modeled the expected diffuse gamma-ray emission from the Coma, Perseus, and Virgo clusters as a disk with a radius defined by R500 (a standard measure of cluster size). Crucially, they also accounted for known point sources within these regions, which could mimic diffuse emission. The spectral analysis involved testing different power-law indices for the gamma-ray emission, and the data was corrected for absorption by the extragalactic background light (EBL). The absence of significant diffuse emission allowed them to derive 95% confidence level upper limits on the gamma-ray flux. These flux limits were then translated into model-independent constraints on the integral energy of cosmic ray protons (CRp) above 10 TeV.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO). Specifically, they utilized data from:

  • WCDA (Water Cherenkov Detector Array): Covering the energy range of 1-25 TeV, with a data collection period from March 2021 to July 2023 (784 days).
  • KM2A (Kilometer Square Array): Covering energies above 25 TeV, with a data collection period from December 2019 to January 2024 (1389.5 days).

The analysis also incorporated information on known point sources within the observed regions, drawing from previous observations and alerts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tightening the Cosmic Ray Budget: The most significant insight is the stringent upper limits placed on the cosmic ray energy budget in these clusters. The lack of detected diffuse gamma-ray emission suggests that the energy stored in high-energy cosmic rays is considerably lower than some theoretical models predict.
  • Constraining Acceleration Models: The absence of characteristic "annuli" or "ring-like" structures in the gamma-ray maps, which would be indicative of cosmic ray acceleration at cluster accretion or merging shocks, provides further constraints on these models. This suggests that either the acceleration efficiency is lower than expected, or cosmic rays are escaping the clusters more readily than assumed in some scenarios.
  • Model-Independent Constraints: A key strength of this work is its ability to provide model-independent constraints on the cosmic ray energy. By directly using the observed gamma-ray flux limits, the researchers can bypass some of the uncertainties associated with specific theoretical models of cosmic ray propagation and interaction.

