Constraining Lorentz Invariance Violation Using the Crab Pulsar Emission Observed up to TeV Energies by MAGIC

M. L. Ahnen, Stefano Ansoldi, L. A. Antonelli, Cornelia Arcaro, A. Babić, B. Banerjee, P. Bangale, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, J. Becerra González, W. Bednarek, E. Bernardini, A. Berti, W. Bhattacharyya, B. Biasuzzi, A. Biland, O. Blanch, S. Bonnefoy, G. Bonnoli, R. Carosi, A. Carosi, A. Chatterjee, S. M. Colak, P. Colin, E. Colombo, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, S. Covino, P. Cumani, P. Da Vela, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, B. De Lotto, E. de Oña Wilhelmi, F. Di Pierro, M. Doert, A. Domínguez, D. Dominis Prester, D. Dorner, M. Doro, S. Einecke, D. Glawion, D. Elsäesser, M. Engelkemeier, V. Fallah Ramazani, A. Fernández-Barral, D. Fidalgo, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, C. Fruck, D. Galindo, R. J. Garcı́a López, M. Garczarczyk, Daniel Garrido, M. Gaug, Filippo Giammaria Praticò, N. Godinović, D. Góra, D. Guberman, D. Hadasch, A. Hahn, T. Hassan, M. Hayashida, J. Herrera, J. Hose, Dario Hrupec, Tomohiro Inada, Kazuma Ishio, Y. Konno, H. Kubo, J. Kushida, D. Kuveždić, A. La Barbera, E. Lindfors, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, Marcos López, C. Maggio, P. Majumdar, M. Makariev, G. Maneva, M. Manganaro, K. Mannheim, L. Maraschi, M. Mariotti, M. Martı́nez, D. Mazin, U. Menzel, M. Minev, R. Mirzoyan, A. Moralejo, V. Moreno, E. Moretti, V. Neustroev, A. Niedźwiecki, M. Nievas Rosillo, K. Nilsson, D. Ninci, K. Nishijima, K. NodaThe Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses data from the MAGIC telescope to set new, stringent limits on violations of Lorentz invariance, a fundamental symmetry of spacetime. By analyzing the TeV gamma-ray emission from the Crab Pulsar, the researchers found no evidence for energy-dependent delays in photon arrival times, pushing the energy scale at which such violations could occur to extremely high values.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics and Einstein's theory of General Relativity are built upon the principle of Lorentz invariance, which states that the laws of physics are the same for all observers in uniform motion. However, many theories of quantum gravity, which attempt to unify gravity with quantum mechanics, predict that this symmetry might be spontaneously broken at extremely high energies, potentially near the Planck scale (around 10^19 GeV). This breaking could manifest as a subtle energy-dependent variation in the speed of light, causing photons of different energies emitted simultaneously from a distant source to arrive at Earth at slightly different times. Detecting such a time-of-flight difference would be a direct probe of quantum gravity. Previous studies have used fast-varying sources like active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), but pulsars, with their stable and precisely timed emissions, offer a unique and complementary way to test this phenomenon. This paper aims to constrain these potential violations using the Crab Pulsar, a well-studied and bright source in the TeV gamma-ray range.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated profile likelihood method to analyze the Crab Pulsar data. This method is more powerful than simpler peak-comparison techniques because it utilizes the full information contained in the photon arrival times and energies. They defined new parameters to quantify linear and quadratic deviations from Lorentz invariance, relating them to an effective quantum gravity energy scale ($E_{QG}$). The core of the method involves constructing a likelihood function that describes the probability of observing the data given a specific model of photon arrival times, including potential Lorentz invariance violating (LIV) effects and various nuisance parameters (like the pulsar's spectral shape and instrumental effects). A test statistic, $D_n$, was then used to quantify the significance of any observed LIV effect. Crucially, the paper dedicates significant effort to calibrating this test statistic through extensive Monte Carlo simulations to understand its bias and coverage properties, ensuring the reliability of the derived limits. They also meticulously accounted for various systematic uncertainties, such as background estimation, energy and flux scale variations, and potential variations in the pulsar's pulse shape.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the MAGIC (Major Atmospheric Gamma-ray Imaging Cherenkov) telescope, specifically observations of the Crab Pulsar (PSR J0534+2200). The data spans multiple years of observation, totaling over 1000 hours, and covers reconstructed photon energies up to TeV. The analysis focused on events with energies above 400 GeV, with a secondary analysis considering events down to 100 GeV. The paper also references and compares its results with existing limits from other sources, notably GRBs (specifically GRB090510), and AGNs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pulsars as stable LIV probes: The study reinforces the value of pulsars as stable, precisely timed sources for LIV tests, offering a complementary approach to transient sources like AGNs and GRBs. Their continuous emission allows for systematic improvement of limits over time.
  • The importance of pulse shape modeling: The paper highlights that the precise shape of the pulsar's emission profile, especially at lower energies (below 400 GeV), is crucial for obtaining the most stringent limits. Uncertainties in this modeling can significantly impact the derived constraints.
  • Calibration is key: A substantial portion of the work is dedicated to rigorously calibrating the statistical methods used. This includes understanding and mitigating bias and ensuring accurate coverage of confidence intervals, which is vital for robust scientific claims.
  • Systematic uncertainties matter: The inclusion of systematic uncertainties, which are often overlooked or less rigorously treated in some studies, is shown to worsen the statistical limits, underscoring the need for their careful consideration.

