Abstract: An important tool for interpreting LHC searches for new physics are simplified models. They are characterized by a small number of parameters and thus often rely on a simplified description of particle production and decay dynamics. Considering the production of squarks of the first two generations we compare the interpretation of current LHC searches for hadronic jets plus missing energy signatures within simplified models with the interpretation within a complete supersymmetric model. Although we find sizable differences in the signal efficiencies, in particular for large supersymmetric particle masses, the differences between the mass limits derived from a simplified model and from the complete supersymmetric model are moderate given the current LHC sensitivity. We conclude that simplified models provide a reliable tool to interpret the current hadronic jets plus missing energy searches at the LHC in a more model-independent way.
Introduction
The search for Supersymmetry (SUSY) at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) involves navigating a vast parameter space. To simplify this task, experimental collaborations like ATLAS and CMS frequently employ Simplified Model Spectra (SMS). These models focus on a minimal set of new particles and decay chains, often assuming other hypothetical particles are decoupled (infinitely heavy). This paper evaluates the accuracy of these simplifications by comparing them against more complete supersymmetric models, specifically focusing on squark production of the first two generations.
Methodology: Simplified vs. Complete Models
The study contrasts two primary scenarios for squark production:
- The Simplified Model ($T2\infty$): This model assumes the gluino—the superpartner of the gluon—is decoupled. In this limit, squark production is dominated by QCD processes involving gluons and quarks.
- The Complete Model ($T2m_{\tilde{g}}$): This model incorporates a gluino with a finite mass. This allows for additional production channels, most notably the t-channel exchange of a gluino.
The researchers utilized a simulation pipeline involving MadGraph 5 for event generation, Pythia 6 for showering, and Delphes 3 for detector simulation, benchmarking their results against 8 TeV CMS data.
Production Dynamics and Signal Efficiency
A key finding is that production dynamics change significantly when the gluino mass is finite. In the complete model, squarks are not just produced in particle-antiparticle pairs. The presence of valence quarks in the proton allows for the production of squark pairs (e.g., $\tilde{u}\tilde{u}$) via gluino exchange, a channel that can dominate the total cross-section depending on the mass ratio of the gluino to the squark ($m_{\tilde{g}}/m_{\tilde{q}}$).
As shown in the figures above, while squark pair production dominates at high mass ratios, other channels like gluino-squark and gluino-gluino production become prevalent as the gluino mass decreases. These shifts in production channels lead to substantial variations in signal efficiency—the fraction of events passing experimental cuts—sometimes differing by as much as 80% between the simplified and complete models.
Robustness of Mass Exclusion Limits
Despite the large discrepancies in signal efficiency, the study reveals a surprising robustness in the final mass exclusion limits. The differences in the derived exclusion contours between the simplified and complete models were found to be moderate, typically falling within the range of standard theoretical uncertainties.
The analysis also highlighted that certain experimental variables are more resilient to model assumptions. For instance, the $\alpha_T$ variable, designed to suppress standard model backgrounds, proved more robust than the Missing Hadronic Transverse energy (MHT) variable.
Conclusion
The research concludes that simplified models remain a reliable and effective tool for interpreting LHC searches for new physics. While they do not capture every nuance of a complete supersymmetric theory, the resulting mass limits are sufficiently accurate for the current sensitivity of the LHC. As the collider moves to higher energies and luminosities, these "moderate" differences may become more critical, but for now, SMS provides a valid, model-independent framework for discovery.
Summary updated