Key Results

  • No Significant Diffuse Emission Detected: The study found no statistically significant diffuse gamma-ray emission from the Coma, Perseus, and Virgo galaxy clusters in the observed energy ranges.
  • Gamma-Ray Flux Upper Limits: The 95% confidence level upper limits on the gamma-ray flux were derived:
  • WCDA (1-25 TeV): (49.4, 13.7, 54.0) × 10⁻¹⁴ ph cm⁻² s⁻¹ for Coma, Perseus, and Virgo, respectively.
  • KM2A (>25 TeV): (1.34, 1.14, 0.40) × 10⁻¹⁴ ph cm⁻² s⁻¹ for Coma, Perseus, and Virgo, respectively.
  • Cosmic Ray Energy Constraints: These flux limits translate to model-independent constraints on the integral energy of cosmic ray protons (CRp) above 10 TeV:
  • Less than (1.96, 0.59, 0.08) × 10⁶¹ erg for Coma, Perseus, and Virgo, respectively.
  • XCRP Constraints: The paper also provides constraints on XCRP (the ratio of cosmic ray energy to thermal energy) under various assumptions about the cosmic ray spectral index and acceleration scenarios (e.g., pp interaction, linear/nonlinear DSA). For instance, under the most stringent scenario (nonlinear DSA with a spectral index of -2.1), XCRP is constrained to be less than ~0.011 for Perseus.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Confinement Assumptions: The derived constraints are conditional on the assumption of effective cosmic ray confinement within the galaxy clusters. The paper acknowledges that propagation effects and the escape of high-energy cosmic rays could significantly alter the predicted gamma-ray spectrum, and a more comprehensive consideration of these effects will be necessary for future modeling.
  • Spatial Distribution Assumptions: The analysis assumes a spherically symmetric distribution for both cosmic rays and the intracluster medium (ICM). Deviations from this symmetry could impact the results.
  • Future Work: The authors highlight the potential for future LHAASO observations with accumulated data to further refine these constraints. They also emphasize the importance of multi-messenger observations, particularly those involving neutrinos, which can provide complementary information and offer deeper insights into the origin and acceleration of cosmic rays in galaxy clusters. The development of next-generation neutrino detectors is mentioned as a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Galaxy clusters act as reservoirs of high-energy cosmic rays (CRs). As CRs propagate through the intracluster medium, they generate diffuse γ -rays detectable by arrays such as LHAASO. These γ -rays result from proton–proton (pp) collisions of very high-energy cosmic rays or inverse Compton (IC) scattering of positron-electron pairs created by pγ interactions of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs). We analyzed diffuse γ -ray emission from the Coma, Perseus, and Virgo clusters using LHAASO data. Diffuse emission was modeled as a disk of radius R 500 for each cluster while accounting for point sources. No significant diffuse emission was detected, yielding 95% confidence level (C.L.) upper limits on the γ -ray flux: for WCDA (1–25 TeV) and KM2A (>25 TeV), less than (49.4, 13.7, 54.0) and (1.34, 1.14, 0.40) × 10 −14 ph cm −2 s −1 for Coma, Perseus, and Virgo, respectively. The γ -ray upper limits can be used to derive model-independent constraints on the integral energy of cosmic ray protons above 10 TeV (corresponding to the LHAASO observational range >1 TeV under the pp scenario) to be less than (1.96, 0.59, 0.08) × 10 61 erg. The absence of detectable annuli/ring-like structures, indicative of cluster accretion or merging shocks, imposes further constraints on models in which the UHECRs are accelerated in the merging shocks of galaxy clusters.
BibTeX
@article{cao2025constraining,
  author = {Z. Cao and F Aharonian and Y. Bai and Y. W. Bao and D. Bastieri and Xiao-Jun Bi and Y. J. Bi and Weixin Bian and A.V Bukevich and Chufan Cai and Weiwei Cao and Zhe Cao and Jin Chang and Jin Chang and A. M. Chen and E. S. Chen and H. X. Chen and Liang Chen and Long Chen and M. J. Chen and M. L. Chen and Q. H. Chen and Shaomin Chen and S. H. Chen and S. Z. Chen and T. L. Chen and Xiang‐Bai Chen and X. J. Chen and Y. Chen and Ning Cheng and Y. D. Cheng and M. C. Chu and Maxwell Cui and S. W. Cui and X. H. Cui and Yongde Cui and B. Z. Dai and H. L. Dai and Z. G. Dai and Danzengluobu Danzengluobu and Yingxue Diao and X. Q. Dong and K. K. Duan and J. H. Fan and Y. Z. Fan and Jun Fang and J. H. Fang and Ke Fang and C. Feng and Hansheng Feng and Lei Feng and S. H. Feng and X. T. Feng and Y. Feng and Y. L. Feng and S. Gabici and Bo Gao and C. D. Gao and Qi Gao and Wenqiang Gao and W. K. Gao and M. M. Ge and Tingting Ge and Li‐Sheng Geng and Gwenael Giacinti and G. H. Gong and Q. B. Gou and M. H. Gu and Fulai Guo and Jian‐Hua Guo and Xiaolong Guo and Y. Q. Guo and Y. Y. Guo and Y. A. Han and O. A. Hannuksela and M. Zahid Hasan and Han He and Hao-Ning He and Jiayu He and Xiaoying He and Y. He and S. Hernández-Cadena and Y. K. Hor and B. W. Hou and C. Hou and X. T. Hou and H. B. Hu and S. C. Hu and Chun-Hao P. Huang and D. H. Huang and J. J. Huang and T. Q. Huang and W. J. Huang and X. T. Huang and X. Y. Huang and Y. Huang and Y. Y. Huang and X. L. Ji and H. Y. Jia and K. Jia},
  title = {{Constraining the Cosmic-Ray Energy Based on Observations of Nearby Galaxy Clusters by LHAASO}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/adb97d},
}

Loading related content...

Figure