Key Results

  • No significant LIV detected: The analysis found no statistically significant variation in the arrival times of gamma-ray photons from the Crab Pulsar as a function of their energy, above 400 GeV.
  • Stringent limits on LIV energy scale:
    • For a linear energy-dependent LIV scenario, the 95% confidence level (CL) limit on the effective quantum gravity energy scale ($E_{QG1}$) is $5.5 \times 10^{17}$ GeV (subluminal) and $4.5 \times 10^{17}$ GeV (superluminal).
  • For a quadratic energy-dependent LIV scenario, the 95% CL limit ($E_{QG2}$) is $5.9 \times 10^{10}$ GeV (subluminal) and $5.3 \times 10^{10}$ GeV (superluminal).
  • Improved limits: These limits are about a factor of four to five better than those obtained using a simpler peak-comparison method on the same data. They also improve upon previous Crab Pulsar LIV limits by a factor of three for the linear case and an order of magnitude for the quadratic case.
  • Systematic uncertainties impact limits: Including systematic uncertainties worsened the statistical limits by about 36-42%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pulse shape uncertainty below 400 GeV: The paper acknowledges that a more detailed understanding of the Crab Pulsar's intrinsic pulse shape, particularly for energies between 200 and 400 GeV, would allow for the inclusion of more data and lead to significantly more competitive limits.
  • Potential for improvement with more data: The authors suggest that with more observation time (e.g., 2000 hours of stereo data), the sensitivity could be improved by a factor of two, potentially reaching world-best constraints for the quadratic LIV case.
  • Better modeling of source physics: Further theoretical work on the emission mechanisms of pulsars and their potential energy-dependent effects is needed to disentangle intrinsic source physics from potential LIV effects.
  • Distance uncertainty: Uncertainties in the distance to the Crab Pulsar also contribute to the overall uncertainty in the derived limits. Future precise measurements from missions like Gaia could help mitigate this.
  • Asymmetric pulse shapes: While explored, the impact of asymmetric pulse shapes on LIV limits was not fully incorporated due to the lack of definitive evidence for such asymmetry at these energies. Future data might clarify this.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Spontaneous breaking of Lorentz symmetry at energies on the order of the Planck energy or lower is predicted by many quantum gravity theories, implying non-trivial dispersion relations for the photon in vacuum. Consequently, gamma-rays of different energies, emitted simultaneously from astrophysical sources, could accumulate measurable differences in their time of flight until they reach the Earth. Such tests have been carried out in the past using fast variations of gamma-ray flux from pulsars, and more recently from active galactic nuclei and gamma-ray bursts. We present new constraints studying the gamma-ray emission of the galactic Crab Pulsar, recently observed up to TeV energies by the Major Atmospheric Gamma-ray Imaging Cherenkov (MAGIC) collaboration. A profile likelihood analysis of pulsar events reconstructed for energies above 400 GeV finds no significant variation in arrival time as their energy increases. Ninety-five percent CL limits are obtained on the effective Lorentz invariance violating energy scale at the level of ( ) for a linear, and ( ) for a quadratic scenario, for the subluminal and the superluminal cases, respectively. A substantial part of this study is dedicated to calibration of the test statistic, with respect to bias and coverage properties. Moreover, the limits take into account systematic uncertainties, which are found to worsen the statistical limits by about 36%–42%. Our constraints would have been much more stringent if the intrinsic pulse shape of the pulsar between 200 GeV and 400 GeV was understood in sufficient detail and allowed inclusion of events well below 400 GeV.
BibTeX
@article{ahnen2017constraining,
  author = {M. L. Ahnen and Stefano Ansoldi and L. A. Antonelli and Cornelia Arcaro and A. Babić and B. Banerjee and P. Bangale and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and J. Becerra González and W. Bednarek and E. Bernardini and A. Berti and W. Bhattacharyya and B. Biasuzzi and A. Biland and O. Blanch and S. Bonnefoy and G. Bonnoli and R. Carosi and A. Carosi and A. Chatterjee and S. M. Colak and P. Colin and E. Colombo and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and S. Covino and P. Cumani and P. Da Vela and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and B. De Lotto and E. de Oña Wilhelmi and F. Di Pierro and M. Doert and A. Domínguez and D. Dominis Prester and D. Dorner and M. Doro and S. Einecke and D. Glawion and D. Elsäesser and M. Engelkemeier and V. Fallah Ramazani and A. Fernández-Barral and D. Fidalgo and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and C. Fruck and D. Galindo and R. J. Garcı́a López and M. Garczarczyk and Daniel Garrido and M. Gaug and Filippo Giammaria Praticò and N. Godinović and D. Góra and D. Guberman and D. Hadasch and A. Hahn and T. Hassan and M. Hayashida and J. Herrera and J. Hose and Dario Hrupec and Tomohiro Inada and Kazuma Ishio and Y. Konno and H. Kubo and J. Kushida and D. Kuveždić and A. La Barbera and E. Lindfors and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and Marcos López and C. Maggio and P. Majumdar and M. Makariev and G. Maneva and M. Manganaro and K. Mannheim and L. Maraschi and M. Mariotti and M. Martı́nez and D. Mazin and U. Menzel and M. Minev and R. Mirzoyan and A. Moralejo and V. Moreno and E. Moretti and V. Neustroev and A. Niedźwiecki and M. Nievas Rosillo and K. Nilsson and D. Ninci and K. Nishijima and K. Noda},
  title = {{Constraining Lorentz Invariance Violation Using the Crab Pulsar Emission Observed up to TeV Energies by MAGIC}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4365/aa8404},
}
Figure