Constraining heavy dark matter with cosmic-ray antiprotons

A. Cuoco, Jan Heisig, Michael Korsmeier, Michael KrämerJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Cosmic-ray observations provide a powerful probe of dark matter annihilation in the Galaxy. In this paper we derive constraints on heavy dark matter from the recent precise AMS-02 antiproton data. We consider all possible annihilation channels into pairs of standard model particles. Furthermore, we interpret our results in the context of minimal dark matter, including higgsino, wino and quintuplet dark matter. We compare the cosmic-ray antiproton limits to limits from $\gamma$-ray observations of dwarf spheroidal galaxies and to limits from $\gamma$-ray and $\gamma$-line observations towards the Galactic center. While the latter limits are highly dependent on the dark matter density distribution and only exclude a thermal wino for cuspy profiles, the cosmic-ray limits are more robust, strongly disfavoring the thermal wino dark matter scenario even for a conservative estimate of systematic uncertainties.

The Challenge of Robust Dark Matter Detection

While the existence of dark matter (DM) is well-established through its gravitational effects, its fundamental particle nature remains one of the biggest mysteries in modern physics. A leading candidate is the Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP), which could reveal itself by annihilating into Standard Model particles, creating a detectable flux of "indirect" signals like gamma rays, neutrinos, and cosmic-ray antiprotons.

Historically, gamma-ray observations of the Galactic Center have set the most stringent limits on DM annihilation. However, these constraints are highly sensitive to the assumed dark matter density profile. If the Galactic Center has a "cuspy" profile (like NFW), the limits are strong; if it has a "cored" profile (like Burkert), the limits weaken significantly. This paper addresses this "brittleness" by utilizing high-precision antiproton data from the AMS-02 experiment, which provides constraints that are far more robust against uncertainties in the Galactic DM distribution.

Methodology: A Global Fit of Cosmic-Ray Data

The researchers performed a comprehensive global fit of cosmic-ray data to derive these new limits. The analysis integrated several key components:

  • Propagation Modeling: Using the GALPROP code, the team simulated the transport of protons, helium, and antiprotons through the Milky Way's magnetic fields and interstellar medium.
  • Statistical Inference: They employed MultiNest to explore a 16-dimensional parameter space, accounting for uncertainties in injection spectra and propagation variables.
  • Electroweak Corrections: For heavy DM at the TeV scale, the radiation of $W$ and $Z$ bosons from primary annihilation products becomes significant. Including these corrections is crucial, as it allows even leptonic annihilation channels to produce a measurable antiproton signal.
  • Conservative Limits: To ensure robustness, the authors used a profile likelihood approach, marginalizing over propagation uncertainties to derive 95% confidence level upper limits on the annihilation cross-section $\langle \sigma v \rangle$.

Results: Stringent Limits Across All Channels

The study evaluated DM annihilation into a wide array of Standard Model pairs, including leptons, neutrinos, quarks, and gauge bosons. Across almost all channels, the antiproton limits derived from AMS-02 data are significantly more restrictive than those from gamma-ray observations of dwarf spheroidal galaxies (dSphs).

Figure 2: Upper limits on the dark matter annihilation cross-section for various channels, comparing cosmic-ray (CR) antiproton data (blue) with gamma-ray observations of dwarf spheroidal galaxies (red dashed).

As shown in the multi-panel figure above, the cosmic-ray limits (blue lines) consistently fall below the dSph limits (red dashed lines) for DM masses between 200 GeV and 50 TeV. This demonstrates that antiprotons are currently the most sensitive probe for heavy DM in many scenarios.

The Thermal Wino and the Advantage of Antiprotons

One of the most significant findings of this research is the strong constraint placed on the "thermal wino"—a popular TeV-scale dark matter candidate in supersymmetric models. The thermal wino, with a mass of approximately 2.8 TeV, primarily annihilates into $W^+W^-$ pairs.

Figure 1: Comparison of cosmic-ray antiproton limits and dSph limits for the $W^+W^-/ZZ$ annihilation channel. The CR limits strongly disfavor the thermal wino cross-section.

While gamma-ray limits from the Galactic Center can only exclude the thermal wino if a cuspy DM profile is assumed, the antiproton limits are stable. Even with conservative estimates for systematic uncertainties, the thermal wino is strongly disfavored by the AMS-02 data. Similarly, the study finds narrow exclusion windows for quintuplet DM around its thermal mass (~9.4 TeV), while Higgsino DM remains largely unconstrained due to its much lower annihilation cross-section.

Limitations and Future Outlook

Despite the unprecedented precision of the AMS-02 data, the analysis is currently limited by systematic uncertainties rather than statistical ones. The two primary bottlenecks are:

  1. Propagation Parameters: Uncertainties in how cosmic rays diffuse through the Galaxy still impact the final limits.
  2. Production Cross-Sections: The precision of the $p + p \rightarrow \bar{p} + X$ cross-section measurements in laboratory settings needs to improve to further refine the background model.

Future measurements from experiments like LHCb are expected to provide better data on these production cross-sections, which will allow for even more precise and robust dark matter searches using cosmic-ray antiprotons.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cosmic-ray observations provide a powerful probe of dark matter annihilation in the Galaxy. In this paper we derive constraints on heavy dark matter from the recent precise AMS-02 antiproton data. We consider all possible annihilation channels into pairs of standard model particles. Furthermore, we interpret our results in the context of minimal dark matter, including higgsino, wino and quintuplet dark matter. We compare the cosmic-ray antiproton limits to limits from \\(\\gamma\\)-ray observations of dwarf spheroidal galaxies and to limits from \\(\\gamma\\)-ray and \\(\\gamma\\)-line observations towards the Galactic center. While the latter limits are highly dependent on the dark matter density distribution and only exclude a thermal wino for cuspy profiles, the cosmic-ray limits are more robust, strongly disfavoring the thermal wino dark matter scenario even for a conservative estimate of systematic uncertainties.
BibTeX
@article{cuoco2018constraining,
  author = {A. Cuoco and Jan Heisig and Michael Korsmeier and Michael Krämer},
  title = {{Constraining heavy dark matter with cosmic-ray antiprotons}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2018/04/004},
}
Figure